Is the MC's sister/steps-sister/childhood friend cheating? I don't recall seeing her actually breakup with Brodie, and she's been getting pretty intimate with the MC. Any ideas on how Mr Dots is going to deal with that? I'm curious on what exactly will happen should Brodie find out that she was being intimate with the MC. But then again, she did say that they were in an on/off relationship, right? So would this be one of their breaks? I'm genuinely curious there.
Also, it should serve as no surprise if she is not a virgin. She's been in a somewhat serious on/off relationship for over 3 years. It'd honestly be pretty ridiculous if she'd held out for so long on the hope that she'd reconnect with the MC. I don't know that many girls that are still reserving themselves like that. But they do exist, so there's that. Her actions, thoughts, and even the dialogue give way to the fact that she is definitely experienced. Personally, I see no problem with that. As long as she wasn't a blazing harlot, then her not being a virgin should be ok. I'm assuming that Mr Dots made her cousin a LI specifically for the fact that our main LI would not be a virgin.
I actually like the fact that Mr Dots may in fact be writing her with qualities of a normal woman, and not some extremely pure maiden who rejects everyone but the MC. Her being 23, I as a woman myself, would be hard-pressed to believe that she's still a virgin. But I could be wrong, as I've also seen girls with the confidence she has absolutely deflate when it's time for the real thing.