bonerland

Active Member
Dec 28, 2017
747
1,146
- That's a cut bandage, not a sprained/broken hand bandage.

- He's not a pitcher or a fighter.
I never said he was either or that he broke his hand. I was pointing out that some people do have the awareness not to injure their dominate hand when punching something out of anger. Sheesh.
 

Ottoeight

Forum Fanatic
Mar 13, 2021
5,650
10,178
I never said he was either or that he broke his hand. I was pointing out that some people do have the awareness not to injure their dominate hand when punching something out of anger. Sheesh.
Sure, but aren't we talking about this game's characters and story?

Why do you keep talking about baseball? I don't see any basaball players or baseball references in Pale Carnation.
 

ename144

Engaged Member
Sep 20, 2018
3,608
14,839
Sure, but aren't we talking about this game's characters and story?

Why do you keep talking about baseball? I don't see any basaball players or baseball references in Pale Carnation.
Oh really?
Mina_Yankees_01.jpg Mina_Yankees_04b.jpg
Game set and match, Otto! :p

That said, I very much doubt the MC injured his hand in some sort of brawl. Maybe Sophia's visit was to perform some sort of invasive test and she bandaged it up for him afterwards?
 

Elduriel

Forum Fanatic
Donor
Mar 28, 2021
5,972
11,421
Oh really?
View attachment 4657940 View attachment 4657941
Game set and match, Otto! :p

That said, I very much doubt the MC injured his hand in some sort of brawl. Maybe Sophia's visit was to perform some sort of invasive test and she bandaged it up for him afterwards?
maybe one of Kath's fucked up ideas during the exhibition backfired and he got injured :KEK:
 

ffive

Devoted Member
Jun 19, 2022
8,304
19,787
But I agree it is probably Edwin, still the question is a bit strange since as I said we know at least since the birthday party that Mina knows Grace. I doubt TD has forgotten his own writing, maybe he is once again hiding something in plain sight.
Hmm it's been long time so i can't remember, but does that bit about Grace come up during the birthday party as fixed content, or maybe just in some optional branch? So Edwin wouldn't necessarily know that Mina knows her?
 

Bill Temple

Active Member
May 20, 2021
786
2,914
This weeks preview sure has generated a lot of thread activity.
I don't think "Have you met Ian's mom?" is a legitimate quest for information. I read it as a facetious, rhetorical question meant to rebut the other speaker's viewpoint or suggestion about Grace with incredulity. A slightly more specific example: Edwin says there is a problem with Grace that demands attention, to which Mina suggests ignoring it, with Edwin replying "Have you met Ian's mom?"

Also, since we're all weighing in with our bandage theories, I have one:
Instead of the diner, Edwin takes the Carnations to an afternoon Orioles-Red Sox game for their pre-exhibition team building activity. The ghost of James Earl Jones shows up to give them a rousing pep-talk, but an inebriated Felicia, mistaking his speech as encouragement to streak, takes the field, becoming the first arrested. Shortly after, Vero gets in a dustup with Ben Affleck and some other obnoxious Sox fans, so she's outta there. Rosie apologizes to Ben while Ed calls Kathleen to figure out how to get the Carnations out of the clink. Suddenly, the kiss cam focuses on Ben and Rose. Thinking quickly before Rose gets swept down the path to being the third Missus Affleck, Edwin invokes the Full Deal to make Rose give him a kiss so lewd that mothers throughout the stadium shield their children's eyes from the debauchery on the jumbotron. Sheepishly, Ben ponders why getting humiliated like this is turning him on so much. Kat has the Police Chief get Big Red and Feli released in time for the exhibition. When Ed goes to pick them up, at the doorway to the police station, he inadvertently shoulder checks a cop getting off duty who's on his way to coach his girlfriend's son's little league practice. The cop, having had a disappointing decade since separating from the Corps, is wistfully yearning for his bygone fobbit days at Delaram, when he and his M4 went unchallenged by women and children alike. Snapped back into the present by the unexpected collision, he takes exception to Edwin's smug face and lack of deference, and bashes his hand with an aluminum baseball bat, promising to do worse if he ever again is witness to Edwin not groveling before the Thin Blue Line.

That's just what sprung to mind when I saw Eddie's bandaged hand. I don't know if it's because today's MLB Opening Day, but I just feel like there needs to be more baseball sprinkled into Pale Carnations. Anyone else?
 

ffive

Devoted Member
Jun 19, 2022
8,304
19,787
I don't think "Have you met Ian's mom?" is a legitimate quest for information. I read it as a facetious, rhetorical question meant to rebut the other speaker's viewpoint or suggestion about Grace with incredulity. More specifically, Edwin says there is a problem with Grace that demands attention, to which Mina suggests ignoring it, with Edwin replying "Have you met Ian's mom?"
That's a very sensible explanation, though with one caveat: referring to her as "Ian's mom" in a follow-up in discussion which is already about her feels somewhat off. "Have you met Grace?" or even "Have you met her?" would be a more natural way to refer to someone when both of you already know who's the person in question.

But maybe that's just tweak for the sake of the preview. Or it's originally about Ian and it only just moved onto topic of his mom.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bill Temple

TD1900

#701
Game Developer
Dec 8, 2017
878
8,702
I don't think "Have you met Ian's mom?" is a legitimate quest for information. I read it as a facetious, rhetorical question meant to rebut the other speaker's viewpoint or suggestion about Grace with incredulity. A slightly more specific example: Edwin says there is a problem with Grace that demands attention, to which Mina suggests ignoring it, with Edwin replying "Have you met Ian's mom?"
Bingo.

I was gonna give it another couple days before pointing that out, since it was generating some discussion.

Also who keeps leaking the script?
 

Idontplay

Well-Known Member
Oct 30, 2017
1,355
1,909
About Edwin left hand, am I the only one who think: «We will discover what has happened, when the next release will be released, so why should I bother for an explanation now?»?
 

dolfe67

Forum Fanatic
Apr 25, 2020
5,503
15,418
I don't think it's Edwin. They're in Mina's apartment, and Edwin usually wears his father's watch when he's outside and "dressed".
It IS Edwin. No other character has a POV cam like this. And it looks like his appartment. But if it's Mina's, he could have come more casually without wearing his watch. Furthermore he has a bandage on his hand.
 

pinuz1

Member
Feb 13, 2021
227
795
About Edwin left hand, am I the only one who think: «We will discover what has happened, when the next release will be released, so why should I bother for an explanation now?»?
By that logic why even talk about the upcoming update at all? We'll discover what happens when it releases, so no point in having a discussion right? :whistle:
 

DarkLords00

Newbie
Nov 23, 2022
81
202
That's a very sensible explanation, though with one caveat: referring to her as "Ian's mom" in a follow-up in discussion which is already about her feels somewhat off. "Have you met Grace?" or even "Have you met her?" would be a more natural way to refer to someone when both of you already know who's the person in question.

But maybe that's just tweak for the sake of the preview. Or it's originally about Ian and it only just moved onto topic of his mom.
Just because Mina knows her name doesn't mean she doesn't refer to her as Ian's mom. Remember that Mina barely knows her and she admitted that Grace "scares" her.

Also, considering it's probably Edwin asking her that in a rethorical tone and what he will probably learn from Vicky after she tells him that she tried to blackmail her I doubt Edwin is on good terms with her to call her by name.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: Bill Temple
4.80 star(s) 535 Votes