So im actually impressed with how far the game mechanics have come along with this game... honestly this game is shaping up to be good enough to put out a non porn version for mainstream gamers, the war with the barbarians is top quality for its non porn elements.
Only thing missing is a counter attack game mechanic every month of the war that has a chance of pushing me back to Camille, and after that the barbarians can push to my capital and conquer the queen.
Like If I have victory points in the Barbarian terf they cant attack into Camille, but if im at 0 victory points or negative they CAN attack Camille and effect the "rebuild" percent. If I get 0 in Camille they can attack my castle for a bad end.
However speaking of the porn in this game.
I quit playing a long time ago because every updated was just more of the same stupid sub slut queen.
The dev has little to no interest in treating all playthrough options equally. The game wont let us be a dom yet (like was planned and advertised at one point).
Why cant we behead the duke for rebellion, or drag him to the dungeon and give him monthly visits as a dominatrix whip him senseless and put his balls in a cock cage. The game gives a moronic reason that "we didn't have justification for war against the Duke", which is totally stupid reasoning that no feudal society would go along with. In real life the Duke would have been drawn and quartered, or placed in the dungeon for the rest of his life. His lands given to his closest loyal relative. So the games excuse for not giving the player a choice is exactly that, an excuse.
On my most recent playthrough I tried to not make an alliance with the barbarians and try to conquere them the New vegas legion way, and the game still wont let me do it after all these years... for reasons, the reason is that the dev doesn't seem to care about a dom playthrough enough to give it equal time with sub slut stupidity. The Queen being a stupid sub slut in this game is all the worst stereo types for a female protagonist in Adult games, dispite this game having every opportunity to break the mold, and make her strong and respectable. Very unfortunate. Now after coming back to this game after being away for so long all the dev did was add more cheesy slut cringe where the queen becomes a willing whore for barbarians, and has moved on to the queens cosin across the sea, who also is doing stupid cheesy slut cringe. Hey broken torpedo why don't you finish the game stories already in the game with proper queen playthroughs before moving on to more slut cringe across the sea.
This game has one of the most insulting illusions of choice I have ever seen in a game.
In the first hour of gameplay starts out great, you can get defeated by barbarians and Raped, start a Lesbian relationship with your body guard, get sexually harrassed by the duke as a prelude to his rebellion, and retake Camille which if you rebuild (which might take slightly more than an hour) you can start a reasonable wholesome relationship with Sir Gerard. Both the Duke and Sir Gerard are nobleman so their shouldn't be a scandal if your in a relationship and planning a marriage. But Supposedly it would be a scandal because reasons. The dev needs to actually do some research into the middle ages and feudal society.
It would not be a scandal because lots of courts were "lively in the sexual passions", and both the queen, Duke, and Gerard are nobleman. It would be proper if a marriage was on the table, but not a full scandal. I also find it amazingly stupid that it would be a scandal to have a romance with a nobleman who is a vassle, but somehow not a scandal to do Gang bang and Bukakke shit with barbarian tribes for forgin policy reason, yet not a scandal for... reasons... really stupid reasons.
So in the first hour we get a sleezy sub relationship choice with the duke, a wholesome Lesbian relationship option with the body guard, a wholesome straight relationship with Sir Gerard, and a choice to go to war with the duke.
All good wonderful choices.
Then the game has NO extra scenes with Williamina, cutting the Lesbian angle off. (Potential wholesome good strong honorable queen playthrough)
Sir Gerard gets like 5 scenes. (Potential wholesome good strong honorable queen playthrough romance)
The duke has 12 scenes 13 if you count the prologe. (Sleezy mildly bad mildly good sub slut queen playthrough). Not one of these scenes are him in a dungeon or on a chopping block.
The choice to go to war with the duke (which should be considered for both a good and evil queen who is a strong dom).
If you go to war with the Duke and win you are told you are wrong (even though your right) the game rug pulls your choice, when you should be able to imprison and torture him, or excuted him. And yes that is the right choice. The dev needs to go talk with Tywin Lanister from Game of Thrones and actually learn something about how the middle ages worked. Replace the duke with his 18 year old Duchess sister/cosin that the evil dom queen can prev out on during the monthly visits. Double team the Duchess with Williamina. Or ignore her while getting all the benefits of a loyal vassle.
After the first hour of gameplay the choices get worse. The game forces you into an alliance with the barbarians to advance the barbarian war quest. Dispite giving you the choice to turn it down. The barbarians (Hawk tribe) approach you with an alliance and your given a choice to accept it or not. If you accept it the game goes as normal. But if you don't accept it the game tells you "fuck you" and won't let you progress past a certain point. <---- do you have any idea how insulting that it, what horrible illusion of choice that is. It's actually worse than the normal illusion of choice because it straight up rug pulls you says "fuck you your wrong" and then if you don't choose what the dev wants the storyline is over until you change your mind.
I should have the choice to be an evil queen and genocide and colonize the barbarians like an evil witch. I should be able to choose to be like Ceasars legion from new vegas for a dom queen playthrough.
But even if im a good queen and accept the alliance, the game mechanic wants me to be a stupid whore for the barbarians to "gain trust ". When I should be able to just pay gold for aid and rebuilding like I did with Camille but the only option is suffer lower trust or be a sub slut queen not a honorable dom queen not whoring herself out to a forgin chiefs gangbang bukakke.
Dealing with your own kingdom is similar. I can only recuit troops and raise moral by being a whore, or I have an official that gets me 10 troops a day instead 100 or 200 you get from being a whore IN THE FUCKING MIDDLE AGES AS A "QUEEN".
The bar scenes with the bandits and the spy, why the fuck cant I bust the door down with troops with no major consequences. Jail the bandits and make them talk. It would be Tywin Lanister approved, and its exactly what every single mideivil king/queen would have done in real life... but NO if you want to avoid being a sub slut queen you have to save scum and reload save after save until you win the gambling game because you don't have real choice in this game, the dev rug pulls your decision making to force you to do what the dev wants.. where is the dom queen option in the bar? Who the fuck is the spy master to not train a replacement or come back to help his kingdom, this is just piss poor writing that only exists to make the player be a stupid sub slut queen.
To give an idea as to how bad this is lets do some math with the gallery:
The duke has 12-13 scenes depending on if you count the prologe.
Williamina the body guard has one scene from the wine cabinet. This is Dispite the wine cabinet being available from day/week/turn 2. Why doesn't she have 13 scenes like the Duke?
Sir Gerard is 5 scenes for a wholesome romance
7 rape scenes for defeat 4 in the barbarian war 3 in the arena (both the Queen and Williamina)
Cheesy slut cringe scenes that only exist for the sake of cheesyslutcringe?
Barbarians 10
Troops 8
Painter 4
Bar gambling because the spy master won't do his job because piss poor writing 2 scenes.
Queens cousin 4 scenes
28 total
Since the duke is also sub slut playthrough we have duke plus other sub slut content
28+13=41
41 Vs 13
13 scenes for all other content which includes wholesome romance, and defeated rape scenes. (Not counting bad ends because they are hard to get, not in the gallery, and I cant catalog them, I also dont know if the bad ends are animated because the two I get most aren't animated)
Most other devs of good games do an updates with different content for different choices. So one update will mostly be sub content, then the next update of mostly dom content. One update is for good choices the next update is for evil choices. "Luna's fall from grace", and "Luna reloaded" come to mind, as well as "The Point of No Return". Where one month is resistance, next is submission, next month is deception.
This game is going to need like 10-20 updates in a row of other content to balance the sub slut playthrough with other content.
Like take the duke... why can't there be multiple options
Option 1: go along with his request, maby marry him because that shouldn't be a problem for Nobility. (Choice is In the game, except marriage because that would actually make sence for the Middle ages)
Options 2: war conquer, behead and kill him. Done with his sorry ass and on to the rest of the game. (Rug pulls the choice because of poorly written lore and lack of knowledge about feudal societies)
Option 3: imprison him and his monthly visits are him being tortured by dommy queen for the rest of his days. Or left to rot. (Rug pulls the choice because of poorly written lore and lack of knowledge about feudal societies)
Devs nonsense option: go to war, keep him in power, and he gets "restless " later on. Which is completely stupid as no feudal monarch would be this brainless as to leave a rebellious vassle in power. ( choice is In the game)
Why is that so hard to provide the two dom choices instead of rug pulling our choices, seems simple would close the plot hole of not being able to do it dispite being a queen? It would stop insulting the players intelligence with false choices. It shouldn't be that hard?
Its even written into the balance of the game mechanics. You start out with around 1500 troops/military points, the duke starts with 3500. Why the fuck isnt he the king if he has 3500 army points and I only have 1500 in debt, 1000 points outside of debt. If Queeny started out with 4000 in debt 3500 not in debt and The duke started with 1500. You could deal with him like the totorial mission he is, still have some left over for the start of the barbarian war, but need to replenish yourself to win. Verrtignis with its 7500 army points would be a real challenge, and the game would be nice and balanced. Right now if you want something resembling a dom playthrough you need to grind like its pay to win, or use the cheat/debug merchant in order to advance the story without being a stupid slut whore. Its complete bull shit.
With the Barbarians and other stories in the game, they are still WIP so if one type of content lags behind thats one thing. But the duke is the tutorial for forgin policy. It would be nice to get all the dukes options done with before moving on to the barbarians. But the duke is left in limbo, without all his playthroughs!!! if you don't want to make the choice the dev wants, the game forces you to make his choices dispite offering and advertising choices in the game. The Dukes story should be finished including the dom Options.
But the dev moves on to the Barbarians, Verrtignis, and now Queen's cosin across the sea, and most of this content is more of the same sub slut playthrough. Without doing all the branching choices for the duke. If the dev has no intention of ever providing those choices, then I feel lied to. This game is false advertising, because in the past Broken torpedo has said that he intended to offer us more choice, but he wanted to get the game mechanics like the war ironed out first. Well that explanation is becoming an excuse and false advertising when the duke can get conquered but not punished, when the duke has 13 scenes and Williamina has 1 and Sir Gerard has 5.
Same with the barbarians.
They attacked and invaded you.
Options 1a: be a good queen build their trust with aid, keep your honor and dominate aura as a proper queen. Forge an alliance and be good. (Realist to a feudal society, not currently available in game because we can't build trust with aid in gold instead of sub slut nonsense)
Option 1b: be a good queen build their trust with aid, keep your honor and dominate aura as a proper queen. Set a governor over them as new subject "betraying" any sence of alliance. (Realistic to a feudal society, not available in game)
Options 2: be an evil bitch queen, take a page from New vegas legion and Ceasar. So you can war crimes you way through the barbarians not giving a fuck until their remnants join your enemies later on in the game. Lots of sex scenes from your troops raping and pillaging the barbarians, and giving the duke come company in his cell with captured chiefs (Realistic to a feudal society, not available in game)
Options 3a: form an alliance with the Barbarians be a sub slut doing "fertility rituals " in their religion to get their trust and have a true alliance. (WIP but choice is in game)
Option 3b: be a sub slut but back stab the barbarians and set a governor over their lands. (WIP likely to be a choice. )
Honestly the barbarian war story is really well done, but only if you choose what the dev wants you to choose. The non porn elements are shaping up nicely. Insurgent counter attacks, attacks of forts and ruined temples. This game could ditch the porn and Finnish itself into a good mainstream game. As long as the dev actually provides multiple real choices, that are not plot hole nonsense like not killing or imprisoning the duke. Mainstream audience would probably be even more pissed and unforgiving at all the false choice as I am as well many others are in the comment section.
Or even reskin the game. i don't want to kink shame, but the game and the games thread give the impression of multiple choices real decisions. If the dev is so committed to his one kink of sub sluttery that he doesn't have the discipline to work on anything other than sub slut kink. He should reskin the game and change the advertising in the threads.
Part of my problem with the the poor writing in the story is the plot holes of unrealistic choices for a feudal society and monarchy. But if you reskined the game to be in a modern city. Make the Queen the Porn Studio Queen with an main Studio where the castle is now, a B studio where Camille is. You only have a 50% stake in the dukes studio, which would give him a real reason to be an uncooperative sleez ball, instead of a bull shit reason that makes no sence for the Middle ages. The barbarians could be thugs from the hood that you need protection from for your B studio. Verrtignis could be a rival studio ran by the mafia. The city across the sea could be the cop shop, and your police woman cosin could have some run ins with the thugs. All the sub slut choices would make total logical sence, and more importantly the lack of real choices would actually make sence to the setting. The choices would actually fit the setting, and a ton of plot holes wouldn't exist.
I was tempted to post something like this comment as a review but not sure what stars to give it, also Broken torpedo is working on it and might deliver one of the best games, if real choices actually start being implemented. But if the porn part of the story keeps going this way its going to be 1 star.
Is there a road map as to when multiple options for different playthroughs will be available? Because im starting to think they are not coming or we would already have multiple options with the duke?
If the dev is going to provide those multiple options for different playthroughs, broken torpedo should get the Duke and Barbarians finnished (all playthroughs) and then bump the game on the F95 site. Start a new thread or get F95 mods to send the game to the top of the new game list. It would probably rake in a ton of new fans who get freshly introduced to the game. But if you do it with all your false choices it could backfire and get quiet a bit of 1 star heat. My bump your game Idea will only work with multiple playthroughs available, or people will hate it.