Lets start by saying that the game title is actually a meta-JOKE. Why?:
Mia, Sadie and Cindy have the same face and almost the same hair color. Isla is pretty similar with freckles. Vivian looks pretty similar but with another eye color.
As for the game visuals:
I think this one loses too much work and effort doing things that are easier like giving free renders of models posing, basically, but other meaningful things are just not there. I mean you get some free renders, you can even change girls clothes with one button ( WTF its the most money grabbing ridiculous thing i have seen) but later when you actually can "hug" Mia, there is no hug, like not even a single hint to let you know it happened, not with Mia face, not in the pose, or the camera distance, nothing at all.
To see this kind of work I can download Poser and do the stuff myself, I did it in the past, but its only girls making poses.
The game has decent renders, ignoring the fact that many girls are the same model,and the blurry hair. Still I wouldnt rate high the visuals because the diffcult poses still look like crap, and for me as a male, a girl bending over is a big thing, and if an ass looks like an aberration, sorry it doesnt work for me, do it differently, or make another camera angels that looks better.
For the writing:
Well, it tries, most conversations are boring, the way of recreating tension is using faces, and the MC stammers and the usual stuff, but mostly the shallow stuff. This MC always on the receiving end, and shutting up and thinking he deserves everything is bullshit.
There are examples of things that could be better like when the MC is talking about his girfriend after meeting Mia. He talks about her, but he should be showing her pictures or something, cause at that point i didnt know the Mc had a girlfriend, it would be nice to see her and create in the process a more "natural" scene, maybe Mia could se that she actually looks like her and have some thoughts or something. For me there is not enough tension,and the release is kind of NAH.
More like tension it feels like writer beating around the bush.
The thing is there is quite some dialogue, but since it doesnt exactly feel well, and most of the time doesnt add much, the first part of the game gets boring as hell and fails to make me care about the characters, including the ones that give you easy sex COUH COUGH girlfriend i barely know... Call me weird there are camgirls out there that I know as much as the majority of these characters.
The second hug in the beach triggered me quite a bit, I mean, It seriously did the run away dissapearing into the distance thing. Thats pretty much a MEME, and what happened previously was serious, and i can't take that shit.
The day with Mia, MC had drink 2 superpowerful drinks and he still felt ashamed of Giselle seeing him. I guess his inhibitions are deeply rooted, and he is always hoding back...(this writing)
AS for the game in general:
There are a lot of fake choices that dont matter,so dont put them in the first place, its annoying to have my expectations subverted all the time and have to make extra clics for no reason.
The player has little to no agency, and even characters in some moments are stripped of it, like when something is going on and they are interrupted and they have to stop. It would be awesome if they could make the choice of stopping or continue by themselves, not because of "plot convenient circumstances"
Too many fanservice renders (which also includes dreams,memories and illusions in addition to the magic buttons) way too many hours of rendering that could be put in useful plot related stuff.
Not convinced about the sex scenes, they feel like a sucession of prerecorded scenes, there is not emotion besides "making faces". No wondering hands, eye contact, anticipation, and so on, the little things, the magic that really sell the sex scene.
Mia route sucks, no buildup at all, just drama and beating around the bush, and the release results in a Silent fart (since the fart is used a lot in the game, its convenient)
The game definetly struggles building anticipation. Without anticipation, if you are 18 to 30ish you are gonna do maybe fine, but im guessing for older people a little extra is needed,and in my opinion this one is not delivering.
Did i mention subverted expectations and plot convenient circumstances? Well they actually make combo with the fake choices so you may pick one option thinking it will move things forward, but an interruption is gonna hapepen,and in the end the difference between one option and the other one might be one render.
FINAL thoughts
The game is a sucession of porn VN tropes, with full drama Mia route, and a lot of girls throwing themselves at the MC. They are avoidable, not like Sadie. For me the game is trashy, and im giving it it 2 stars cause some animations are interesting if they keep working on them and polishing them.
Not the best work of Inceton, definetly a cashgrab to "fix" the crap ending of SWM1.
(this one's too long and there may be typos and stuff, bear with me, im not an English native speaker)