Exocrine

Active Member
May 12, 2023
504
766
Oni must've really not been paying attention this time around. Or maybe the spaghetti code just caught up with the system and took the whole thing down.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zepheral

sleepingkirby

Active Member
Aug 8, 2017
519
759
Yeah sorry, should've been more clear. I'm running Windows 10, it shows nothing but the process "starts" as in yes the task manager shows a process, I tried running the exe in administrator mode and disabling my antivirus, still doesn't work
Hmm... Not much for me to go on. The good news is, it not dying immediately means its trying and starting. As in, it's trying to load stuff but can't get a window open.
Do other ren'py games act this way?
Does windows event viewer show anything for this application?
Which version of the game are you running?
Is there a log.txt or traceback.txt generated in the direction of the game and what does it say?
If you hold shift while starting the game, apparently, you can open up a menu to try different settings. Does it make a difference if you try different renderers?

Addendum:
Doing some googling, there are a few common things that can cause this:
1) "There is an issue that will cause a problem if the path to Ren'Py is not representable in the system encoding. (For example, if your user name is Russian and your system is set to Japanese, you might have a problem.)"
2) Video drivers not installed properly. ( )
 
Last edited:

Laritas

Member
Jul 10, 2023
188
347
  • Like
Reactions: kryanBR

Masal15

Member
May 17, 2023
179
92
Maybe you mean the channel:
Rogue-Like Modding


There is the community of
Rogue-like: Evolution - Prime Mod
https://f95zone.to/threads/rogue-like-evolution-prime-mod.99576/

and
Rogue-like: Evolution - Expanded Mod
https://f95zone.to/threads/rogue-like-evolution-expanded-mod.14865/
yes, but the expanded mod was abandoned, right? That mod is really interesting, it's a shame that it isn't updated with the latest game versions :confused:
 

Laritas

Member
Jul 10, 2023
188
347
yes, but the expanded mod was abandoned, right? That mod is really interesting, it's a shame that it isn't updated with the latest game versions :confused:
As I understand it on Discord, the Expand mod is on hold. Has not yet been abandoned. But don't pin me down on that. English is not my mother tongue :whistle:
 
Sep 7, 2019
65
120
If the game was more communicative about how far you can get in things, like relationships, sex, etc. I would have less a problem with tying relationship progress with story progress. A lot of the limits, etc. are not intuitive for me.
Yes! It is a work in progress, but I would say establishing a design language that players can understand how to interact with seems quite foundational. Especially about how they set and communicate boundaries: setting up players for goals they cannot achieve will understandably lead to frustration. They give you a list of goals but put you in the sandbox, forgetting, a little bit, that you will start to generate your own goals in this situation, some of which are easy to anticipate (especially in porn game). I think this is what RLE is doing so well: Oni seems to anticipate your goals, and put enough of a journey on the micro-plots, that you to a degree feel like you are making your own story. Magic of sandbox. Well, you can of course postpone gratification, make it adventure, encourage experimentation and discovery, but it needs a decent feedback loop (information).

I do agree with you in your review in that there are certain aspects of it that fills what RLE lacks. But it does feel unfocused.
The GUI being unintuitive, the story choices giving only an illusion of choice.
Hmm, focus. Tell me what you think about this: story itself, with the help of quest-log, that to a degree gives focus and even built-in walkthrough for sandbox itself. It is even in a sense in conflict with it (pure sandbox), limiting your free-play and self-expression.

Buuuut... Should we focus on the story? Can we? Is there enough of it? The real meat and potatoes of the game, the main gameplay loop, is still purely relationship/sex focused. So it is an interesting question what exactly is/are the functions of the story here? Is it only here to give a little bit of background and flavour? Let you use power in very limited circumstances? One thing it was doing so far is measuring/progressing passage of time and by extension advancing you to new stages of your relationships. So contextualization and framing? Interestingly enough, none of the girls so far was introduced in story events. There were no big changes in circumstances, major changing of status quo so far either. Mostly bridging iterative, progressively more open sandbox sections.

I'm wondering if the reverse relation should have been better. Rather than requiring chapter 3 to increase relationship, requiring a certain relationship level before being able to continue the storyline.
To a degree, it is like that already. One of the conditions (quests) to progress from one season to another is a total number of relationship points, IIRC.

I feel like The Null Hypothesis is what happens when no one tells the creator that this idea is number 1, 2 and 3. And, as much as I hate to say it, solutions that look for a problem, if it doesn't learn to pivot (correctly) or have a HUGE backing (i.e. too big to fail), often slowly get bloated and fail.
What I have seen in TNH thread so far looks like they are really open to feedback. I think they have some good ideas. I'm hopeful, they will be able to build something compelling. Games on this forum have unusual development, by mostly inexperienced but passionate people. If Bioware, Blizzard or Arcane can really go completely off the rails... As we've seen... It is a small miracle we have so many interesting games in this genre.

A lot of learning to become a programmer isn't just learning to write code, but to understand and find the essence abstract human concepts.
Not a programmer myself, but understanding of stories - of narrative arts - is kinda passion of mine. I can do a lot of philosophizing and psychologizing about it given opportunity, and conversation with you so far put me in very analytical mood :D

Which brings me back to why I'm so lenient on Oni's code. [...] I know people keep complaining "He's making so much money, the code should be better." But I can tell you, first hand, what he's done is pretty impressive. Because, again, how many google products have died during RLE's existence? And they had more money AND people behind it.
Even thinking about making my own game makes me often appreciate people that make these games a lot. In my opinion, there is a lot of quite unfair criticism and accusations. In large part because money is involved.

//I think I'll double post it in TNH thread, since they seem to appreciate feedback.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: splamo and Exocrine

sleepingkirby

Active Member
Aug 8, 2017
519
759
Yes! It is a work in progress, but I would say establishing a design language that players can understand how to interact with seems quite foundational.
Absolutely agreed. This is why a director of a game is so important. Like in animation, a director is the person in charge of keeping/maintaining the feel/style/etc. of a game. If the director's vision is vague, the work will turn out vague, even with the same footage, etc.

Especially about how they set and communicate boundaries: setting up players for goals they cannot achieve will understandably lead to frustration. They give you a list of goals but put you in the sandbox, forgetting, a little bit, that you will start to generate your own goals in this situation, some of which are easy to anticipate (especially in porn game). I think this is what RLE is doing so well: Oni seems to anticipate your goals, and put enough of a journey on the micro-plots, that you to a degree feel like you are making your own story. Magic of sandbox. Well, you can of course postpone gratification, make it adventure, encourage experimentation and discovery, but it needs a decent feedback loop (information).
Agreed. I also subscribe to Yahztee's idea of establishing a primary gameplay loop. And I think that's the difference. TNH has an idea and a plot, but not a good primary gameplay loop. This is how Oni "anticipates" your goals. He doesn't. He established a good/fun primary gameplay loop and then built things up from it and around it. You want to fuck the girl. You do things to get to that goal. All the other stuff around it is giving you a variation on that and/or helping with that.


Hmm, focus. Tell me what you think about this: story itself, with the help of quest-log, that to a degree gives focus and even built-in walkthrough for sandbox itself. It is even in a sense in conflict with it (pure sandbox), limiting your free-play and self-expression.
I could be wrong, but I feel like there's so little player interaction at that point that it's not really a game. If there's something telling you every answer or guiding you every step of the way, what's the player doing besides clicking the thing the game tell you to click? (Not a rhetorical question. Honestly asking to see if I missed something or to develop the idea further.)

Buuuut... Should we focus on the story? Can we? Is there enough of it?
You might have misunderstood what I meant when I said focus. I didn't mean what should the player focus on, but rather where the effort of the dev team was focused on. As we both have said before, games should have a good primary gameplay loop. I feel like the game is focusing developing on story and gui and art and locations and choices, etc. etc. and gameplay loop. But in doing all of those at once, it's not doing any of it well. That's what I mean by it lacks focus. It's doing all the other stuff kinda good, but not one thing about it is done well. Their effort is not focused on doing one thing well. Their focus is spread across several ideas and making it look appealing, but not play well.

The real meat and potatoes of the game, the main gameplay loop, is still purely relationship/sex focused. So it is an interesting question what exactly is/are the functions of the story here? Is it only here to give a little bit of background and flavour? Let you use power in very limited circumstances? One thing it was doing so far is measuring/progressing passage of time and by extension advancing you to new stages of your relationships. So contextualization and framing?
That's a good question. Because if this was a visual novel, all those would be good things. Very good things. But, to my knowledge, none of those contribute to it as a game. If they were to contextualize it to the game, it should progress/be brought up/be given with game progress. i.e. during the primary gameplay loop of relationship/sex. Again, I'm not saying these are bad things. But they don't contribute to the game as a game. They contribute to the story that gameplay happens to be in. Which is why they seem so antagonistic to gameplay.

Interestingly enough, none of the girls so far was introduced in story events. There were no big changes in circumstances, major changing of status quo so far either. Mostly bridging iterative, progressively more open sandbox sections.
Agreed. As we discuss this, I'm beginning to think TNH is better as a visual novel than as a game. Or at least take the Being A DIK approach where you have story accented with mini games and free roam sections.

To a degree, it is like that already. One of the conditions (quests) to progress from one season to another is a total number of relationship points, IIRC.
Correct. The caveat being that there's a cap on max relationship points per season. So season 1 might require like 1000 total relationship points and season 2 might be like 3000. But season one, even if you're able to get more, it won't let you get more than 1500 total relationship points or something like that. Which, again, if the gameplay loop is about the relationships, why is are the relationship points based off of the story and not the other way around? This tells me that the primary gameplay loop is the story, not the relationship.

What I have seen in TNH thread so far looks like they are really open to feedback. I think they have some good ideas. I'm hopeful, they will be able to build something compelling. Games on this forum have unusual development, by mostly inexperienced but passionate people. If Bioware, Blizzard or Arcane can really go completely off the rails... As we've seen... It is a small miracle we have so many interesting games in this genre.
This is a motto I've had since I became 18. I've said this at my first job and when I played FFXI and FFXIV and when I was in college and at my jobs as a programmer.
We all start out somewhere. ^^b

Not a programmer myself, but understanding of stories - of narrative arts - is kinda passion of mine. I can do a lot of philosophizing and psychologizing about it given opportunity, and conversation with you so far put me in very analytical mood :D
Alright, I'm gonna tell on myself a little here. I grew up reading scripts and storyboards for cartoons. In fact, if you're American (or even not) there's a good chance some of the scripts I've read as the cartoon was in development, you've seen. So much so that my first job was at an animation studio. During my teenager years, it's possible I've read more storyboards and scripts than I have actual books. So this is why I'm so experienced in this. I have A LOT of experience and have talked about this type of stuff A LOT with, often seasoned professionals, since I was very young.

Even thinking about making my own game makes me often appreciate people that make these games a lot. In my opinion, there is a lot of quite unfair criticism and accusations. In large part because money is involved.
Honestly, give it a shot. I recommend starting small, especially if you have no coding background. I can't tell you how many interviews or commentary I hear from seasoned game developers that will say things like "I didn't know about making primitive classes or the factory pattern. It makes the world of difference in making my game!" and I'm like "Yeah... they teach that in your second year of computer science." Basically, a lot of game makers eventually learn the programming chops it takes to code a good game, but it takes time, experience and trial and error. So start small. Like a sugarcube html game or even ren'py if you feel like diving head first into python. Chances are, your first games will suck or you'll make a lot of mistakes, but you'll learn important lessons from it. And then you'll be able to make better games. The line I was given when I was young is "You have 5000 (or some large number) bad drawings inside you. It's better to get them out as fast as you can so you can get to the good drawings." I'll give you a similar line (not that I'm a game dev. But saying this as motivation.) "You have 3 bad games inside of you. It's better to get them out as fast as you can so get to making the good games."
And, when in doubt, remember that
1) FNAF came from a bad Christian game
2) Untitled Goose Game was made by a bunch of friends.

Oh, if you decide to get into game dev, I recommend watching (if you don't know about these already):
  • Yahtzee's game dev diaries
  • Masahiro Sakurai's youtube channel (no surprise. Sleepingkirby recommends the creator of the Kirby game's youtube channel)

side note: Python is a popular language, but I have to say that python, despite popular opinion, don't breed the best programmers. The language often acts too much as a crutch for the people using it to expand into really good programming. If you want to learn to be a good programmer, I'd recommend another language. If you want to learn to make games, it's an alright language. (as for which language to learn to be a game dev... I'm not the person to ask.)

//I think I'll double post it in TNH thread, since they seem to appreciate feedback.
Good luck.
 

Exocrine

Active Member
May 12, 2023
504
766
You're right. It's not a game. It's an experience. Something far better. And the reason why most people keep giving Oni money, despite their grievances. Has one person stepped up and even tried to give us a better game? No. Not one. Ok. Stop. Put that Null Hypothesis away. It has nowhere near the amount of player interaction that RLE does.
https://f95zone.to/threads/rogue-like-evolution-v1-5h-oni.14/post-13070598
 

SpikyHair

Member
Nov 13, 2019
363
659
Hopefully an update within the next 47-years remembers to put the Boom Boom in the boom-boom game.
You have my... uh... wand!

That last image reminds me once again how much of a moral travesty it is that no WallStreetBets chad has yet bothered to trickle down for a cultured game with Ganassa as the lead artist.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
Last edited:
4.40 star(s) 149 Votes