pinuz1

Member
Feb 13, 2021
217
752
Interesting, aside from the amazing theory of Edwin breaking his hand because he slapped Mina's beautiful ass too hard, what could've happened? maybe he punched a wall after the morning talk with Victoria because he got really angry when she told him what Ian's mom said? Edwin has never really shown signs of being that impulsive, though… :unsure:
 

DarkLords00

Newbie
Nov 23, 2022
77
183
Interesting, aside from the amazing theory of Edwin breaking his hand because he slapped Mina's beautiful ass too hard, what could've happened? maybe he punched a wall after the morning talk with Victoria because he got really angry when she told him what Ian's mom said? Edwin has never really shown signs of being that impulsive, though… :unsure:
That was my guess as well, I think it's the classic cliché where the character breaks his hand while punching something after learning very distressful information.

More interesting to me is why is Mina asking about Ian's Mother (I am assuming it's her since it would be very weird for Edwin to ask Mina about her unless he was willing to tell her something about what just transpired at the end of the previous update) .

So it's probably Mina asking about Grace because of her last interaction with Ian or Edwin is asking about her because he is telling Mina the short not very detailed version of why him and Ian had to suddendly left would be my 2 main predictions.
 

dolfe67

Forum Fanatic
Apr 25, 2020
5,463
15,249
That was my guess as well, I think it's the classic cliché where the character breaks his hand while punching something after learning very distressful information.

More interesting to me is why is Mina asking about Ian's Mother (I am assuming it's her since it would be very weird for Edwin to ask Mina about her unless he was willing to tell her something about what just transpired at the end of the previous update) .

So it's probably Mina asking about Grace because of her last interaction with Ian or Edwin is asking about her because he is telling Mina the short not very detailed version of why him and Ian had to suddendly left would be my 2 main predictions.
No it's Edwin asking. Should probably add who says it in the patreon post, it's only on discord for now.
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: DarkLords00

Ottoeight

Forum Fanatic
Mar 13, 2021
5,615
10,094
That was my guess as well, I think it's the classic cliché where the character breaks his hand while punching something after learning very distressful information.

More interesting to me is why is Mina asking about Ian's Mother (I am assuming it's her since it would be very weird for Edwin to ask Mina about her unless he was willing to tell her something about what just transpired at the end of the previous update) .

So it's probably Mina asking about Grace because of her last interaction with Ian or Edwin is asking about her because he is telling Mina the short not very detailed version of why him and Ian had to suddendly left would be my 2 main predictions.
Edwin is asking Mina whether she met Ian's mom.

About his hand: we should check whether Edwin is left-handed. If he's right-handed, he did not punch anything (a mirror?) or broke a glass in anger for sure.
 

bonerland

Active Member
Dec 28, 2017
724
1,071
Edwin is asking Mina whether she met Ian's mom.

About his hand: we should check whether Edwin is left-handed. If he's right-handed, he did not punch anything (a mirror?) or broke a glass in anger for sure.
The smarter MLB pitchers would, if someone charged the mound, use their non dominant hand to throw punches to avoid possibly injuring their pitching hand. Maybe Edwin smart enough to do that too.
 

Maccabbee

Well-Known Member
Mar 26, 2024
1,070
1,619
The smarter MLB pitchers would, if someone charged the mound, use their non dominant hand to throw punches to avoid possibly injuring their pitching hand. Maybe Edwin smart enough to do that too.
A smarter pitcher would use his dominant hand to throw a ball right at the charging player.
 

Ottoeight

Forum Fanatic
Mar 13, 2021
5,615
10,094
The smarter MLB pitchers would, if someone charged the mound, use their non dominant hand to throw punches to avoid possibly injuring their pitching hand. Maybe Edwin smart enough to do that too.
- That's a cut bandage, not a sprained/broken hand bandage.

- He's not a pitcher or a fighter.
 

ffive

Conversation Conqueror
Jun 19, 2022
7,985
18,829
Somehow I doubt that it is Edwin. The question about Ian´s mom does not fit! We and Edwin know since his birthday party that Mina knows Grace.
Well...
* there isn't many people who would refer to Killian per "Ian", i think.
* it's not Ian in the picture because he wouldn't refer to his own mom this way.
* if it turns out Mina is sitting with some other guy like that, there's gonna be riots :sneaky:
 
  • Like
Reactions: PervyParadox

Ozymandias037

Member
Sep 25, 2023
127
381
Edwin is asking Mina whether she met Ian's mom.

About his hand: we should check whether Edwin is left-handed. If he's right-handed, he did not punch anything (a mirror?) or broke a glass in anger for sure.
The smarter MLB pitchers would, if someone charged the mound, use their non dominant hand to throw punches to avoid possibly injuring their pitching hand. Maybe Edwin smart enough to do that too.
Is this really a thing? TIL, if so. Because I'm mostly left-handed but my instinct to punch usually goes to my right hand. Maybe I'm more ambidextrous than I thought...


Well...
* there isn't many people who would refer to Killian per "Ian", i think.
* it's not Ian in the picture because he wouldn't refer to his own mom this way.
* if it turns out Mina is sitting with some other guy like that, there's gonna be riots :sneaky:
I agree with all of this. And to these points, I will add that I can't recall anyone else ever getting this kind of POV view of events, especially not when it comes to the LIs (mom's videos don't count). I will be very, very surprised if that isn't Edwin.
 

Darreau91

Member
Dec 31, 2022
146
578
The ultimate girl friend experience is helping Mina get back at her cheating ex by banging his mom with her new lover.

Edwin is just dotting the I’s and crossing the T’s in that preview pic for a bucket list revenge 3some. Just push the Felicia 3some to the side and it makes perfect sense.
 

Turret

Forum Fanatic
Jun 23, 2017
4,475
7,676
Well...
* there isn't many people who would refer to Killian per "Ian", i think.
* it's not Ian in the picture because he wouldn't refer to his own mom this way.
* if it turns out Mina is sitting with some other guy like that, there's gonna be riots :sneaky:
How about Donovan, Chuck or the music guy?:sneaky:
But I agree it is probably Edwin, still the question is a bit strange since as I said we know at least since the birthday party that Mina knows Grace. I doubt TD has forgotten his own writing, maybe he is once again hiding something in plain sight.
 

bonerland

Active Member
Dec 28, 2017
724
1,071
- That's a cut bandage, not a sprained/broken hand bandage.

- He's not a pitcher or a fighter.
I never said he was either or that he broke his hand. I was pointing out that some people do have the awareness not to injure their dominate hand when punching something out of anger. Sheesh.
 

Ottoeight

Forum Fanatic
Mar 13, 2021
5,615
10,094
I never said he was either or that he broke his hand. I was pointing out that some people do have the awareness not to injure their dominate hand when punching something out of anger. Sheesh.
Sure, but aren't we talking about this game's characters and story?

Why do you keep talking about baseball? I don't see any basaball players or baseball references in Pale Carnation.
 
4.80 star(s) 530 Votes