Nope. I daresay the opposite.
Same question, Hana is on the fuckbuddy path, Mina has lesbian points, but I got in trouble with Mina instead. Is there supposed to be convo prior where you tell Mina about Hana?
I was on the Hana gf path, I haven’t tried fuck buddy path yet. I even told Mina about the date which was planned with Hana before going on the date
There's option when you are about to go on a date with Hana to be "fully transparent" about it with Mina. Pretty obvious choice if you remember what behavior got Ian in hot water with her.
el oh el. You really don't understand why you'd get in trouble with Mina if she finds out that you are (still) trying to fuck around with her when Hana is your actual girlfriend, as opposed to just a friend with benefits? Especially when, if you tell Mina about your date with Hana earlier, Mina asks you not to double-time Hana?
Directly from the horse's mouth: https://f95zone.to/threads/pale-carnations-ch-4-up-5-mutt-jeff.50281/post-15768937
Exactly what ffive said: you should have told her, bro.
Nope. The more the story moves forward, the more everything is telling us that he didn't deserve her.
I checked, it really is. Oh, how I wish Ren'Py had the ability to somehow hide this information from players, I think the games would be more interesting
That's the beauty of this game, that it gives you the opportunity to go down different paths and have different perspectives. If you go down a certain path, you can't project it onto other paths.
Well, you make her really happy. Isn't it good enough?
Well, the advantage is that Hana is your GF.
Also means I'd be cheating on her, with Rosalind, Mina, Felicia, etc. Which makes you no better than Ian. Also makes you think, Hana isn't that good at picking boyfriendsWell, the advantage is that Hana is your GF.
This has some dedicated text variants, like Edwin telling his mom about it at the cinema, and in some other places.
I still have an eye for Mina. Right now leaning towards Hana but i wanna see what Mina has to offer.This is probably an unpopular opinion, but as much as I like Mina, she disappears from my LI's radar after this update (in my main playthrough). It's obvious that Mina and Ian could get back together, especially if Ian goes the introspective route. As we know, Ian loves to "test the limits of others" and that didn't work out with Mina. He also can't believe that despite his behavior, Mina can still like him (for other reasons, of course). And now this internal conflict haunts him.
I also really like Ian's trait where he doesn't ask Edwin unnecessary questions, reading his mood in serious situations. Having friends like that is rare.
There's a reason Mina has a "Killian Romance" stat.
I also wouldn't want a repeat of Marlow's story
Well, sorry, but NO.
as Otto said, you can be faithful barring club events, which is agreed upon with Hana. She may not like it, but it is what it is. Even some choices leading up to cheating have some inner monologue by the MC. Also there is a cheating counter as well iirc, so if any club events do have that flag I'll just avoid those (e.g. you could fuck a house girl, but that's not really carnation business is it, I would consider that cheating even if it happened technically in the club)
