What do you mean what I am on about? I asked a question on a forum if an evil path was necessary. Didn't ask about the choices given. I clearly saw them. As you said one of the choices was geared towards being a bad guy my question basically was was that needed. Your daughters come to you cause they lost there mother so you are given a choice to be a bad guy, not a disciplinarian, a bad guy. Thats is basically my question a legit question.
This game has been developed with the bad guy path in mind since the start so for me it is just such a random question to begin with. And the bad guy path can be disciplinarian, you don't HAVE to go full on bad guy and
rape Olivia in EP6, you actually have to do some certain choices for it to even be a choice. Neither do you have to spank Maddison to she almost screams of pain, you can stop early. So on and so on.
What I meant with "What your on about" was literally you saying the MC was built to be a good guy, which is not true. You are given the choice to go the good and caring path and be a good dad towards the girls. But you are also given the choices to be controlling/disciplinarian or a straight up bad guy. I for one appreciate devs who give us these options in their games