To be honest 'breaking Myriam to his will' sounds a bit too much like Anthony's approach, and I thought we were moving away from that.
Perhaps you're right. Perhaps you're wrong. Perhaps it will be up to the player. Unless Zorlun comes out and clearly declares it one way or the other, we all just have to wait and see.
That being said, I do not accept that Marc breaking Myriam to his will means that he becomes another Anthony or acts in exactly the way that Anthony did.
Sub/Dom relationships are mutual arrangements with the Sub willingly submitting. Forcing someone to do what you want has got nothing to do with this, and is simply the abuse of a bully.
This statement is simply not true. There are many sub/Dom relationships which are not mutually beneficial or even consensual. And forcing someone into a sub/Dom relationship does have to do with submission and dominance. Unhealthy horses are still horses, and abusive dominants are still dominants. Now, if you had said, "A
good sub/Dom relationship is...", then I would have been more inclined to agree with you.
As someone who has participated in BDSM and D/s for more than two decades, I can tell you with confidence that these things are very complex, and statements which amount to "This is how it always is" tend to be proven wrong more often than they're proven right.
But all of that is talking about BDSM and D/s in real life, and this game is a work of fiction, and all of the characters are fictional characters. So what would constitute "good" or "bad" D/s or BDSM in real life is in no way binding on the storyteller, unless he has stated that one of his goals is to teach people about D/s or BDSM. The storyteller has the freedom to tell the story as he or she pleases. And, of course, I don't know whether or not Zorlun will include something like Marc breaking Myriam to his will. But I'm open to it.
Bearing in mind that Myriam is being trained to defend herself and she's going to be Marc's legal guardian anyway, it's simply not realistic to imagine this kind of relationship between them.
Sure it would be realistic. Myriam was probably naturally submissive (to some extent) to begin with, and has certainly been conditioned for many years to be extremely submissive. That's not something which just goes away because she took a couple of martial arts classes, or because she's had two sessions of therapy. In the first place, it takes more than just a week or two worth of classes for someone to become competent in martial arts. In the second place, Myriam wouldn't want to deploy martial arts against her son. In the third (and most important) place, her conditioning to submit means that, so long as she isn't placed in a situation where the need to fight back outweighs her submissiveness, the question of whether or not she could beat Marc in a fight doesn't even come up.
With regard to the psychiatrist trying to help her to take charge of her sexuality, therapy can only be as effective as she allows it to be, and she has to actively choose to apply the things which the psychiatrist is trying to impart to her. It is often much easier to just go back to what you already know and accept, especially for people who have been abused.
And the fact that Myriam will become Marc's legal guardian would be very close to meaningless, so long as Myriam continues to submit.
Honestly, it's at least as realistic to imagine that the D/s relationship between them would continue, as it is to imagine that it would simply stop. Not that realism is one of the foremost considerations for this game. There have been plenty of things happening in the game, so far, which are in no way realistic. Realism isn't a requirement of good writing or good games. Believability is important, but when it comes to work of fiction, realism is only important insofar as it aids believability. Historical fiction being an obvious exception, of course.
For me, the only way this relationship has any chance, is if Marc learns there are limits beyond which he can't push Myriam. She may be submissive, and enjoy being dominated by Marc, but she's not a pushover anymore. And if he goes too far, he'll be the one suffering and not her.
Perhaps you'll be able to play the game that way. I think it's likely. And perhaps others will be able to play the game differently. If you can avoid content which you don't want to view, it should all be fine.