I did not say she can't love her sister while she jealous. I said it was not jealousy it's just sibling rivalry. She does not allow anyone but herself to badmouth her sister even if it was MC. Like I said she acts to same towards Astrja before and after she has romantic interest in MC.
Nox is a witch in her eyes. When her father asks her to get Nox's help, she says from that witch, you can't trust her etc. MC was not present at that conversation since he was on a raid. Was she jealous of Gertrude or her father? She simply does not like Nox and find DR members weird.
She has brief conversation with Mathilda when she was with MC at the market and she was not acting jealous at that interaction. Though what I meant there, her future interactions with other LIs beside Astrja to be sure about whether she is jealous or not.
At least we agree, harem is not gonna happen on Astrid path.
Like I said, it is my opinion you can take it as you like not gonna try to convince you.
For me, I probably should have worded the previous post a bit better;
"Astrid can still have sibling rivalry with Astrja and love her as a sister while being jealous of her."
I mean.... why would she be acting differently though especially given the events that happened?
Even if we assume Astrid is jealous, after we build both relationships with her and Astrja up as LIs, there were no scenes post-book creation scene between them which were significant enough with MC in between to incite their rivalry (and jealousy) - given the only proper scene they share after that was when she sees off MC and her sister off on that Jarl Harek (oof, hope I'm remembering the name right) raid.
She says to MC and her sister "Look after each other" or something along those lines - but that doesn't really make me think 'Just cause she's a caring sister, that equates to her not being jealous of relationship her sister may have with the MC.'
A person can still be a caring/decent person (given her sister might get killed) despite having a negative emotion such as jealousy especially when it comes to their kin.
The game moved to more "end of the world Ragnarok" danger arc, and away from the living daily lives in the early part, so I do feel it's irrelevant to compare the After part since all characters' heads are in another thought right now.
But given what we've seen between Astrid and Astrja, I'd say jealousy between them is quite plausible - at least that's my interpretation, anyway lol.
Fair enough on Astrid's reaction to Nox.
With Mathilda, I think her jealousy isn't just necessarily towards MC & Astrja's specific romantic relationship. It felt like whole lot of different things come into play with her;
- Astrja being the chieftain's daughter (so higher position in heirarchy)
- Astrja being more respected in the village
- Astrja being more popular and wooed by more men in the village
- MC not paying as much attention to her
So, a bit of mixture of envy and jealousy.
I'm a bit sucker for flawed characters so Mathilda is my favorite out of WW, and I'm kinda looking forward to where her character goes.
To BB? Ngl, can be quite interesting, given she feels underappreciated with the WW.
Heh, I wasn't trying to convince you either; just stating my pov, nothing more nothing less.