VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.6 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[Meiri]

As a dreamer of Hana-Mina-Edwin trouple ending, I'm going to take this particular opinion of yours as biased, stemming from the fact that "it is not your favorite one". Following this statement, and despite being fully aware of my own biases, I refuse to acknowledge the possibility that this trouple can't be made long term.

And I'll refuse to acknowledge it up until the very end (and maybe even after that).

I think there may be a chance for that, Mina and Hana solo routes seem to be more on the traditional girlfriend experience but honestly the open relationship path just makes me think a threesome and ending is eventually going to happen... Or maybe they will both dump you

 

[Skeltom]

I think there may be a chance for that, Mina and Hana solo routes seem to be more on the traditional girlfriend experience but honestly the open relationship path just makes me think a threesome and ending is eventually going to happen... Or maybe they will both dump you

I'm still holding out hope for a actual romantic throuple, not just a casual threesome. On both of their paths you can kiss Mina and go to the first "date" as he says. If you go to the stage instead of the bar you see that Mina is jealous but she doesn't know if it was because of Hanna kissing Edwin or of Edwin kissing Hanna. She says they could all do something so no one feels less. To me if he was just looking to jump both of them she probably wouldn't be jealous of anything. The scene could play regardless but I fucked up and didn't see if it happens if you go to the bar as well.

The whole night it felt like she was worried about losing whatever they have going on and I don't think it's just because she would need to find someone else for her list. Even Edwin clearly gets jealous of the thought of Mina doing something with someone else. Sure, at first it's played off as "greed" but it's different by the end. He also says that maybe a relationship is possible in the future and the talk of a throuple with Mina in the hotel.

That could all just be me holding on to a sliver of hope that it is possible in the future and I'm reading too much into it but a man can dream...

 

[The Senior Perv]

Chapter 4 Up 6 Preview (4)

"Have you met Ian's Mom?"

 

[pinuz1]

View attachment 4653092

Chapter 4 Up 6 Preview (4)

"Have you met Ian's Mom?"

What the heck is going on with Edwin's left hand? Are those bandages? or just some weird lighting effect going on?

Also Mina is a cutie

 

[Skeltom]

What the heck is going on with Edwin's left hand? Are those bandages? or just some weird lighting effect going on?

Also Mina is a cutie

Looks like a bandage.

 

[TD1900]

I think there may be a chance for that, Mina and Hana solo routes seem to be more on the traditional girlfriend experience but honestly the open relationship path just makes me think a threesome and ending is eventually going to happen... Or maybe they will both dump you

Edwin can be the maid of honor for both sides of their wedding party.

 

[Darreau91]

What the heck is going on with Edwin's left hand? Are those bandages? or just some weird lighting effect going on?

Also Mina is a cutie

Went too hard being Mina's "daddy" is my guess. Smacking that tight ass could break some bones if the proper technique is not used.

 

[pinuz1]

Looks like a bandage.

View attachment 4653652

Interesting, aside from the amazing theory of Edwin breaking his hand because he slapped Mina's beautiful ass too hard, what could've happened? maybe he punched a wall after the morning talk with Victoria because he got really angry when she told him what Ian's mom said? Edwin has never really shown signs of being that impulsive, though…

 

[TheresiaW]

Looks like a bandage.

The main thing is that it's not a big blue eye like the MC in "Friends in Need" has. That ugly thing has been bothering me for a long time

 

[DarkLords00]

Interesting, aside from the amazing theory of Edwin breaking his hand because he slapped Mina's beautiful ass too hard, what could've happened? maybe he punched a wall after the morning talk with Victoria because he got really angry when she told him what Ian's mom said? Edwin has never really shown signs of being that impulsive, though…

That was my guess as well, I think it's the classic cliché where the character breaks his hand while punching something after learning very distressful information.

More interesting to me is why is Mina asking about Ian's Mother (I am assuming it's her since it would be very weird for Edwin to ask Mina about her unless he was willing to tell her something about what just transpired at the end of the previous update) .

So it's probably Mina asking about Grace because of her last interaction with Ian or Edwin is asking about her because he is telling Mina the short not very detailed version of why him and Ian had to suddendly left would be my 2 main predictions.

 

[dolfe67]

That was my guess as well, I think it's the classic cliché where the character breaks his hand while punching something after learning very distressful information.

More interesting to me is why is Mina asking about Ian's Mother (I am assuming it's her since it would be very weird for Edwin to ask Mina about her unless he was willing to tell her something about what just transpired at the end of the previous update) .

So it's probably Mina asking about Grace because of her last interaction with Ian or Edwin is asking about her because he is telling Mina the short not very detailed version of why him and Ian had to suddendly left would be my 2 main predictions.

No it's Edwin asking. Should probably add who says it in the patreon post, it's only on discord for now.

 

[Ottoeight]

That was my guess as well, I think it's the classic cliché where the character breaks his hand while punching something after learning very distressful information.

More interesting to me is why is Mina asking about Ian's Mother (I am assuming it's her since it would be very weird for Edwin to ask Mina about her unless he was willing to tell her something about what just transpired at the end of the previous update) .

So it's probably Mina asking about Grace because of her last interaction with Ian or Edwin is asking about her because he is telling Mina the short not very detailed version of why him and Ian had to suddendly left would be my 2 main predictions.

Edwin is asking Mina whether she met Ian's mom.

About his hand: we should check whether Edwin is left-handed. If he's right-handed, he did not punch anything (a mirror?) or broke a glass in anger for sure.

 

[ffive]

What the heck is going on with Edwin's left hand? Are those bandages? or just some weird lighting effect going on?

There's Edwin in that picture?

 

[Skeltom]

There's Edwin in that picture?

Right? All I see is a bubbly blonde.

 

[bonerland]

Edwin is asking Mina whether she met Ian's mom.

About his hand: we should check whether Edwin is left-handed. If he's right-handed, he did not punch anything (a mirror?) or broke a glass in anger for sure.

The smarter MLB pitchers would, if someone charged the mound, use their non dominant hand to throw punches to avoid possibly injuring their pitching hand. Maybe Edwin smart enough to do that too.

 

[Maccabbee]

The smarter MLB pitchers would, if someone charged the mound, use their non dominant hand to throw punches to avoid possibly injuring their pitching hand. Maybe Edwin smart enough to do that too.

A smarter pitcher would use his dominant hand to throw a ball right at the charging player.

 

[Turret]

There's Edwin in that picture?

Somehow I doubt that it is Edwin. The question about Ian´s mom does not fit! We and Edwin know since his birthday party that Mina knows Grace.

 

[Ottoeight]

The smarter MLB pitchers would, if someone charged the mound, use their non dominant hand to throw punches to avoid possibly injuring their pitching hand. Maybe Edwin smart enough to do that too.

- That's a cut bandage, not a sprained/broken hand bandage.

- He's not a pitcher or a fighter.

 

[ffive]

Somehow I doubt that it is Edwin. The question about Ian´s mom does not fit! We and Edwin know since his birthday party that Mina knows Grace.

Well...
* there isn't many people who would refer to Killian per "Ian", i think.
* it's not Ian in the picture because he wouldn't refer to his own mom this way.
* if it turns out Mina is sitting with some other guy like that, there's gonna be riots

 

[Ozymandias037]

Edwin is asking Mina whether she met Ian's mom.

About his hand: we should check whether Edwin is left-handed. If he's right-handed, he did not punch anything (a mirror?) or broke a glass in anger for sure.

The smarter MLB pitchers would, if someone charged the mound, use their non dominant hand to throw punches to avoid possibly injuring their pitching hand. Maybe Edwin smart enough to do that too.

Is this really a thing? TIL, if so. Because I'm mostly left-handed but my instinct to punch usually goes to my right hand. Maybe I'm more ambidextrous than I thought...

Well...
* there isn't many people who would refer to Killian per "Ian", i think.
* it's not Ian in the picture because he wouldn't refer to his own mom this way.
* if it turns out Mina is sitting with some other guy like that, there's gonna be riots

I agree with all of this. And to these points, I will add that I can't recall anyone else ever getting this kind of POV view of events, especially not when it comes to the LIs (mom's videos don't count). I will be very, very surprised if that isn't Edwin.