VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch.4 Up.6 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[ffive]

Man, I love this game but I am the only one who felt like Hana's GF route was kinda.... lacking?

They've only just gotten into the relationship like few days ago at most?

Pretty sure this will feel quite different for people who get to play the completed game with all GF-specific content in one go, and haven't spent more than half a year fantasizing about Hana GF route and then only got like, 2 days of the in-game time with major focus on other characters.

 

[pinuz1]

Man, I love this game but I am the only one who felt like Hana's GF route was kinda.... lacking?

Like, I love her character and I definitely want to keep on her route but it's kinda disappointing how there is basically no return at all for going into her route as opposed to just remaining fuck buddies. The choice comes really early in the game, so you sacrifice a lot of content from the other girls and yet you get nothing in return. I expected some exclusive gf content, you know? Like going on dates, chilling in the apartment and stuff. Some new content exclusive to the GF Route that makes it worth it picking it over the FB.

And I really hate to say this, but it doesn't really feel worth it to go into her GF route. You basically get the same content going into the FB route and yet you can still play around with the other girls. I truly wish we get some exclusive GF route content in future updates.

Funny you mention that when in the last dev diary TD pretty much confirmed Hana will have some kind of unique scene tied to the GF route next update .

 

[Ero - Sennin]

I wish that MC could bang Mina in this form with this face reaction, since he was able to bang Hana in the same looks

 

[ename144]

Man, I love this game but I am the only one who felt like Hana's GF route was kinda.... lacking?

Like, I love her character and I definitely want to keep on her route but it's kinda disappointing how there is basically no return at all for going into her route as opposed to just remaining fuck buddies. The choice comes really early in the game, so you sacrifice a lot of content from the other girls and yet you get nothing in return. I expected some exclusive gf content, you know? Like going on dates, chilling in the apartment and stuff. Some new content exclusive to the GF Route that makes it worth it picking it over the FB.

And I really hate to say this, but it doesn't really feel worth it to go into her GF route. You basically get the same content going into the FB route and yet you can still play around with the other girls. I truly wish we get some exclusive GF route content in future updates.

At least for the moment, going steady with Hana is more of a roleplaying decision than it is a separate path. If you look at it from that perspective it does give you some unique content, namely the ability for the MC to act like he's committed to Hana (or conversely the ability to cheat on Hana if you're a horrible person who should feel bad).

Obviously it would be good to get some lewd content that's unique to the GF branch as well, but as people have said, it's only been a couple days in game. I'm sure we'll get some unique content as time goes on.

 

[Thor875]

Well, If you're together for quite a while with a healthy sex life, almost all your clothes have been involved in pleasing your partner in some way or another. Based on how basic the outfit is I doubt that these were especially bought for sexy times but just adapted from regular wear rotation when she and her husband were having fun. Most clothes used for sexy roleplay are just that, regular clothes.

Sorry for the late reply. It's not about the question of which of these was specifically bought, but whether it is a specific combination and what memory or meaning it had for her. The fact that these are special items of clothing that she wears exclusively in anticipation of sexual acts (in the past and at the moment) becomes clear when you ask about their interchangeability. I don't think she bought the fishnet tights to wear at work or when shopping. (A matter of opinion)
Why does a woman have a blouse in her closet that is so tight (small) that you wonder whether it still closes at all, or if it does, all the buttons fly off her ears? (And that after 6-7 years of "malnutrition").
But seriously, she herself says: Dress for the job you want. It is a specially put together combination that only serves one purpose. She herself associates the outfit with the role of the sexy...
And if she used this combination for role play (one of the most intimate things a couple shares) with her husband, I think it’s bad to wear it to a porn casting and comment on it in that way.

 

[bonerland]

I think he said it's his first writing work. But he's a movie buff of obscure stuff, that might help He has some talent anyway

Considering the similarities between characters, I’m wondering if TD and Gil are fans of Tomo-Chan is a Girl.

Well, someone in the thread made the work to compare all the "funbags" in the game. With the result that Vicki has the largest bossom of them all and Sophia the smallest.

Sounds like that topic needs to be brought back, or at least the images

If you can speak about small breasts in this game, since even Sophia´s are rather big. The breast sizes are one of the few flaws of Pale Carnations, in my opinion, too many very large ones. But that is always personal tastes at work.

I’ve never heard the words “too many” and “large breasts” used in the same sentence before.

 

[pinuz1]

I’ve never heard the words “too many” and “large breasts” used in the same sentence before.

My issue is pretty much all the girls have the same body type, massive tits are nice but some variety would help the game imo

 

[Ungawa]

So yeah... I'm looking for the breast comparisons for... Science reasons.

Then I found this post and the details of Vicki...

I was wondering how Edwin became obsessed but then... Yeah, the early days proved we do get locked in and focused on what we like.

I'm not even mad. I missed a lot about the scene. I might have to replay it.

For Science of course...

And found it...

Porn power levels are no joke.

 

[schinushka]

Only just finished the latest update. Always funny to see the usual suspects here come up with high level analysis and all I can think of is 'another great update, the meeting between Grace and Vicky and everything around the concert was probably my favourite' lol.

Anyway, a few (minor) things I enjoyed:
- the music that played during the scene when Edwin greeted Felish in the carpark (and that scene in general)
- drunk and stoned Rosie
- Eve and Nico

Already looking forward to the exhibition, 'Tokyo' my ass. Before that, I will play the whole game again from the beginning to freshen up my memory and try out new paths, something I rarely do. Cheers!

Spoiler: Also

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[ffive]

View attachment 4546442

I'm sure Felicia can be easily convinced to penetrate Edwin's butt next.

 

[Turret]

I’ve never heard the words “too many” and “large breasts” used in the same sentence before.

There is always a time for the first time! I am not a fan of overlarge breasts, never was, never will be. Women should not be flat, but also not equipped with gas bags for Zeppelins! PC is at the uppermost border of what is acceptable in my opinion, we have worse offenders on site.
GIL3D is an absolute artist with HS, incredible work! And it is his talent why I still feel PC to be OK, when it comes to breasts. There are games here where I pass instantly due to balloon breasts.

 

[AlbertoRiveron]

The newest update was great just wish we got a little more in terms of scenes, love how the stories are playing out though.

 

[Ungawa]

There is always a time for the first time! I am not a fan of overlarge breasts, never was, never will be. Women should not be flat, but also not equipped with gas bags for Zeppelins! PC is at the uppermost border of what is acceptable in my opinion, we have worse offenders on site.
GIL3D is an absolute artist with HS, incredible work! And it is his talent why I still feel PC to be OK, when it comes to breasts. There are games here where I pass instantly due to balloon breasts.

Well, to be fair, there's just so much that goes into the story which a lot of developers don't do and is unique to this game in particular.

For me, the breast sizes are a bonus, and I know I'm ribbin' ya a bit on that, but with a story that tells a modern day film noir and really allows people to define how exactly they want the story to go and a choice and consequence that makes sense, I have to really applaud how the characters are unique, resonate strongly, and all bring something different into the story.

Who knew that a story about a Muscle Mommy, a Southern Belle trophy wife, a goth chick with daddy issues, a sheltered mouse, a housewife and a sadist who loves terrorizing them all would entice so many people in a cathouse?

It certainly wasn't on my bingo card so long ago...

 

[Draim]

There is no harem in the game, but you can also fuck all the girls without consequences. I wonder what the developer is planning . Will it add jealousy, NTR, and all that fuss? So far, the most interesting route is to try to fuck all the chicks in the game.

 

[Thor875]

The day before yesterday I read a very interesting older post about these two pictures.



It was pointed out that she is wearing her watch in the second picture. I didn't like the explanation from him very much. The thought occurred to me: what if she didn't take off her clothes but wanted to put them back on? That would mean she had already had a shoot beforehand.

Suppose it is the first day of her porn career and she has just finished the interview. (Time stamp 2:31-3:21 and that is not the end. We only know the farewell scene (without time information) covered in cum and a condom between her breasts. The camera data also matches, only the January data somehow still doesn't match.

Spoiler: ONE possible scenario

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

I have another question. Where and how do I get the animation in which she gets fucked from behind on the bed?

I read about Rose at the end?? But where exactly and which Rose condition do I need for that? I have a save game where I can make the full deal. It would be nice if someone could post that before I've progressed so far, that I don't have the time or desire to start there again. Unfortunately, I'm making too little progress for that.

Spoiler: Another small detail

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[ffive]

It was pointed out that she is wearing her watch in the second picture.

Probably just render continuity error, as the alternative would be she has somehow put that watch on during the minute between the two shots, while also covering up her tits and face. Which would be pretty neat trick to pull off with only two hands.

 

[Thor875]

the alternative would be she has somehow put that watch on during the minute between the two shots, while also covering up her tits and face. Which would be pretty neat trick to pull off with only two hands.

I understand the argument, but don't see it as a contradiction or even a trick. I just went to the trouble of trying it out. I'm sitting in front of my computer and I took off my watch beforehand and put it on a table about 5 m away. Don't laugh, I set the stopwatch on my phone and took her position. After 10 seconds I really got up leisurely, got my watch and sat down again. Then I put it on. It took me 26 seconds for everything.
So the cameraman comes in. She is really surprised and he asks why so shy. Since she doesn't yet know what's in store for her, she puts her hands down and continues getting ready. Her bag is next to the Sofa. She takes her watch, puts it on and he tells her that it's going to continue, whereupon she seems rather stunned or sad and tries to hide it.
Of course, it is just a thought experiment.

 

[ffive]

Don't laugh, I set the stopwatch on my phone and took her position. After 10 seconds I really got up leisurely, got my watch and sat down again. Then I put it on. It took me 26 seconds for everything.

But were you covering up your tits and face while you were putting on that watch? Because that's the hard part...

 

[Thor875]

But were you covering up your tits and face while you were putting on that watch?

I wrote it ebove. Then 2-3 pictures are missing. It´s a memory , he does not remember the entire situation, but only the moment of her reaction to what the cameraman says.

 

[Ottoeight]

The day before yesterday I read a very interesting older post about these two pictures.

View attachment 4549846 View attachment 4549847

It was pointed out that she is wearing her watch in the second picture. I didn't like the explanation from him very much. The thought occurred to me: what if she didn't take off her clothes but wanted to put them back on? That would mean she had already had a shoot beforehand.

Suppose it is the first day of her porn career and she has just finished the interview. (Time stamp 2:31-3:21 and that is not the end. We only know the farewell scene (without time information) covered in cum and a condom between her breasts. The camera data also matches, only the January data somehow still doesn't match.

Spoiler: ONE possible scenario

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

I have another question. Where and how do I get the animation in which she gets fucked from behind on the bed?

I read about Rose at the end?? But where exactly and which Rose condition do I need for that? I have a save game where I can make the full deal. It would be nice if someone could post that before I've progressed so far, that I don't have the time or desire to start there again. Unfortunately, I'm making too little progress for that.

Spoiler: Another small detail

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

I understand the argument, but don't see it as a contradiction or even a trick. I just went to the trouble of trying it out. I'm sitting in front of my computer and I took off my watch beforehand and put it on a table about 5 m away. Don't laugh, I set the stopwatch on my phone and took her position. After 10 seconds I really got up leisurely, got my watch and sat down again. Then I put it on. It took me 26 seconds for everything.
So the cameraman comes in. She is really surprised and he asks why so shy. Since she doesn't yet know what's in store for her, she puts her hands down and continues getting ready. Her bag is next to the Sofa. She takes her watch, puts it on and he tells her that it's going to continue, whereupon she seems rather stunned or sad and tries to hide it.
Of course, it is just a thought experiment.

Bro, you are overthinking.