At the current moment, I'm on the fence about what I should rate this. So I guess we'll see by the time I've sorted out my thoughts in this review. I do want to say something, and I'll make it big and bold for those that don't understand this.
THIS IS HOW AN INITIAL RELEASE SHOULD BE. SPEND TIME MAKING IT LOOK GOOD. A DECENT UI AND USER EXPERIENCE. AND HAVE MORE THAN 5 MINUTES OF BAD PLOT TO START OFF WITH.
Was I subtle enough? Anyway, there's a lot of content from these first two releases. And there's a welcome lack of the garbage default RenPy UI and even some extras that I like to see. Also I'm happy that it's not a sandbox where after every interaction you have to click around the external view of the spaceship to find content. Was that too pointed? Anyway, the few times I see these qualities, I get excited and think "Hm. Maybe everything isn't terrible..." But then there's the writing.
I want to clarify, the STORY is fine. A little bit mystery, a little bit sci-fi it works. But the dialogue is tiresome. Any time there is even a hint at MC having any sort of conversation with someone that is possibly serious, the LOLSORANDOMANDWHACKY AI chimes in with "WOWZERS she's hot" or "Isn't sex the bee's knees?" type garbage. And to make it worse, there are three more characters just like that. I'm so tired of the Borderlands Tiny Tina/Psycho humor, it's just not charming. And it does this so YOU the player know "HEY this character is so hot/attractive/cute" instead of letting YOU the player think that on your own. THEY'RE ALL PORNOGRAPHIC DAZ MODELS OF COURSE THEY LOOK GOOD. I don't need 4... No, wait, 5 characters (Because MC constantly says it too) telling me that so and so is hot. It is just a given at this point.
So the story. The actual story is summarized in the OP. MC wakes up with 1 year worth of amnesia and is the only male on a female interstellar spaceship. The unfortunate truth is the "mystery" is just whether or not MC magically starts remembering the lost year of his life. And none of that starts until Day 5, so you have to listen to all of the horny dialogue ad nauseum until, during, and after all of the amnesia stuff. There's also someone "evil" on the ship that wants to take the AI in MC's brain. You know what I say to that? PLEASE. And you won't know who is the antagonist of this story, probably ever, because MC's dialogue solely consists of "I'm gonna get nudes" or "You are so attractive" so it's not like he'll try to figure it out. Outside of half-assed speculation. My best guess would be that it's Ishani or one of the few women that aren't immediately trying to sleep with MC. That or MC himself. My hopes is that this story ends with MC being jettisoned into space, it would be funny.
I also think that ending would be fitting because more than one girl in the story has said that MC just acts how he thinks the girls want him to act. Which will hopefully cause problems down the line. Anyway I'm talking about the non story too much, the characters. I'm not going to name anyone, I'm just going to list personality types. There are 4 LolRandom horny types, 2 innocent virgin types, 4 bored housewives (one is work focused, one is motherly, the last two are horny), 1 sheltered emo, one hates you, one is robotic and makes bad jokes, a virgin sex addict, the new girl, and the lady on her way to your ship. They are all just different flavors of the day nothing more and nothing less.
The more I read this VN the more it makes me mad. And the writer either just makes a bad joke, talks about how hot or horny the MC/girls are, OR breaks the 4th wall saying that the writing is bad or that RenPy just made a transition. Or something along those lines. Just because you say that your writing is bad, IN YOUR WRITING, that doesn't exempt it from actually being criticized for being bad. And the harem talk, my god. I can tolerate a joke or two in a harem game using that word, but with this update, the word "harem" went from being used a couple times to hundreds. And it's dumb. And the nightly recaps. There's a certain other game, that I'm not allowed to mention due to rules, that does nightly recaps too. Both of them DO NOT NEED THEM. I don't need to hear MC and quirky AI recount the times they looked at girls that day. Nor do I need to see what pose Paige decided to make on the bad. It's not funny, I don't have the memory of a goldfish, and I don't enjoy the padding.
There's also the issue of the force pausing. I don't need to see the 4 different renders you made for a kissing scene for 3 seconds each. That is absurd. And there is also a game breaking bug in I think day 5, the second DM session with Umiko just flat out crashes the game. And it's not like I have edited the game in any way, that's fresh playthrough. every time i clicked her name, bam.
TLDR - After actually thinking about all the complaints, I'm just gonna have to give it a 3. A lot of planning and effort went into making this a good looking user experience. But the writing is bad. Like uber mondo bad, to get my point across. And now that is the one thing that will not change so my opinion won't either. I guess I am like MC in this game, I like to look at it, but every time anyone opens their mouth I don't actually care or want to listen.