I mean i dont think he is entierly wrong. Not trying to hate here, it could well be that you guys spend a ton of effort on the remake so far, but all we have seen are walls of text about whats planned and like 4 renders.
And while i wouldn't call it milking it is strange to open a patreon before even having a short release or demo to show. And lets be real the only reason this flies is because you guys reuse the name of a small but well liked game. Saying things like "how about you subscribe to see what we are up to" is also a red flag. We have to pay to even see what is sold? Thats just weird. Just my 2 cents.
That's a far more polite way of voicing your concerns, so thanks for that.
I am not sure why someone remaking an abandoned game is a red flag, but maybe you were inferring that we were trying to ride the coattails of the previous game's popularity. The reason we're remaking it is
absolutely because it was popular with myself and the other devs, and thought it deserved new life. The problem with the idea of us reImagining the game being a red flag is simply this - I only know of maybe one or two games that were ever remade [and I'm not talking about remaking to a different software like ren'Py]; even then, those games had a single update before fading away.
We're devoted to carrying this game forward over at least the next 2-3 years - and that's a deeply conservative number; there is an enormous amount of content to explore, and we want to explore it all. We want
all of you to be able to explore it all.
As for the second 'red flag' let me point out that I am not suggesting that everyone needs to subscribe. Maybe elect
one of your number to sub at the 1 dollar level, see that there are images and posts spanning back over almost 2 years, and report back to everyone here the results of their low-rent-recon. We keep a lot of the images behind the paywall for a variety of reasons, not the least of them is scraping.
And yeah, it's taking longer than I hoped it would; there is a lot of stuff to remake and, as I noted before, this is our first effort as a dev team, and most of us come from fields outside of game creation and have bills to pay, real life jobs, and lives that require us to carve out time to create. That's a large part of the reason for the delay, the other being that - being new - we are essentially teaching ourselves to do things that really haven't been done in the way that we are doing them.
We are absolutely unswerving in the idea of
not putting out some low-grade pos that isn't worth the time even mentioning the title of. I love this game; why dafuq else would I spend more than 2 years of my free time in trying to assemble a quality remake?
I readily admit that I used to use this site to download content to see if it was worth my patronage [if it was, I sub'd; if not, I deleted the game and moved on]. Most devs loathe this place, because of the generally entitled behavior of contrbutors who think their opinion - without financial support - carries any weight. I think it has value, but I am definitely in the minority among the development communnity. I am not suggesting that you need to be 'grateful' or anything that I'm posting, but you might want to reflect on why most devs don't post here. I am here, interacting with you, and being called a thief is a pretty shite way to encourage me to keep coming back to keep a pirating community up to date about a game that they will probably never pay for, never support in any way.
I do it because maybe after playing it, you'll do as I did; you'll want to see more and support the game. Plus, I usually like talking to people who like the same stuff I do. All I ask is that people make an effort to remain polite.
Jack Oh