Preface: This review is based on the fully patched (incest+loli) game version 1.1, so I won't be referring to "roommates" or anything like that.
Very likely my favorite VN so far. There are some tiny details I would've done differently than Mr. Shaw and where I'd wished I'd have been given the choice, but the characters are just so fucking lovely.
In other VNs, I usually end up having one or two favorites fairly early on (I wanted to give some examples, but then saw it would violate the
Reviewing Rules), but here I find it really hard to choose a favorite (or even three).
The interactions aren't just about the sex, and I can easily believe that Jenna is the MC's sister. You can feel their history in their interactions, and there's the faux-hostility and bullying you'd expect in such a relationship. Elly's affection seems so very genuine and each moment feels earned, even despite the short time frame. The portrayal of certain serious topics involving Sofi is so well done, that I found myself wondering if the creator has a personal history with them.
Pretty much all of the characters here make you fall in love with them more so than with their bodies or the taboo kinks. Heck, even the
VERY taboo scene that requires you to confirm it twice was handled very nicely and somewhat respectfully, given the circumstances.
Overall, I can just say that the writing is pretty stellar. The MC makes some puns in inappropriate moments that make the scenes feel more real, and I actually like that there's laughter even during the sexual interactions, some of the phrases used are somewhat elaborate, the vocabulary is extensive and the grammar, while certainly not perfect by a long shot, is inoffensive and decent as well.
What the game most surprised me with, though, is the huge amount of branching paths, some of which differing from the others quite severely. I was not ready for the game to not instantly end after I intentionally fucked up in the second-ever choice the game gave me and, instead, give me a whole side-plot, including some crucial backstory, culminating in a unique ending.
Also, speaking of that route reminds me of another great aspect about the writing, namely how not everything has to be spelled out in detail. I met a unique character in said unique ending and there are many references to her in the other paths, but piecing together the whole of it takes a lot of subtle remarks and the reader's attention. Sienna is a standout character, quite literally, as she almost exclusively exists outside of the story. And I love her regardless. And that's a testament to the writing talent at work here.
The game also manages to satisfy a shitload of different kinks and even handles content that probably isn't exactly the creator's cup of tea (well, maybe it is, but some of it is just a one-off thing, so I assume not) with a ton of respect. Given that the tags are already giving you a decent idea of what to expect, I suppose it's not a spoiler to mention that there's a trap in the game (completely optional), and her scene, if you choose to let it play out, doesn't treat it as a big deal and has the MC be very respectful and open about it.
The renders are also pretty nice, even though the animations are a bit painful to watch at times. I'm not sure if I would've preferred stills only, and some of the animations are actually nice, but the majority of them seemed a bit rough.
There aren't any music, sounds or voices in the game. Not too unusual but worth pointing out, regardless.
Lastly, the game is even something for achievement hunters, as it offers a whopping 14 (+1 for getting all the others) of them, some of them quite sneaky.
Overall, I just had an excellent time with this VN and reaching the last ending (1 of 5, as that is the objectively best one) has left me with that bittersweet feeling that only well-written stories can ever give you. I'm happy I got to experience it, sad that it's over and ruined for any other stories for a short while... bravo!