VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.5 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[Dactess]

I prefer the three Carnations (Felicia being my favorite) over Mina and Hana, their stories hit harder. While I know they'll likely have some content involving patrons, I personally don’t mind (too much ) .

I kind of want to wait and see how things progress before I decide to commit to Felicia but Her Mina and Hana are my favs for their own reasons. Though Andrea is up there now lol I liked Felicia's character pretty early on but that art exhibit and romantic evening kind of made me fall hard for her lol It was great. I could be way off but it's nice kind of reintroducing love into her life, also kind of gives off like Aladdin and a "whole new world" vibes... at least that is what I think of, well with more sex I guess.

I like Rosie and Veronica's characters but they aren't really Love Interests for me. And well Kathleen is a sadistic sociopathic bitch that's like 57 so a bit too old.

I'm not looking forward to the other exhibitions to say the least but I've had time to come to terms with it I guess... So following her path depends on if my vanilla ass can stomach it

 

[Silegy]

Kathleen is like 57 so a bit too old.

Now, now, age is just a number.

 

[Ozymandias037]

Most likely, I already know the answers to all my questions, but I'm trying to hold on to a non-existent thread that might lead to a happy ending in this story. This really is a brothel game, with all the scenarios that come with that.

I'm with you. I am still hoping for happy endings possible for each LI -- but I don't think there's any possible way this ends well for everyone. No matter who wins, there are absolutely some people who will lose.

 

[prpa]

Oh you saying that now and when I said it will not end well for everyone you said I am being too forward in what I was claiming it's gonna end in, considering how Lucy end up dumped as a whore in the club after not saving herself as a carnation, I am pretty sure only the winner carnation will be the one to have a somewhat of a happy ending and that could be a bad ending for someone considering what this game considers as a happy ending might not be parallel with what all the players playing it might consider. The other 2 carnations will be the house girls that's how it's gonna end. It's a sad sob story and only the ones who can take pleasure from that can enjoy it.

Wilhelms, is that you? Long time no see.

 

[Dactess]

Oh you saying that now and when I said it will not end well for everyone you said I am being too forward in what I was claiming it's gonna end in, considering how Lucy end up dumped as a whore in the club after not saving herself as a carnation, I am pretty sure only the winner carnation will be the one to have a somewhat of a happy ending and that could be a bad ending for someone considering what this game considers as a happy ending might not be parallel with what all the players playing it might consider. The other 2 carnations will be the house girls that's how it's gonna end. It's a sad sob story and only the ones who can take pleasure from that can enjoy it.

I mean maybe Rosie would be willing or need to become a house girl to pay off her debt (assuming she has it still, 20k isn't too bad lol) but I don't really see Felicia going that route win or lose, and well same with Veronica. She is doing it for the chance at quick cash. If she loses she will probably just back out and declare bankruptcy, take the hit and start anew and on a smaller scale.

That's assuming drama doesn't hit the club, I am guessing we are in for some revelations that will shake things up and ultimately Edwin ( you ) will probably have a hand in how things play out for the carnations.

 

[lustforsex]

Wilhelms dislikes this game so much (but I suspect it's just words) that after creating a new account, he leaves his first message in this thread. This game simply doesn't give him peace of mind. Isn't this game a masterpiece?

 

[Dactess]

I don't think I have ever actually looked at the ratings for this game, or many others. Easy enough to find out if it is good or not. Plus it is hard to trust reviews on this site, if an AVN has another male character ppl will give it 1 star for NTR. Hyperbolic but still.

Case in point "it's the best game for a closet cuck?"

 

[pinuz1]

Wilhelms, is that you? Long time no see.

Took him less than a day to make another account , it's incredible how this game lives rent free on his head, he even made a cute thread complaining about the reviews, he's in love with this game one way or another .

just mass report him and move on.

 

[Ozymandias037]

Like... I don't mind when people have different opinions from me on gender roles, kinks, even actual relevant things like writing, plot, etc. But I absolutely cannot imagine being so butthurt over a porn game as to create multiple accounts and just continue bashing one's head against a wall over it.

I get posts deleted sometimes for being off-topic or replying to other deleted posts or whatever, just like everyone else who participates in an active thread like this. Sometimes I disagree with mod decisions, or get cranky because my post is nearly identical to a different one that doesn't get deleted. But that's life, and it's not a big deal. I can't imagine devoting this much time and energy to being mad on the Internet.

 

[Dactess]

https://f95zone.to/threads/manipulation-of-ratings-on-threads-like-pale-carnations.256255/

Took him less than a day to make another account , it's incredible how this game lives rent free on his head, he even made a cute thread complaining about the reviews, he's in love with this game one way or another .

just mast report him and move on.

Can't blame him, I can't say that it lives in my head rent free considering I sometimes pay them but it's such a great game I can understand why he keeps coming back for more.

 

[Turret]

Took him less than a day to make another account , it's incredible how this game lives rent free on his head, he even made a cute thread complaining about the reviews, he's in love with this game one way or another .

just mast report him and move on.

Yes, I went over there and had a laugh. Personal moderation, four 1 star reviews removed, further rants, other alu hat ideas, this guy is , hmm, let´s say "special".

 

[ImlerithRate]

So guys is this vn punishes the player for going all main girls routes at once or still not? Played long ago and now curious

 

[Turret]

So guys is this vn punish the player for going all main girls routes at once or still not? Played long ago and now curious

While you currently can pursue all possible LI´s simultaniously, it has been massively hinted at that it will not end pretty for you going Alpha Harem. At the end of the game or a bit before the end you WILL HAVE TO choose 1 special LI, there will be no harems in PC. You can have friendly relations with all possible LIs, but you will have to choose one for a longterm relationship only.

 

[pinuz1]

So guys is this vn punishes the player for going all main girls routes at once or still not? Played long ago and now curious

Nothing so far, the game is keeping track if you've cheated on Hana tho, so it's coming sooner than later, but only if you've made the choice of commiting to Hana gf instead of staying as fuck buddies, which at that point it's your own fault. We don't have anything serious with Mina nor the other girls yet tho.

 

[ImlerithRate]

While you currently can pursue all possible LI´s simultaniously, it has been massively hinted at that it will not end pretty for you going Alpha Harem. At the end of the game or a bit before the end you WILL HAVE TO choose 1 special LI, there will be no harems in PC. You can have friendly relations with all possible LIs, but you will have to choose one for a longterm relationship only.

So URM mod will solve this one. It will be harem for me anyway. Thx for answers boys

 

[Ottoeight]

Guys, just put the troll in your ignore list and move forward.

No troll deserves your time. Not even a second.

 

[Silegy]

In that sense even Rosalind can be saved by the MC. 20k isn't much in the premise of this game especially for someone who's working in the club. There are literally infinite ways he can do that, not just from the money he's getting from the club.

Depends on the path you're on. If I'm not mistaken, if she owes to Kitty-Kat and you didn't have high enough points with her, her condition is explicitly that Rose works it off as a house girl.

Which I guess may or may not have some ramifications endings-wise...

 

[imcharliebrown]

Does any of you have problems with mod? If I put the specific one but, even the universal one, the game crashes, I didn't even start, I click start in the menu and crash

 

[torpedogoat]

Does any of you have problems with mod? If I put the specific one but, even the universal one, the game crashes, I didn't even start, I click start in the menu and crash

I am running the latest version on Linux with no issues. For Ren'Py games that normally means it works well on Windows as well (and vice versa). I am using the universal cheat mod. I haven't installed the walkthrough mod yet because last time I tried it wasn't updated yet.

When the game crashes, it normally creates a file traceback.txt next to the executable. It contains valuable information that can often be used to solve the issue.

 

[ILoveWorkout]

FCK. Can't choose between Hana or Mina.

As the game isn't complete, and im reading the walkthrough (Still on Week 2), I don't see the option of us being a Throuple. I'll just have to wait for like 2030 lols of maybe finding that possibility. Fantastic Writing btw to the devs!