I respectfully disagree and I will explain why:
I do not dislike the principle of a sluth path, not at all. Actually, the slut path was my main playthrough until the club blowjob scene in Chapter 10.
I thought the first ONS with Mike was hot, I thought Lena waking up Jeremy was hot, I thought cheating on Ian with Axel the first time was hot, damn, I even thought sex with Robert after the date with Ian was hot.
To me, there was a turning point on the slut path, one sentence announcing the downfall and EK losing her shit on the slut path, during the toilets blowjob to Mark:
"One more seed I had conquered".
Damn, this was the most ridiculous line in the history of AVNs - until the "gimme ur alpha cock" of the Jack scene that is.
Since then, the slut path has been increasingly boring and mediocre. I wish it had not been. It is.
That said, I do agree that it is poorly written only in absolute terms, but that when you compare it to not just 95% but 99,9% of other AVNs it is still superior.