VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.6 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[dexterousgecko]

I need to know, how do I get some sweet Hana/Mina/MC action? It's really all I want

 

[Discrepancy]

I need to know, how do I get some sweet Hana/Mina/MC action? It's really all I want

You can't, not yet

 

[dexterousgecko]

You can't, not yet

I can't cheat on my girls, but they're both so incredible.

 

[UmbralKnight]

When I see a preview I put my own spin on it. For fun. That's all there is to it. What ends up in the game is usually more tame, especially since the previews don't show any plot twists. Victoria's audition tape doesn't come up here. I've put it in there for cheap laughs.

nothing wrong with a little speculation or theory crafting
not much to do until the next update drops

 

[WeAreChecking]

How many sharing or swinging scenes does this VN have? And which Lis have those scenes?

 

[Turret]

How many sharing or swinging scenes does this VN have? And which Lis have those scenes?

That depends on how you count scripted sharing/swinging scenes, like the "present" with Dalia, Lucy and Co Kath can give you early in the game. There are several of these events in the game, most prominently so far with Rosi, Felicia and Mina in them.
But remember that most, if not all, of these scenes impact the love routes, where you loose chances if they would occur in parallel. e.g. The Feli/Mina/MC swing event hurts the Felicia romance route, because you loose the chance to gain some rarely awarded points with her.

 

[Discrepancy]

How many sharing or swinging scenes does this VN have? And which Lis have those scenes?

That depends on how you count scripted sharing/swinging scenes, like the "present" with Dalia, Lucy and Co Kath can give you early in the game. There are several of these events in the game, most prominently so far with Rosi, Felicia and Mina in them.
But remember that most, if not all, of these scenes impact the love routes, where you loose chances if they would occur in parallel. e.g. The Feli/Mina/MC swing event hurts the Felicia romance route, because you loose the chance to gain some rarely awarded points with her.

In my view of those terms I would even say there's no swinging or sharing scenes.
Swinging is if you're on a relationship with someone and exchange your partner for sex with a partner of another couple.
Sharing is sharing your partner with someone else, and only Hana can be in a serious relationship with Edwin atm and you can't share her with anyone.
I might be wrong though but that's how I see those terms.

 

[FRVN]

In my view of those terms I would even say there's no swinging or sharing scenes.
Swinging is if you're on a relationship with someone and exchange your partner for sex with a partner of another couple.
Sharing is sharing your partner with someone else, and only Hana can be in a serious relationship with Edwin atm and you can't share her with anyone.
I might be wrong though but that's how I see those terms.

I agree with you. There's no swinging or sharing in the game, but in a looser definition of sharing (the player can choose to let a love interest have sex with someone else), there's Rosalind (threesome with Ian and porn shoot with Ian), Mina/Felicia (can choose to let them fool around or stop them during their threesome scene), Mina/Veronica (can push them together), and Veronica (can be her wingman). There are other times where a love interest (main girls and side girls) has sex with someone other than Edwin, but the player doesn't have a choice, so I didn't include them.

 

[bonerland]

I agree with you. There's no swinging or sharing in the game, but in a looser definition of sharing (the player can choose to let a love interest have sex with someone else), there's Rosalind (threesome with Ian and porn shoot with Ian) and Mina/Felicia (can choose to let them fool around or stop them during their threesome scene). There are other times where a love interest (main girls and side girls) has sex with someone other than Edwin, but the player doesn't have a choice, so I didn't include them.

I'd say setting Veronica up with Mina and her offering to have a threesome later and the aft forementioned Felicia/Mina threesome would count as sharing, since it's the two LI's offering to bring a third in.

 

[FRVN]

I'd say setting Veronica up with Mina and her offering to have a threesome later and the aft forementioned Felicia/Mina threesome would count as sharing, since it's the two LI's offering to bring a third in.

I edited it to add that and being her wingman because I forgot about those until I hit post.

 

[Discrepancy]

I agree with you. There's no swinging or sharing in the game, but in a looser definition of sharing (the player can choose to let a love interest have sex with someone else), there's Rosalind (threesome with Ian and porn shoot with Ian), Mina/Felicia (can choose to let them fool around or stop them during their threesome scene), Mina/Veronica (can push them together), and Veronica (can be her wingman). There are other times where a love interest (main girls and side girls) has sex with someone other than Edwin, but the player doesn't have a choice, so I didn't include them.

I'd say setting Veronica up with Mina and her offering to have a threesome later and the aft forementioned Felicia/Mina threesome would count as sharing, since it's the two LI's offering to bring a third in.

I confess I din't even considered the threesomes as sharing, but you guys are right they should count, especially the Edwin, Rosalind and Ian. From experience the people asking about Sharing are most interested/worried about the"sharing" topic when another male is involved not females

 

[Turret]

In my view of those terms I would even say there's no swinging or sharing scenes.
Swinging is if you're on a relationship with someone and exchange your partner for sex with a partner of another couple.
Sharing is sharing your partner with someone else, and only Hana can be in a serious relationship with Edwin atm and you can't share her with anyone.
I might be wrong though but that's how I see those terms.

Generally I agree with you that PC has no literal swinging/sharing scenes (except Rosi/Ian/MC) so far. But if we apply looser restrictions on the definition than the scenes I mentioned would count. And since we are a varied lot of perverts here in our cosy den of depravity that is F95, there are players for whom the looser sharing/swinging definition and the resulting scenes are fully ok.

 

[Halsy]

Having a friendly relation with the carnations is probably better than sexual relation. You can learn more about them that way.

 

[pinuz1]

Having a sexual relation with the carnations is probably better than friendly relation. You can learn more about their tits that way.

 

[Discrepancy]

Having a friendly relation with the carnations is probably better than sexual relation. You can learn more about them that way.

 

[Ummmh]

Admitting to my (still not all that high) age as a Gen X, do you have to know this Jerrica? At least here were I live I never heard from her?

I to am Gen X, and watched Jem when it was out. No excuses!!! (TB fair, I didn't remember her name either, as it'd been like 35 yrs, but someone clearly did).

That said, SOME countries have free-thinking (TM) folk who can choose to make up their own damn names for their kids, and not be chained by useless and pointless convention... Tho it CAN be a bit hit or miss...

 

[Idontplay]

Having a friendly relation with the carnations is probably better than sexual relation. You can learn more about them that way.

Having a sexual relation with the carnations is probably better than friendly relation. You can learn more about their tits that way.

Having an economical relation with the carnations is absolutely the best: they work, you earn; earn, not learn.

 

[Turret]

Having a friendly relation with the carnations is probably better than sexual relation. You can learn more about them that way.

That depends very much on the character in question! Felicia for instance is easier to get close to if you are both mentally and sexually compatible, you even have a talk about that in her Porsche.
If you bang Rosi first opportunity on the other hand that will make reaching her more problematic. Veronica is also different as a lesbian-leaning bisexual and closet sex fiend (even a well-meaning Edwin can raise her lust stat rather more easily than with others). You have to first click mentally before any deeper sexual relations are possible with our gym owner.

Same with the other love/sex options.Hana you have to convince you are halfway ok as a person first, before real fun stuff can happen. Mina too, but to a lesser degree due to her sex bucket list.
Kath on the other hand uses sex as a tool, you get close to her by showing you are as sadistic and peverted as she is. Sophia is very much about mental challenges and her eccentric mindset to click with her.

I to am Gen X, and watched Jem when it was out. No excuses!!!

Different regions of the world playing a role her. As I mentioned in a deleted post, here we grew up with own productions, American, British, French, Italian ones and esp. "early" Anime.

 

[YuNobi]

I know someone posted a short walkthrough for the update a few pages back.

I checked: no walkthrough for Ch4Up6 of any kind has been posted.

 

[Meiri]

I checked: no walkthrough for Ch4Up6 of any kind has been posted.

The walkthrough mod is updated, but the PDF one is not.