VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Up 4 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[CAznable]

I'm only in the first part of the game, Veronica and Lucy going head to head. I know as people have said It would be a massive effort having Lucy win and writing out all that and it was meant for Veronica to be set up/established or whatever, but I wont lie its a damn shame. Everyone has there own preferences I get it, just so happens muscular women are a big turn off for me, real shame.

Preferences are preferences. luckily for you the rest of the 5 Main Girls are not built like Vero. I'd still encourage you to give her a chance as you play more. All the main girls have varying and interesting personalities.

 

[RJ940]

Preferences are preferences. luckily for you the rest of the 5 Main Girls are not built like Vero. I'd still encourage you to give her a chance as you play more. All the main girls have varying and interesting personalities.

I'll definitely keep an open mind for sure, I won't let it cloud my overall judgment of the game by any means! I'm enjoying it so far, plan to basically binge play it tonight.

 

[UnoriginalUserName]

I'll definitely keep an open mind for sure, I won't let it cloud my overall judgment of the game by any means! I'm enjoying it so far, plan to basically binge play it tonight.

PC is easily top-tier, you won't regret it.

 

[Tokenugget]

During the Elias Ford interview... he says he found a new rising star that just auditioned and was as a shoe-in for a popular TV show.. Is that going to be Mina? She just auditioned and was given the job before even leaving. Although, he says some drama superficial drama was started with that "star" so i don't believe that could be Mina. She's not one to create drama there.

Thoughts?

 

[Holdem High]

I know maybe not the most appropriate thread for this question but I know I will find like minded folks here. This game and Being a Dik are my favourites by far, mostly because the story and the sex scenes link in so logically well together that it makes the games extremely hot to play. A lot of games have some sudden sex scenes that may or may not look good, but don't feel hot or sexy at all.

Considering the above, are there other games people would recommend?

 

[ValeriaEx]

I know maybe not the most appropriate thread for this question but I know I will find like minded folks here. This game and Being a Dik are my favourites by far, mostly because the story and the sex scenes link in so logically well together that it makes the games extremely hot to play. A lot of games have some sudden sex scenes that may or may not look good, but don't feel hot or sexy at all.

Considering the above, are there other games people would recommend?

What are you actually kind of into? Femdom? Maledom? SM? NTR?

 

[Kinky Bully]

I know maybe not the most appropriate thread for this question but I know I will find like minded folks here. This game and Being a Dik are my favourites by far, mostly because the story and the sex scenes link in so logically well together that it makes the games extremely hot to play. A lot of games have some sudden sex scenes that may or may not look good, but don't feel hot or sexy at all.

Considering the above, are there other games people would recommend?

If you like HS(Honeyselect) art and love good stories try these:
Pale Carnations
Once in a lifetime
Bound by lust
Ripples
A house in the rift
New games:
Eternum (Best hs2 renders/graphics)
Desire of Fate (Best hs1 renders/graphics)

 

[claus001]

If you like HS(Honeyselect) art and love good stories try these:
Pale Carnations
Once in a lifetime
Bound by lust
Ripples
A house in the rift
New games:
Eternum (Best hs2 renders/graphics)
Desire of Fate (Best hs1 renders/graphics)

Nice list.

 

[RoamingZone]

You now apart from the story going pretty well so far I can't stop but to think if the game will have some sort of bad endings when finished, will MC involve himself to deep in this new world for trying to help the girls? will he step on some toes because of this? make some enemies?

Of course I don't want spoilers, just wanna see what other people think about. Btw don't know if this has been asked before in this thread so if it has my apologize.

 

[gears]

You now apart from the story going pretty well so far I can't stop but to think if the game will have some sort of bad endings when finished, will MC involve himself to deep in this new world for trying to help the girls? will he step on some toes because of this? make some enemies?

Of course I don't want spoilers, just wanna see what other people think about. Btw don't know if this has been asked before in this thread so if it has my apologize.

They had better have "Bad" endings because they are often the most entertaining ones . weather it be individual bad endings for girls or an MC who becomes morally corrupt both would be great to see and be extended on.

 

[Poser_Voyeur]

I'm only in the first part of the game, Veronica and Lucy going head to head. I know as people have said It would be a massive effort having Lucy win and writing out all that and it was meant for Veronica to be set up/established or whatever, but I wont lie its a damn shame. Everyone has there own preferences I get it, just so happens muscular women are a big turn off for me, real shame.

I can agree that for me personally. I wanted Lucy to win that head to had for the final slot as Carnation. But I realised soon into playing that that was merely setting up the story that devs wanted to tell.

My one big disapointment with Lucy is that Edwin did nt have a chance to do more to/with Lucy. I would have loved it if Kathleen had dangled the carrot to Edwin of corrupting Lucy to see how far down the rabbithole he would go.....

If it was me, I would have gone all the way!!

I would have loved Edwin have the chance to introduce Lucy to anal sex and swallowing, buut plogs and vibrators (maybe at the same time) and just turned her into a total fuck bunny. But that is just me and I admit I do have a bit of a thing for Lucy out of all the girls we have met so far.

With the rest of the girls, I am not yet sure which of the Carnations I want to win. I lean most toards Rosalind because of the parallels between her and the MC's mother - she NEEDS the help more but then she has played Edwin with sex. Felicia is the hottest of the 3 IMO (the pictures of her and Mina attaracted me to start the game in the first place) but I think we have only just started unwrapping the onion that is Felicia's reasons for wanting to join the club. I might sway more her way as we learn more about her. I am least drawn to Veronica (in part because I wanted more Lucy) but I still hope we can help her get her gym back.

 

[selberdreher]

You now apart from the story going pretty well so far I can't stop but to think if the game will have some sort of bad endings when finished, will MC involve himself to deep in this new world for trying to help the girls? will he step on some toes because of this? make some enemies?

Of course I don't want spoilers, just wanna see what other people think about. Btw don't know if this has been asked before in this thread so if it has my apologize.

Bad Endings were kind of confirmed in this post from dev:

Yes, there's **at least* a couple of bad endings already in the outline, with maybe more if we find places to put good ones.
Personally I'm a HUGE fan of bad endings in visual novels, provided they're done right. That is, if they actually enhance the story and provide additional information/context to the setting as a whole. (...)

I love, love, LOVE bad endings that go beyond fade-to-black-you-fucked-up and hope to include some good ones down the road.

Regarding your other questions, there were indeed already a lot of theories about potential outcomes made in this thread, some of them rather lengthy and detailed, and therefore a bit much to repeat here.
If you are interested, i would advise you to skim through the thread and read a few of them. And of course you are very much welcome to comment on those theories and add your own two cents.

My personal short answers to your three questions are:

"(...)will MC involve himself to deep in this new world for trying to help the girls?" - Yes
"will he step on some toes because of this?" - Yes
"make some enemies?" - Yes

depending on your playstyle and choices of course.

In my opinion there is still a possibility to remain perfectly neutral, but this would be a challenge of its own, because you need to wiggle your way through various diverging interests without pissing of one of the parties too much. Personally i think it is more likely that you are forced to choose a side sooner or later and thus inevitably make some enemies.

oh, and by the way, the definition of a "bad ending" is also very much open to your own interpretation, for instance guiding Mina callously through her "bucket list" and "helping" her with the more extreme "tasks" could end her very much as a degraded cumrag, which i definetly would count as a bad ending for her, but ...

its also kind of hot...

 

[Sasarko99]

So I'm still not sure what to expect from the game content-wise, I'm mostly interested in femdom at least in my first run, so I would like to hear people who played this game.
Which characters have femdom content?
I suspect Hanna given the anger variable but I doubt it, probably gonna try to keep her calm from doing something stupid is my guess, Kat seems like the most likely candidate but her variable is trust, and Veronica has horniness and seems to possibly be lesbian (maybe bi?) I guess she's for those who want to break a strong woman maybe even "turn her straight"?
Can you pursue multiple characters at once without them clashing?

 

[Turret]

Can you pursue multiple characters at once without them clashing?

Currently you can pursue several characters at once without too much trouble. That will change somewhere near the end the latest, since PC is not a harem game. You will have to pick your special sweetheart and you have the option (if you were not a complete douche or sadist) to part with some girls you did not chose in a friendly way. Others, well...

 

[Kinky Bully]

Which characters have femdom content?

Veronica(The redhead bodybuilder) has a lot of femdom content.

 

[TD1900]

So I'm still not sure what to expect from the game content-wise, I'm mostly interested in femdom at least in my first run, so I would like to hear people who played this game.
Which characters have femdom content?

To be honest, if femdom is your primary interest, you will find the content lacking. There's a few light splashes of it here and there (I'd say about 2 or 3 scenes as of now), but the tag on the site was added due to the lezdom content.

 

[RJ940]

PC is easily top-tier, you won't regret it.

Wow... that was, an experience. Just this second finished the current content and you were absolutely right. What a fucking game, genuinely did not want it to end and that is a major feat for my short attention span pea brain.

 

[TheSmoothCriminal]

Absolutely loving the game so far but holy hell do I just feel fucking... "Icky" while playing

Keep it up dev, you do damn good work

 

[mrdanaris]

this one would fit greatly in that list

https://f95zone.to/threads/harem-hotel-v0-15-1-public-runey.12760/

Harem hotel has an amazing story and a lot of great characters and about 40 hours +of content

 

[dreamgoat]

Yeah. Amazing that. Women working in a sex club being shared.

lol good point