The good:
-Lots and lots of content. The main story is relatively short, but there are hundreds of side quests and mini quests, not to speak of the three DLCs.
-Name a fetish you like. This game has it.
-Decent story (up to act 2). It's the usual stopping-the-dark-lord plot, which is executed well.
-(Major) characters have solid, consistent personalities (Tishtyra being morally very good, for example)
The bad:
-The whole world feels rather isolated to major events. A literal dark god went kaput and not a single guy in summeredge is talking about it. It's as if the dark god going kaput doesn't really matter at all.
-Very strange character development, mostly about Meredith. In the prologue she's a simple shopkeeper, several quests later she's fucking a horse. And a dog. I'm all for corruption, but this was waaay too fast and unexplainable.
-Bugs and typos (in my experience mostly minor, but annoying nevertheless).
-Act III is just total nonsense in my opinion. In Act II Murkhal is kaput, that should be the end of the main story. Meanwhile, in Act III, we're treated to a bunch of courtly intrigue set up by those who took Murkhal's shards (or something like that), which is totes fine if only there were some groundwork done for that on the previous Acts. Nobody knows what Cinkahn or Yakotin even is before Act III. Act III should just be a DLC like Emek's Rest, then maybe it can work.
Personal pet peeves and comments:
-For goodness' sake, the protagonist killed the freaking death god. You know, the god whose faction was kicking the wood elves' arses, manipulated the dwarves, sowing discord among the nexilim, and so on? And those council-of-whatever in Cinkahn had the galls to taunt the protagonist.
-Very weird distribution of repeatable sex scenes. You'd think repeatables are reserved for main characters like Meredith, Ruksana, or Clawyn, but no, the (as far as I know) three characters who get repeatable sex scenes are:
1. The unnamed slave you get after becoming wrath
2. Farm origin mom
3. Some ancient dwarf sex robot
EDIT: Alright, I did find a few more, with similarly strange distribution:
4. Threesome with the Succubus and Rulwe
5. Meredith's titjob
6. Xyless slave throne scene
-Would really like to see other factions' fight against Murkhal. We know the wood elves were fighting a losing battle against Murkhal and the (good) orcs are fighting the bad orcs (until the orcs just said, 'fuck it' and rebelled), but what about factions like the Church in Vesunna, or Novos and Orilise (after their situations were resolved)?
-Some quests make sense. Become Wrath (an orc champion) and you get some gold, bed that you never use because you have a freaking castle, and a slave. Some don't, like how to get enough loan money to rebuild a ruined city you just need to ... go down a mine and grab three crystals. Yeah. Sure.