The thing was, he had it, he had the formula at the very start back when it was just a typical RPG.
It had scenes, amazing art, poses, multiple-partner capability, fetishes, battle-fuck, customisability, humour, intriguing story, even voice acting! All alongside numerous differentiating coded lines of dialogue and descriptions to keep actions and repeated acts fresh. He then added a minigame and sure it was buggy but it showed immense promise, this was going to be the next Karryn's Prison and shoot this guy to the stars. He HAD it!
Then he just 180ed, began stripping away everything that made the game better than another bland VN, and just focused on making a bland VN, and we lost all of it. But what we had originally was so good, Velminth could return tomorrow with a tiny update to the old Saria (either skill or card based, either was fine) with a few new scenes, new skills and a teaser for upcoming minigames or jobs, and he would soar again. There would obviosly be some flak to take, but if he did so, and showed he would stick with it and just keep going, even after everything that's happened to now, people would still be jumping on every new update for Saria Reclaimed again.
That's how good it was, that's why people still keep coming back to this thread after all this time, and it's a damn shame we lost it =/