Zara Scarlet
Engaged Member
- Apr 3, 2022
- 2,861
- 3,905
- 422
I'm not pretending anything. All I'm talking about is facts, and what you're talking about are possibilities. The reality is that Lena and Ian did do those things, whereas what you're suggesting about Ivy might have have happened, if your hypothesis is correct, and there's no guarantee that it is. There is likely a very high probability that Ivy is a very promiscuous person, and if you could see everything that goes on in her life, maybe you could come to a different conclusion. But we can't, and therefore we cannot say that she is the most promiscuous person in this game, with any degree of accuracy. You pretty much acknowledge that above. But you're never going to agree with me, because you're talking about something completely different to me. What I'm talking about, relates to the original comment that I made, and what you're talking about, is what other people have introduced into this discussion.By your premise, we might as well assume that Lena's brother is a upstanding politician, or that Gillian's boyfriend is Tony Soprano, because they've never been shown to do anything in the game that we've been told about them, and in your scenario we completely ignore context clues to the contrary.
Ivy is not forthcoming. We can tell that from how she keeps information from Lena about both Axel and Mike, and maybe others that I'm not even remembering. When Lena confronts her over Mike, Lena is able to guess, correctly, that they hooked up because Ivy says that she and Mike get along. Lena, her best friend, who knows Ivy best, understands that when she gets along with a guy, they hook up.
Pretending that she's not promiscuous simply because she's not a POV character is absurd. Lena and Ian would have to follow her around, tied at her hip, to reach the burden of proof of her promiscuity that you're asking for.
In any case, it doesn't matter who started the game as the most promiscuous person, because it's fairly clear that Lena will end up occupying that position by the end of it, if you allow her to. Just like Ashley eventually superceded Jessica in Good Girl Gone Bad. And it's becoming increasingly clear that slutty Holly (who is modelling herself on Ivy and the sluttier version of Lena) won't be that far behind.
Last edited: