Dr. Mick
Member
- Nov 21, 2017
- 497
- 1,112
It would certainly make for an interesting "What If" story. One where Frank and Jess raise the girls because Shannon is gone.Yes, Frank can be exhausting at times, but I think a lot of his problems stem from the following:
His first wife, his true love and best friend dies in an accident because a drunk party girl with rich parents thinks she has to drive her car around. And she never gets punished because the party girl's father greases the court like an oil sardine. On top of that, there's apparently survivor's guilt because it wasn't him who went shopping, but Jess. He was never really able to come to terms with it, partly because the money probably wasn't there and partly because he had to look after his daughter. Then there's probably the stigma of psychotherapy. But since he now has a trusting, friendly relationship with Vanessa, he should perhaps talk to her about it.
Shannon. The woman not only brought her own children down, as we saw in Lilith's and Becca's side stories, but also Frank. I think Frank may even have subconsciously known how bad his marriage was at a certain point, didn't want to give it up, if only so Abby could continue to have a mother figure and he didn't want to let Becca and Lilly down. He had spent about 5 years with Becca and Lilly by the time Becca's side story takes place, enough time to see what Trevor's disappearance had done to Lilly in particular.
I think in a scenario where Jess never died but Shannon and her daughters ended up with Jess and Frank for story reasons, Frank would still be a more reactive person, but because he never had to deal with Jess's death and was never dragged down by Shannon in a rather messed up marriage, he would be someone with a lot less self-doubt and fear of failure. Additionally, he would have a partner by his side that he can absolutely trust.
I would love to see a side story like this where Jess would then verbally kick Lilly's ex-boyfriend's ass in a scene after she finds out he cheated on Lilly. Becca called herself a mama bear in an Update, but I don't think that's anything compared to what Jess would do to someone who hurts one of “her” girls.
That would change the dynamic quite a bit, though it would also likely eliminate the whole harem story. As we're seeing in Becca's side story, part of the reason the plan came about was because she recognized that Shannon is a bad person, and that they all deserve better.
How different the story would be if they already had a loving family, rather than having to save themselves from Shannon's abuse.
Would Becca still develop the same feelings? If she did, would she tell Jess? With Jess in the picture, would she encourage the idea or be opposed to it?
While we generally know that Jess was a better person, we really don't know that much about her outside some dialogue and a couple flashbacks.