Okay, so I have reached the end of the 0.1 version, which seems to be the current one. I am unsure what I have missed along the way - for example, I don't see a pregnancy option so far. So presumably I took a "wrong" turn somewhere.
But comments on what I've seen/played ....
A general comment is that it seems harsh to me to wade in with what may be destructive criticism, especially if you are playing for free. You don't have to like, but you also don't have to play. ~ And it seems a pity to discourage a developer's efforts, especially if they are relatively new in the field.
On to details. I think I'll start with a few (I hope constructive) criticisms, then move on to the praise. Reversing the usual process, perhaps.
1) I would agree the incest theme is very recurrent, a wee bit obsessive. Sometimes it reads/feels like "DADDY DADDY DADDY ..."", which may be a big turn-on for some, but is a turn-off for others (such as me). I would sort of wish for a "Non-Incest Patch" ....
or more seriously, a mode of equally heavy sexual involvement without the psychological triggers of father-daughter infatuation. As (e.g.) DfD has always offered, I think.
2) I also agree the Daddy in the story looks more like a sibling, even of twin age (19-21), which makes for further disorientation.
It would be nice if players had the option of just making that lucky guy just a college mate on summer break, or something.
3) The super-donkey dick. Well, that is grotesque. On the other hand, I take it in the spirit it's presumably offered. A joke, and a sort of revenge for all the sex games where the women are depicted with mammaries so mahoosive, they'd actually fall over forwards if they ever tried to get up and walk. Or stand.
Grotesque, but hey, comic relief or something.
4) I agree too that some of the climaxes for the girls seem endless. Don't get me wrong. Great, in games as in reality, if a girl's ecstasy is prolonged, repeated and above all enjoyable. But in this game, it seems in places a really long drawn-out process - you'd just wish she'd get to the point a few frames faster. This (in the game) may again be a reaction to a tendency of many male-ejaculation-centered sex games, where it's Wham, Bam, Thank You Mam, and all over in a few frames. But maybe here it becomes unnaturally extended in places - and so goes from one extreme to the other.
Maybe female players experience this differently. But it has a blue-balling effect - cum on girl, for heaven's sake - for at least this male
5) Whoever created the game gives an impression of high intelligence and sensitivity. The dialogs are articulate, detailed, well observed from nature, intellectually solid too. But oh, how wordy they can be at times, especially at times of greatest sexual arousal: putting into drawn-out verbal description what the images are already making clear enough. I like articulate texts. I love intelligence and sensitivity in sexual areas. But you have to beware killing the passion with overlong verbal accounts.
To use a bit of hyperbole, there are times where a simple "Ohh, Ahhh, Ohhhhhhhhhh .... YEAHHHH!" can beat something like: "I am now coming to the most inexpressible climax, envisioning my Daddy entering my vaginal passage and delivering immense consignments of high-viscosity semen into that particular part of my anatomy".
6) A few criticisms of this game on Newgrounds are based on there being no decisions (options) the player can take.
In fact, the downloadable version there, as here, does feature some player choices. Personally, I'd wish for a few more, although I realize that always makes more work for the developer, greater capacity also for the game and its download, etc. And of course the greater likelihood the player will miss out on some juicy possibilities in the game, unless these are alerted (e.g via Walkthrough). Options and alerts/Walkthrough are the best combination, when available. I know it's asking a lot.
On the other hand, very good:
1) Storyline is neatly woven. I really like the effort to construct an effective sequential storyline with the girls, and it works well.
2) The perspective is more "traditionally female" than many games. Meaning: feeling, mood, atmosphere, surroundings, contingency all matter quite a lot. Beautiful bodies yes, but it's not just an anatomical lesson. That is good, and a big plus. (The downside was already mentioned: the occasional wordy protraction of orgasms!)
3) The girls are sensational, both bodies and psychologies (daddy-complex apart, but that's already been mentioned). Zoe in particular, despite her strange android eyes (a common feature of hi-spec games such as this, I can certainly live with it).
4) The artwork is amazing. The modeling of Zoe's body in particular, the skin toning, and perhaps most of all, the incredible detail in her (nicely tousled) hair. How fantastic.
And hard to do, a labor of love. Her sister, Hannah? (or did I misremember her name?) is very sexily shaped and colored too, even if not quite so exquisitely contoured as Zoe as an integrated female body.
As others have said, the overall banner/splash, of the two sisters becummed facing each other, is indeed sensational. The whte stuff on Zoe's breasts looks a bit like whitewash or paint, but her breast itself, and the two dueling cumfaces, wow! And Zoe's hair.
5) Great signs of imagination, technique and promise.
While six "negatives" and five "positives" may look like an overall bad balance, those positives weigh more heavily, and all but two of the negatives are more comments than seriously bad criticisms.
Keep it up!!
)