Romance her and don't mess up the relationship with her and Ian, then she won't fuck Axel. There are two differing versions where you either trust her or set boundaries in which case she's more daring when working with him if you do not. If Wade breaks up with Cindy she doesn't fuck Axel either.
In the game's routing it recognizes three different paths to Cindy/Axel with various conditions I believe, though it's been a while since I looked into it, wherein all she seems to fuck him. Though it has of course not actually been confirmed.
So three where she fucks him and three where she don't. Half.
Given her popularity I understand why. Cindy's got some interesting elements to her route that makes her an engaging prospect I think. She's hot, somewhat of a forbidden fruit, and has some moral questions to her route. There's a bit to enjoy for most I guess.
I admit I had completely forgotten the path where Wade breaks up with Cindy himself. Probably because I don't pay much attention to this plot in the game as I don't find it interesting, so when I replay the game, at times I get Wade breaking up with Cindy, and others Cindy hooking up with Axel, and I have absolutely no idea on the choices I have made which lead to one outcome or the other (tbh...I don't really care).
However, I really have a hard time identifying the "interesting elements" making her "engaging":
- She's hot ok, that's why I mentioned her as a potential FMF candidate with my loyal Ian/Lena.
- Ok I get the "forbidden fruit" aspect, it is interesting....for exactly one second and a half.
Then what ?
Let's look at her from the start of the game:
- She's a rich girl working for her papa
- She's the kind of people who grabs stuff for free from her poorer friends, but rarely offers anything to them (beer etc.)
- She's not a good sport, super competitive even on the most silly games, and a VERY bad loser
- She does not know anything - and is no that interested - in arts, culture, politics, in anything
- She admires the bimbo influencers on instagram and tik tok pretty candidly
- She cheats on her boyfriend in almost any instance
- Before that, she is stupid enough to publish her naked pics before even having told her boyfriend about the shooting
- She doesn't cheat on her new boyfriend only if he has discplined her and put her on a leash
=> frankly, to me Cindy is just a blonde Kim Kardashian wannabe.