I know I dont want a dick on Eve in any form.I don't think Futa was ever on the table. Those who don't like trans Eve, would not like futa Eve either and those who like trans Eve because of her story would probably be bothered by adding some fantasy futa stuff into it.
At least I don't see a single reason to add that option, honestly.
As long as there are two separate routes, meh, it doesnt matter to me if there is a trans version in some alternate reality version I'm not playing.
And if a third full on futa route was added as an option, again as a route i could ignore? Meh, whatever.
But shoehorn in some stupid ass futa crap as the *only* route? That would just kill Eve's route for me just for the sake of "reasons".
And I wager i'm not alone in this. I dont see there to be anything for DC to gain to make such a retcon just cuz.