Others Saria Reclaimed Remake [v0.16.1.0] [UnfetterSangria]

3.00 star(s) 1 Vote

Egoria

Newbie
Mar 9, 2023
34
8
Things that I, personally, would like if you continue making this remake:
1 - SOUNDS, and i'm not talking about the fight sounds if you know where i mean :^
2 - When the ero picture appears you should be able to CLICK for it to dissapear, not press Enter, Space or something like these...
3 - I only started the remake but I don't rly understand how this card thingy work, cuz in the main game you have a lot of cards off the start with the energy system, but here, you have 1 card, and even if you get more cards, the turn is over and they just dissapear...

Bugs i noticed:
1 - first bug i noticed at the start of the game is the npc near the first camp, he just crashes your game if you start a fight with him...
2 - for some reason every npc is attracted to her mouth and not any other body part... Only. Mouth.
 
Last edited:

Gierka

Member
Dec 2, 2017
203
173
Remake, what's wrong with the original game?
The original dev made a game with good promise, had a change of mind, remade it into a card game nobody wanted, then... had a change of heart and remade it AGAIN into an even worse card game.

Now you got at least two randoms trying to salvage assets from the original three(?) games and make something playable.
Probably.
 

BigBiggieBig

Member
Jan 6, 2019
334
922
The original dev made a game with good promise, had a change of mind, remade it into a card game nobody wanted, then... had a change of heart and remade it AGAIN into an even worse card game.

Now you got at least two randoms trying to salvage assets from the original three(?) games and make something playable.
Probably.
The problem is neither one of them has any 'vision' for what to do past importing previously-made assets by Velm, the best bet would be to train an AI on his artstyle and use that, but that requires some knowledge of how to *actually* use AI as opposed to opening a browser-based generator and typing "Big tittus" and calling it a day.

High-effort AI generation is actually quite easy on the eyes and might be passable, other than that I'm not sure what they could do to add content, hiring a different artist to make art is probably not going to be feasible without financial support, so I'm a bit confused as to what the thought process is.

Would be nice to hear from one of them regarding how they want to approach development, but so far it's been a bit silent.
 
May 4, 2024
17
156
The problem is neither one of them has any 'vision' for what to do past importing previously-made assets by Velm, the best bet would be to train an AI on his artstyle and use that, but that requires some knowledge of how to *actually* use AI as opposed to opening a browser-based generator and typing "Big tittus" and calling it a day.

High-effort AI generation is actually quite easy on the eyes and might be passable, other than that I'm not sure what they could do to add content, hiring a different artist to make art is probably not going to be feasible without financial support, so I'm a bit confused as to what the thought process is.

Would be nice to hear from one of them regarding how they want to approach development, but so far it's been a bit silent.
Actually, I answered this in a previous comment here. There are no plans to continue. This ends were the 15.2 version ended, unless Velminth joins in.
 
Last edited:
  • Sad
Reactions: BigBiggieBig

The_Thiccness

Member
May 20, 2022
144
199
the game was good in the first versions, but got ruined in the recent ones, the remake for what i get it is trying to bring back the first versions gameplay who was objectively better
It's actually bringing back the second versions gameplay, the original gameplay was a Karryn's Prison fighting system with skills and talents. He changed to the card game system after about a year then ended with a VN with card game added. The original concept was the debatable best version for those of us who came for the Karryn's Prison-like gameplay and stayed for the more attractive protagonist.
 

Susan Xandera

Active Member
Jul 13, 2017
780
1,029
It's actually bringing back the second versions gameplay, the original gameplay was a Karryn's Prison fighting system with skills and talents. He changed to the card game system after about a year then ended with a VN with card game added. The original concept was the debatable best version for those of us who came for the Karryn's Prison-like gameplay and stayed for the more attractive protagonist.
Same here, came for the KP style gameplay to see how this dev improves on it/gives it its own spin. Then immediately dropped it as soon as the card mechanics came in out of nowhere. I was on the fence about trying this remake until you pointed out it brings back the card mechanic. Saved me time and effort on downloading but good luck to the guy working on this remake if you do your own thing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: p0np0n and Dr. Coom

Rexizor

Member
Mar 4, 2021
174
84
If you're going to stick with the card system instead of the RPG system, you should probably make it so that you start out with literally any choices. Like, at the basic level, you draw one card per turn, and can play one card per turn (not counting 0-costs), which is essentially no choice, since why would you ever want to not play your card? And you might think you can play the "regain energy" card to get 2 extra cards to play on later turns, but in this version, you discard at the end of your turn, so that part of the card's ability is completely useless. Also, maybe put a warning on the insta-defeat enemy on the far left? In the base game that's a friendly(?) NPC, so I assumed it was in this too.
 

Hollowbankai

Newbie
Sep 12, 2018
98
91
please don't be dead
This is actually dead the op doesn't have the intention to update this with new content.

" Actually, I answered this in a previous comment here. There are no plans to continue. This ends were the 15.2 version ended, unless Velminth joins in. "
 

iamnuff

Well-Known Member
Sep 2, 2017
1,669
1,214
Well the whole game was made with stolen art, so of course the attempt is going to have to stop when he runs out of assets to reuse.

That's the problem with trying to make something out of other people's stuff.
 

Dupson

Member
Dec 15, 2018
134
250
This is actually dead the op doesn't have the intention to update this with new content.

" Actually, I answered this in a previous comment here. There are no plans to continue. This ends were the 15.2 version ended, unless Velminth joins in. "
oh that's sad..

Well the whole game was made with stolen art, so of course the attempt is going to have to stop when he runs out of assets to reuse.

That's the problem with trying to make something out of other people's stuff.
how can you give a fuck about stolen assets on piracy forum also if someone would use other person art it would mean that he was better and person who made art doesn't know how to propely use his own art making it worthless saria could be great game but dev just don't know how to make games and all of his art is waste of time
its like giving monkey paint and brush monkey would put brush in their ass and drink paint and fucking die from poisoning but if you give it to someon minimally talented in arts he would create something
i'm just trying to say that any game from vel won't succed or even complete because he's monkey that don't know how to propely use his own art
but he is to proud to create game with someone else and share the praise
 
  • Haha
Reactions: O&M's

iamnuff

Well-Known Member
Sep 2, 2017
1,669
1,214
how can you give a fuck about stolen assets on piracy forum also if someone would use other person art it would mean that he was better and person who made art doesn't know how to propely use his own art making it worthless saria could be great game but dev just don't know how to make games and all of his art is waste of time
its like giving monkey paint and brush monkey would put brush in their ass and drink paint and fucking die from poisoning but if you give it to someon minimally talented in arts he would create something
i'm just trying to say that any game from vel won't succed or even complete because he's monkey that don't know how to propely use his own art
but he is to proud to create game with someone else and share the praise
I can't understand most of what you're trying to say.
Use grammar.

As for why I give a fuck about stolen assets, it should be fucking obvious. I already spelled it out for you in my previous post.

"The problem with stealing assets is that eventually you run out of other people's art."
Dumbass.

I don't give a fuck about the piracy aspect. I care because Vel could fucking draw. When he needed new images, he just drew more images.
(To say nothing of other creative aspects like writing, worldbuilding or dialogue.)

This guy can't draw, or at least he can't properly copy Velminth's style, so all he can do is reuse existing art until he runs out and then give up.
Which is exactly what happened.

Rearranging other people's assets like lego pieces is easy. Actually creating whole new stuff to use is much harder.
Until you can clear that hurdle on your own, you can't do anything with a half-finished product except reuse the pieces to make make another slightly worse but equally half-finished product.

"There are no plans to continue. This ends were the 15.2 version ended, unless Velminth joins in. "
Yeah, cos he needs Velminth do handle all the parts that require actual creative skill or talent.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KJay9051

Hollowbankai

Newbie
Sep 12, 2018
98
91
I can train an AI model for his artstyle that's not difficult at all, but the question would more be "Is this the right way to go from here ?". I think it's morally questionable to use AI to copy someone artstyle and use it for a public project. I already trained a model for his character about a year ago which also kind of copied his artstyle.. I never shared it though.
 

Kiro4139

Newbie
Feb 25, 2021
35
7
16.1 version

Your equipped accessory doesn't get deleted if you do something like switching from Core Tenets with 2 slots to 1 slots, or 1 slot to 0 slot. Which is very nice. Always hated that part about the original.
Showing the stat changes as you hover over different Tenets is helpful. Don't know what decides the color, cause -20 Willpower is red, but +0.25 blunt damage is also red. Thought it was buffs green, and debuffs red, but it seems like each Core Tenet gets a different color for it's stat changes?
Can you make it display the name of each Core Tenet?
A note for right click to close message log would be nice. As well as left click being able to close combat end screen.



Bug
Main menu. Game is windowed. Opened options, adjusted sound effects and background music volume to half, clicked accept. It made the game window smaller. Does the same thing if I just open options and click accept. Options > Cancel does not do this. If I leave the window small and do all of that, it doesn't change the size.

Combat log might need to be longer vertically. Long sentences like "Saria hits Roughman A for 2 blunt damage, inflicting 1 stacks of Daze" only show "stacks of Daze" until I expand the combat log. "stacks" should be "stack" if it's 1. It also doesn't have spacing between the sentences, so you can see the bottom of the words above it. Stuff like enemies doing lewd stuff and corruption increasing has the same issue. Skips to the next line too fast to read. There's also stuff like
"Saria is disgusted by Enforcer's comments about her
lips.
Mouth Corruption increased by 4!"
Which takes up 3 lines.

"Exited" status should be "Excited"
Corruption level unlocking scenes doesn't work, all scenes are unlocked. Corruption perks also don't increase sensitivity.
 

ConfusedCube

New Member
Apr 5, 2024
14
10
This guy can't draw, or at least he can't properly copy Velminth's style, so all he can do is reuse existing art until he runs out and then give up.
He can easily generate the art by using AI, which is freely available for everyone to use on CvitAI. And the art also looks exactly like the original ones. I don't know whats the problem here.

The model is . (Don't know if this is the one Hollowbankai is talking about) :
I can train an AI model for his artstyle
And the generated images, for example are:

SD5J5VZBA01ZV8ZZQ2W3X18KA0.jpeg 28093361.jpeg 28093363.jpeg
created by:
 
3.00 star(s) 1 Vote