VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.5 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[Meabe37]

Best girls are outside business. There are few girls who take part of "sex shows" but Mina and Hana (blond and goth from top banner) are not hoes.

They defo gonna end up being whores in the club if i have anything to say about it before the end of the game

 

[Ass prefer]

They defo gonna end up being whores in the club if i have anything to say about it before the end of the game

Can Edwin himself become a whore in a club?

 

[dolfe67]

Can Edwin himself become a whore in a club?

He's the biggest whore

 

[ffive]

He's the biggest whore

Technically true because Edwin gets paid more than most.

 

[Ass prefer]

Technically true because Edwin gets paid more than most.

rightfully.

 

[ename144]

i haven't played this game, i just read overview, and i never play game that have ''brothel'' or '' sharing'' content. I wanna ask

If you can't stand the idea of other characters having sexual relations with the LIs, you will almost certainly not like this game. Thus far it's mostly happened off screen or been something you can prevent by making the right choices, but the implications are very clear and the odds are strong things will only get more explicit and harder to avoid as we approach the endgame.

Of course, if you don't mind seeing other characters with 'your' girls, I strongly recommend the game because the quality is top notch. It's just that the premise won't be to everyone's taste.

 

[Simpgor]

Best girls are outside business. There are few girls who take part of "sex shows" but Mina and Hana (blond and goth from top banner) are not hoes.

Logically this is more or less correct but considering Mina is dating Ian and we know that they do in fact have sex (Ian mentions it being better after she is "mad" at him, the story also makes it very clear that Edwin is a more giving partner than Ian but in for fragile people that just confirms Mina got fucked multiple times heavily implied to be during the course of the game as well), as well as wanting to experiment with girls (player choice). Then like I mentioned Hana has absolute 100% fucked other people with the only player choice being if we hear about it.

If a person has to ask if they will be safe playing this (any) game and wont be at risk of their feelers being hurt the simple fact that none of the LI (or side girls) is a virgin is probably enough for them to determine if they will be able to withstand this game

 

[dolfe67]

What, Mina and Hana are not virgin???

 

[Simpgor]

What, Mina and Hana are not virgin???

Not even Sophia or Victora are virgins there's no hope

 

[pinuz1]

Not even Sophia or Victora are virgins there's no hope

Sophia might've received more cock than some of the whores in the club LOL.

And I cant fucking wait till we add +1 more cock to the total

 

[SamualHand]

Not even Sophia or Victora are virgins there's no hope

Virgin tags is only earned when they stay virgin, so there is no hope at all after the MC has fucked them all. So all the girls & the MC are not virgins anymore. What a wasted potential in this game, we could have gotton such a good story with some nice and pure virgin, but we got a fuckfest.... ridiculous!

 

[Fapparition]

Sophia might've received more cock than some of the whores in the club LOL.

And I cant fucking wait till we add +1 more cock to the total

Fucking Sophia is like entering a brotherhood. You'll become hole-brother to like half of the patrons of Carnations Club and who knows to how many more gentlemans outside of the Club

 

[Deleted member 3788572]

If anything I'd say it's Felicia who's early path might exclude a potential playerbase. Her initial interactions are laser focused on sex, but if you turn her down in Chapter 1 you'll never get to see her surprisingly tender romantic side later on.

Sorry to dig up this almost a week old post (just browsed this thread for the first time in a few weeks), but as a Felicia simp aficionado, with what scene/day does Chapter 1 end?

 

[ename144]

Sorry to dig up this almost a week old post (just browsed this thread for the first time in a few weeks), but as a Felicia simp aficionado, with what scene/day does Chapter 1 end?

Ah, good point; AFAICT Chapter 1 ends when the Felicia is officially revealed as the third Carnation.


I should have said Felicia's path ends you turn her down in Week 1 when she asks the MC out for a diner date (either by phone or in person if the MC spends the day with Mina when Killian ditches her). You can turn Felicia down in Chapter 1 (the prologue) and still stay on her path if you accept the date in Chapter 2.

 

[Deleted member 3788572]

Ah, good point; AFAICT Chapter 1 ends when the Felicia is officially revealed as the third Carnation.
View attachment 4021897

I should have said Felicia's path ends you turn her down in Week 1 when she asks the MC out for a diner date (either by phone or in person if the MC spends the day with Mina when Killian ditches her). You can turn Felicia down in Chapter 1 (the prologue) and still stay on her path if you accept the date in Chapter 2.

Got it. I assumed you didn't mean the prologue scene, but since I usually only see Weeks being used for the timeline, I was a bit confused.

Fwiw, iirc on my save I didn't 'do' anything with her (outside of the club) up until the final cut-off point at the photo shoot with Elias.

 

[Kulman]

So does being dominant and overall doing kind of a lust path instead of a vanilla path with veronica close her later solo content?

Or is there a path of her submitting? I am not talking about the general unavoidable submission thats just part of the games.

 

[UmbralKnight]

So does being dominant and overall doing kind of a lust path instead of a vanilla path with veronica close her later solo content?

Or is there a path of her submitting? I am not talking about the general unavoidable submission thats just part of the games.

unless you are massive asshole to her and pick every dick head option its still possible to solo romance her
also her romance path is a bit of quid pro quo you can play nice and vanilla with her for a while and she plays nice with you, later both can indulge in kinky stuff and a bit of submission/dominance
her path is neither about being submissive to her or dominating her its like a dance between the two
you both go back and fro sometimes you can play the submissive side , some times she plays submissive for you

 

[Kulman]

unless you are massive asshole to her and pick every dick head option its still possible to solo romance her
also her romance path is a bit of quid pro quo you can play nice and vanilla with her for a while and she plays nice with you, later both can indulge in kinky stuff and a bit of submission/dominance
her path is neither about being submissive to her or dominating her its like a dance between the two
you both go back and fro sometimes you can play the submissive side , some times she plays submissive for you

Ah too bad, wanted pure dominance on my part. Well at least its something, thanks.

 

[UmbralKnight]

Ah too bad, wanted pure dominance on my part. Well at least its something, thanks.

that might still be possible if the devs decide to make a corruption/black mail route for her
for example a good MC might agree to help rose for free no strings attached meanwhile you can currently play as a "bad" MC who takes advantage of her after she makes a deal with you to help her win
so maybe in the future felicia and veronica might have their "bad" routes where you can coerce or blackmail them to take advantage of them
current veronica route is centered around good /neutral MC maybe in "bad" route the MC can team up with samson and blackmail her so they could dominate and make her submit to them

 

[melissus]

Yay, new numbers! TD already gave us the raw totals, but he and GIL have completed an average of roughly 75 statics, 3.3 animations and 1624 words per week since the last Dev Diary 21 days ago. Overall, that gives them an average of ~93 statics, 2.7 animations and 1746 words per week since work on Chapter 4 Update 5 began. Here are the charts for Week 22:

Spoiler: Still Charting Silently

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Looks like we're approaching the final lap, though this is a big course so we still have a while to wait. But I'm very eager to see what hints we can get about this big multi-character extravaganza - and obviously to play it eventually, too. As for the improved sound effects, not going to lie, I'm pretty nervous about it. I rarely like sound effects in lewd scenes, and I just as rarely have the stomach for Kathleen's take on a lewd scene. So this could have some major squick potential. Still, you can't win them all; as long as they're hooked up to the sound sliders in the Settings menu, all will be will.

And now for a completely random aside. I opened the game's Settings menu while writing this, just verify the term used. While there I thought I accidentally clicked one of the buttons, at which point I realized I have no clue what the different 'Skip' buttons actually mean! That made it very hard to work out what I might have done.
View attachment 4014284
Opening an older copy of the game, I realized that while the buttons themselves are the same, the labels they used to have were apparently removed when the image of the girls was enhanced. The original image was glaringly bright so the change was a good one, but could we get the labels back?
View attachment 4014283

Hi there ! I haven't followed development progress at all since last update, what is your estimation about the release date, with respect to these numbers ?