100% of art - scrapped
60% of story - scrapped
100% gameplay - scrapped
Good portion of the game is just like a visual novel - So why bother with making players walk everywhere RPG style when it's just a huge pain in the arse? Sure, it makes sense for a dungeon part of the game, or some other special sections. But it should mainly just give an option to click specific point on a map, either world map or city/village.
Also, some kind of branching sex scenes or extra choices during those are fine, but stupidly complicated branching story is just pushing it, simple one would be enough.
Art - Inconsistent, terrible here and there... Just no, all of current art is pure crap.
Cloth damage system - Ok, this one is good and independent from HP which should always be the case. I love it and it stays.
MC - Oh, sad, sad Rose. While I do like her as a character, bratty and smug Rose was way more fun to play with. Also, bad things happen to bratty girls and it's way more rewarding/exciting. Then again, would work well as her initial status before getting bad/good with virgin/slut combination.
It's like... I would be insane to just start this game from scratch.
Good thing I don't deal with sanity.
While majority of characters will stay, whole story is going to be shifted around, a lot, so no more sad village girl. To the point of being re-written from the scratch.
More VN, no walking around on maps. Battles will stay, RPG maker will stay, cloth damage stays, battle system stays, only required walking should be inside dungeons and similar.
That's all. I will be back later when I have something playable... Until then, I wasn't even here