Ren'Py Summertime Saga [v21.0.0 wip.4468] [Kompas Productions]

[GaRbS]

These wouldn't happen to all be 2d games? I recognize some at least and may check out the others, but I don't the 3d look.

Yes, those are all 2d games.

6.Book 5: Untold Legend of Korra: Another Avatar game, worse than FET: -1
7.Insexual Awakening: Shota trash, taking off extra: -2

No, I refuse your trash opinions.

So your grand total comes to 3, as I see it. Now the real challenge, find 7 more WITHOUT listing a parody game. I'll allow parody characters(StS has them), but not a full parody game.

1-Monster Girl 100
2-The Sword of Succubus
3-Snow Daze
4-Town of Passion
5-Unveiling the Unknown
6-HuniePop
7-Eroico

At this point you're just being petty with your ultra specific requirements for a game to be compared to StS: "completed 2d adult sandbox non-parody non-Japanese game that is not part of a series of games and has art of a similar level of quality". Come on now.

 

[meh1995]

Snow Daze.....
Hot take:
DarkCookie has an infinitely better dev team than Outbreak Games
I'm still annoyed they're remaking the entire game instead of doing Tropical Daze

I agree, but at the very least Snow Daze is a finished game as of now. I do remember when people complained about the game because they didn't have updates for a couple of months. Like, oh boy, lol.

Don't know what the fuck you're smoking, but pass that shit my way. StS is WAY better than all of those games, with the exception of maybe Katawa Shoujo, which doesn't meet all my required stipulations. I don't get where this new narrative that the game is actually trash has come from. The game is fine, in its highest moments it is one of the best games on the site. It just hasn't updated in 3 years. That is its only major problem.

Because the standards for what makes a good game has changed in 3 years with more games being completed and having far more content than STS does. You are crazy if you think 4 Elements Trainer isn't better than STS, let alone games like Town of Passion. You might think this is something subjective, but FET has far more content than STS does, likable characters despite being a parody, two different routes with each book, and good art in general.

Hell, FET started development AFTER STS and it's already finished and a better product than STS currently is. The game is definitively not a bad game, don't get me wrong, the issue here is that there are already far better games on this site that make a fraction of what this scam does, finished or not. That's pretty frustrating.

Grant you, I didn't read the parody line, but I could go on:

1. Knightly Passion
2. Hentasia
3. Paradise Lust
4. S.H.E.L.T.E.R.
5. Confined with Goddesses
6. Sexy Quest
7. Paprika Trainer

Honorable mention to Tamas Awakening. And that not to mention unfinished games with more content than STS does, like Another Chance.

 

[RT5X]

true af

All bro had to do was hire a new artist but got lazy and used koikatsu lmao (KK is the easiest shit to use to pump out images)
Despite DC taking forever i'd rather wait long for another update than have a dev switch to KK lmao

 

[meh1995]

All bro had to do was hire a new artist but got lazy and used koikatsu lmao (KK is the easiest shit to use to pump out images)
Despite DC taking forever i'd rather wait long for another update than have a dev switch to KK lmao

It isn't even an issue with Koikatsu being cheap or not, is that you can feel there isn't even a little bit of effort put into it. Some KK projects can look pretty good if you invest enough time in making them look good.

 

[RT5X]

It isn't even an issue with Koikatsu being cheap or not, is that you can feel there isn't even a little bit of effort put into it. Some KK projects can look pretty good if you invest enough time in making them look good.
View attachment 3649156

I agree, ive been saying that on the IA thread before it closed lmao
IA2 just looks like a KK DLC lmao

 

[Slytherin͏]

DC earnings, currently doing nothing.

You must be registered to see the links

 

[Lorion2k20]

I think you and a lot of other people on here underestimate just how ambitious the game really is. If were really that simple why aren't there more? Name 10 completed 2d sandbox adult visual novels of the same quality. Hell, name 5. Hell, name any.

Not counting Japanese games. Name 10 western-made games, same requirements. Also, cannot be from the same series. You have 1 so far.

So your grand total comes to 3, as I see it. Now the real challenge, find 7 more WITHOUT listing a parody game. I'll allow parody characters(StS has them), but not a full parody game.

Lol... really? Went from "name any" to super specific requirements with your biased personal ratingsystem you're adjusting on the go real quick... hilarious.

For the "name any" pot: Paradise Lust

 

[CUNTBLAZER420]

Yes, those are all 2d games.
No, I refuse your trash opinions.
1-Monster Girl 100
2-The Sword of Succubus
3-Snow Daze
4-Town of Passion
5-Unveiling the Unknown
6-HuniePop
7-Eroico

At this point you're just being petty with your ultra specific requirements for a game to be compared to StS: "completed 2d adult sandbox non-parody non-Japanese game that is not part of a series of games and has art of a similar level of quality". Come on now.

1. Monster Girl 1,000: TwistedScarlett again, she just pumps that shit out.: +1
2. Sword of Succubus: Not even close to being similar, doesn't meet requirements: -1
3. Snow Days: Pure VN, doesn't meet requirements : -1
4. Town of passion: Lower quality art, RPGMaker, doesn't meet requirements.: -1
5. Unveiling the Unknown: TwistedScarlett is some sort of psychopath, for real: +1
6. HuniePop: Vaguely meets my requirements in some areas, I guess.: +1
7. Eroico: Again, completely different game type.: -1
You got 7 now. 3 if we discount TwistedScarlett games. I'm being petty, but its to make a point. There aren't a whole lot of completed games out there that you can compare to StS. You can't say how long something like it should take to make, because almost everything out there like it, is also in the exact same boat: unfinished.

Lol... really? Went from "name any" to super specific requirements with your biased personal ratingsystem you're adjusting on the go real quick... hilarious.

For the "name any" pot: Paradise Lust

Paradise Lust is hella mid across the board, but I'll give you a +1.

 

[Count Morado]

perhaps you should have.its bad enough when devs dont deliver-you dont contribute to this site.as i said youre just a sellf appointed mouth piece or is Kompass paying you.all your posts regarding abandoned tag youre countdown-all on you,sad really ,just jumping on the talent when you have none

Why the fuck are you obsessed with me? You're the one who seems to be giving my power within your life. Let me go. Let me be free. Stop giving me free rent in your vacuous head. Your comments don't even make sense.

Again, the post you made to me about me just before your last one shows that "you and I are essentially saying the same thing. I haven't changed my position." And yet you continue the attack.

 

[Count Morado]

Then why not hire a real project manager? From the impression I get here of his success he can probably afford to.

because he hates project managers and corporate deadlines. He is running his business the way he wants it run, even if we don't agree on his decisions. It's his business to run it how he wants. You wouldn't want people shoving their noses in your business if you were successfully doing what you wanted to do for a living and made good money doing it. That's why.

Whether or not I agree with how he runs his business is beside the point. It is his business. Not mine. Not yours. His.

 

[Black-Wolf]

I'd say Aurelia has any other 2D game beat. But that, of course, depends on if you count pixel art like that as 2D.

How did I forget about Aurelia?? Agree.

 

[j4yj4m]

How did I forget about Aurelia?? Agree.

Aurelia is so good, because it's well done and pretty uniqe. Though it is probably true, that many people struggle to find pixel art really erotic (at least that's how it's for me).

That kinda highlights this whole problem. People won't, as far as I see it, easily spend a lot of money on games which feature anime-like art (because there are just sooooooo many of them, everybody has played like 50+ and because that stuff is just everywhere), on RPGM-games (because most of them feel the same and they almost always feel dated) and on games which feature art that's too simple. Once you exclude these factors, there's honestly little left. If you then exclude some niche'ish concepts (like some themed trainer games) the alternatives become even fewer. Sure, there are some notable exceptions, but really not that many.

These last pages summerize that problem quite well. There aren't many actual 2D alternatives to SS around in the western market and as long as that's the case, games like SS and WaL! will still do very well.

There are many great and at times quite uniqe games in development (like just off the top of my head House Chores/Siren's games in general, Demon Deals, Night Driver, Quickie or Aurelia) and I'm happy to even pledge to some of them, but if you look at it objectively, they simply don't have the potential of SS to make money with the general public.

 

[Xupuzulla]

Lol... really? Went from "name any" to super specific requirements with your biased personal ratingsystem you're adjusting on the go real quick... hilarious.

For the "name any" pot: Paradise Lust

Paradise lust has to be the most underrated game on this site while Summertime Saga is the most overrated one.

 

[j4yj4m]

Paradise lust has to be the most underrated game on this site while Summertime Saga is the most overrated one.

I'm sure Paradise lust will be doing somewhat well on Steam and Itch. DC has never monetized any other platform but Patreon and as such his earnings will certainly be higher over there, while some other games to spread them across 3 or 4 platforms.

I wouldn't be surprised if for example Remtairy made more money/month than DC at times across all platforms, but because of the split we'll never know.

 

[Senigata]

I'd remove good girl gone bad and karryn's prison from that, but yeah, more or less that.

1. Insexual Awakening
2. Snow Daze
3. Zombie's Retreat
4. Town of Passion
5. Four Elements Trainer
6. Friendship with Benefits
7. Project X
8. Space Paws
9. Katawa Shoujo
10. Fucking Unteralterbach

Can even mention plenty of other unfinished games with more content and more quality. I'd say STS is actually bottom of the barrel when it comes to quality.

It's funny how revealing these type of lists are.

Paradise lust has to be the most underrated game on this site while Summertime Saga is the most overrated one.

Paradise Lust is pretty average. The art doesn't really stand out and the plot is pretty basic. Mind you, average =/= bad. A perfectly average porn game does exactly what it needs to do, provide people with stuff to fap to.

 

[harem.king]

Man, I wanna see someone say that about the church

do you live under a rock?
people have been saying this about every religion for a while now.

 

[ARCHoNE]

Artificial intelligence will become a captivating addiction worldwide in a few years, while manual art will acquire a slightly vintage allure... i particularly enjoyed some of the renders from Dall-e

 

[NatKill]

hey idk why it was marked the case but the game is very much not abandoned the development is just taking longer , you can check there discord i think they started a QA testing if i am not wrong ... so ya.. the game is still very much going i hope..

 

[vks017]

Artificial intelligence will become a captivating addiction worldwide in a few years, while manual art will acquire a slightly vintage allure... i particularly enjoyed some of the renders from Dall-e

We are many years till AI relegates manual art to a vintage allure. The current tech has been overhyped, its good at certain things but has glaring weakness compare to even mediocre artists. I agree it will be an addiction soon though.
For AI to compete with good artists we will need quite a big hardware jump that is above the current slow incremental gains we are getting right now.

 

[harem.king]

For AI to compete with good artists we will need quite a big hardware jump that is above the current slow incremental gains we are getting right now.

the problem isn't hardware, it is software.
throwing more hardware at the problem does not solve the fundamental issues of it being a mindless algorithm