This is a game I've grown to despise.
So, let's get the pros out of the way:
1) It looks great. Good options with the girls and they're all attractive
2) It seems natively written in english, and the writing is competent. The game neither suffers from bad english, nor does the writing fall flat, leaving you unsure of context, what it is trying to say, or how the characters are different.
If you are looking to turn on skip, hold down ctrl, click the right choices, and look for scenes to fap to, there is more than enough here to enjoy.
But these games offer a story and characters. We shouldn't just be giving it 5 stars because there is porn in it. And as a game, it falls apart for me, to the point where I, as I said, despise the game.
So, characters:
Your father. Typical military asshole dad for this kind of story. Never knew how to care, or be a father. Considering you play as him in the intro, you're lead to believe he's a good person, but when you play as his son you realize he's a serial cheater, never cared enough to be a father, and abandoned his daughter, and otherwise seems to lack redeeming qualities.
Ashley, your kinda-step-mom, and your sister's mother. No two ways about it, she's a whore. She slept with your married father. Sleeps with him again years later and then springs a mystery daughter on him. Goes from abject poverty to your father taking her in, taking care of her, giving her a chance to set the groundwork to make something of herself, and then she leaves, with her daughter, cutting you and dad off from her, and her off from her brother and father.
When meeting up with you, you learn that she dropped a business on her daughter that she knew her daughter lacked the skill, ability, money, or help to run, and expected her daughter to just sell it. Going as far as to say she never considered that it could be a burden and hurt her daughter. This is key to her character, she doesn't consider other people, whatsoever. She decided, as a late-middle aged whore does, to just bail on her daughter to discover herself. I've known people like that in real life. Always scum.
In a private meeting with her, she tells you about how much she enjoys sleeping around, and despite you being in a relationship at the time (more on that later), she encourages you to try the same.
She is a selfish, irresponsible homewrecker. And the only reason she is not still living in abject poverty is because she took what she needed from your dad, and left.
When talking of the hotel, one thing she says is that her parents left it to her, and she turned it down, because she didn't feel she owed them anything, and that she didn't want them to owe her anything in return. Keep in mind, with her parent's money and help available, she choose to live in abject poverty, and subject her daughter to it, just to avoid... what, letting her parents help, because she didn't want to feel she owed them?
Surely in that mindset, she feels the same about her own daughter. Her daughter owes her nothing, and she, in turn, owes her daughter nothing. She certainly lives that way.
Your sister. Look, this is an incest game. We all came here to nail sister. Too bad she is wildly unpleasant. Jealous over the most minor issues. Demanding. She manipulates you with lies to join her in the first place. Anything that even mildly inconveniences her involves her blowing up at people and yelling... usually you, the MC. She will dish out endless criticism, and can take none. Like her mother, she is selfish to the point of being cruel. She's the type of woman who will hear you open your heart and speak nothing but direct truth to her, and choose to try to read between the lines, make up her own mind over what you mean, or imagine lies and manipulations where there are none, and then lose her temper.
To me, she has no redeeming qualities. Between lies, manipulation, vanishing without a trace and leaving others to pick up the pieces, etc, she is just an obnoxious carbon copy of her mother.
And the fact that the game, which seems otherwise inclined to let you choose who you do and don't want, essentially force sexual encounters between you, is a huge sin.
These games should not force the player to fuck anyone. Let us choose. I hate her character, and I hate being forced to be closer to her, even if I choose to start over and intentionally pick all the wrong choices with her.
Nichole. Your GF. While appearing overbearing and unpleasant at first, it becomes clear she is more than that. She is stressed from money and work. She is stressed and anxious about MC leaving for 3 months. She loves the MC and wants a future with him, but finds herself in a mixed up situation.
So, she springs an ultimatum on the MC. Open relationship, or no relationship.
Earlier versions of the game gave a third option, where you turn her ultimatum down, stay together, and an option for a loyalty playthrough.
This was later removed. Now your options are to accept, and sleep around, cheating on her because it is what she wants because she feels the relationship is falling apart... or break up with her.
Like many other characters, she makes all the choices for you, and refuses to let you speak or tell your side. Even if you accept, MC thinks to himself how he thinks this is a bad idea, and is worried it will hurt things, but he doesn't say it to her. She seems worked up into thinking that either she gives you a hall pass for 3 months, or that you'll cheat on her anyhow. And the option for loyalty was removed, so the MC can't even tell her her fears are unwarranted and he is coming back to her. Either you agree to sleep around, or you break up.
Technically, she is free to sleep around too. Having ditched the loyalty path, the dev assured us that, don't worry, she won't. Great. So she suggests this, fails to find anything else, and is left alone, while I put my dick in everything because she said so.
For porn content, great. For story? It takes away agency from the player to choose to stay loyal, and excuses you to cheat while promising no NTR.
If there is a path where I can accept an open relationship, and a path where I can break up, why can't there be a path where these people, who have been together for over 5 years, just TALK, and calm her fears, and be loyal? It isn't like it takes away the option to break up, or the harem option, or even an option to swear to be loyal and then cheat.
The other girls either don't have much screen time, or aren't as interesting. I'm not into my step-cousin's slut mother. Or the twins and their plans to make me their next plaything. The asian girl gets minimum screentime, the church girl weirds me out. The girl with the food truck would actually be a great love interest in another story. So would the step-cousin. But both seem to be falling for you, which just means that your use of your hall pass would just leave them hurt.
And then there's your sister's boyfriend, Brodie.
How the game treats Brodie is criminal.
He is a decent guy, who your sister just treats like crap. She won't let him talk, won't let him explain himself. Because all she does is manipulate and use people, she feels that's what he is doing too.
We see ample cut aways to show he is trying to be reasonable, and he is being forced by his dad. To show he cares about his sister's feelings, and truly loved the MC's sister. How he felt bad for being used to get to her, and how he just wants to be better for her.
So, after the game chooses to build Brodie up as a decent guy, and someone our character, as a lawyer, would like to get to know, and maybe hear his side of things.... the devs seem to decide they made him too nice and built up too much sympathy towards him.
Brodie decides to change script, at the drop of a hat, and become cartoonishly evil, all because you and your sis hosted his sister's birthday party.
His father was going to ruin his sister's party. He was sympathetic to his sister and mad at his dad... until he found out his now-ex hosted her party instead. And so now he swears revenge.
Worst possible choice. Having a character who is adjacent to the antagonist, but be genuinely sympathetic, makes for a better story. This turn just totally shit the bed.
And seeing as I hate sis's character, I'd have rather had a plot option where, if I didn't pursue sis, I could meet Brodie, work out misunderstandings, and set the two of them back up. It isn't NTR if it is a character I rejected, and if I choose to pursue that path.
That could have made the story more interesting. Instead the character built so sympathetically is now Bond villian junior, for the sole purpose of bad storytelling.
This game pisses me off. And it does so, so much, because it has the bedrock foundation needed to have been fantastic, and instead chose to be shit.
My rating is based on the characters, the story, the fact that some choices seem burned in no matter what you do.
If these games were just here to fap to, a story dozens of hours or more isn't needed. The purpose of the games is to build a narrative, and I find the one provided to be lacking, or offensively callous, or just plain bad.