harem.king

Engaged Member
Aug 16, 2023
3,995
6,971
Hobo came, got laughed at by a bunch of kids, took it extremally poorly, and got put at his ass by MC. Then Ella shows up and shoo him away. The guy had no chance at doing anything, even if MC does not choose to help, as one of the kids was reaching to his blindfold, presumably to use his powers on him(kinda vague), and then MC is forced to do this anyway by "mystery forces". The end of an encounter, the guy knows beter now and fucks off into the distance.

After that she takes MC to the guy, guts him with a smile and unravels the "Transform others" power to MC. Why? What is justified here? The guy couldn't and wouldn't do anything to her or the kids, Charlie as a baseline would ensure that if nothing else, and she let him go the first time, didn't she? This was not defense of herself, or the runaway kids. Like, if a guy with multiple sclerosis, that barely even moves, attacks my girlfriend with a rubber knife over any reason, and she could defend herself, if not tear the guy apart - me scaring him away, then taking one of my buddies with me to track the guy, kill him for show and throw his body into a meatgrinder, just to explain to the buddy that the meatgrinder as a tool exists, and he has one in an attic ... Man, this is nothing but cruelty.
Just because THESE kids happened to have super powers, does not make it suddenly ok for the hobo to rob children with a knife.
He deserves the death penalty for that, and in some countries would receive the death penalty. At which point, as a condemned, he was an ideal subject for a lesson.
 

obibobi

Active Member
May 10, 2017
951
2,494
not to mention that there's a debate to be had about how strong Syla's imitation was when compared to the original (and not even just power-wise, Eiseth could survive some nasty wounds while Syla's copy easily broke).
One of the monsters hunts has you go after a memory monster, and Nico wanted you to engage it first because it may have made a copy of Malik if she did. I think it was said that the limitation was the power reserves of the creator.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SquallofNight

OnlineRando

Member
Aug 4, 2021
172
359
One of the monsters hunts has you go after a memory monster, and Nico wanted you to engage it first because it may have made a copy of Malik if she did. I think it was said that the limitation was the power reserves of the creator.
That's true, but I meant in the sense that Syla's Eiseth seemed awfully fragile when you consider that one of Eiseth's greatest weapons is arguably her survivability. Syla's copies, meanwhile, break easily, so I think that might have limited her ability to use Eiseth effectively.
 

obibobi

Active Member
May 10, 2017
951
2,494
That's true, but I meant in the sense that Syla's Eiseth seemed awfully fragile when you consider that one of Eiseth's greatest weapons is arguably her survivability. Syla's copies, meanwhile, break easily, so I think that might have limited her ability to use Eiseth effectively.
Maybe but I think more so that moment was to highlight Indra's overwhelming power, he say's himself that she's throwing opponents at him he's bested. It wasn't to give him drawn out battles but to show his clear superiority.

I also wouldn't say her survivability is her greatest weapon, at that level they are all incredibly difficult to kill, she survived in a very similar method to the MC's mom, willing the attack to have had no affect.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SquallofNight
Sep 12, 2021
286
547
Just because THESE kids happened to have super powers, does not make it suddenly ok for the hobo to rob children with a knife.
He deserves the death penalty for that, and in some countries would receive the death penalty. At which point, as a condemned, he was an ideal subject for a lesson.
There are countries in which rudely talking to your superior will get you in front of the firing squad, by the letter of the law. This is no argument, most civilized countries do not have death penalty at all. For the deserving part, I don't think trying to steal a bike from a kid sets one to be killed off by any margin. Threatening to get violent and harming a kid - oh, THAT may be, but he got put on his ass and left, maybe taught something. So, for me at least, at best he MAY deserve death, not is set to it. But I understand your point well, just I have much forgiving mindset.

But my point still stands about Ella, who didn't killed him for that, not even according to herself (I played this part again to refresh my memory). She killed him because he was stinking, and was the last person to negatively interact with her, indirectly but still. Not even to show the ability to transform others, she says she intended to show MC that anyway, even before he came. And when MC has a problem with that, to quote Ella "Yeah? Why do you care? It's just a fucking human."

The more I am in this debate about Ella being or not being just evil, the more I check and recollect the game, the worse she is than I originally thought.
 
Apr 17, 2024
223
966
Strength Eaters and Undines, what monster is the undines? i don't remember that one
I don't think we've actually seen them, just told that they were in the force field Malik was trapped in. Based on the name they would have water powers (an undine is a water spirit), which would have been useful for teaming with Strength Eaters.
 

One_Black_Sun

Member
Mar 27, 2020
136
297
I don't think we've actually seen them, just told that they were in the force field Malik was trapped in. Based on the name they would have water powers (an undine is a water spirit), which would have been useful for teaming with Strength Eaters.
They *do* actually appear, later on in the game, during the Twins arc.
 

Grimnir098

Member
Jan 27, 2021
162
588
But my point still stands about Ella, who didn't killed him for that, not even according to herself (I played this part again to refresh my memory). She killed him because he was stinking, and was the last person to negatively interact with her, indirectly but still. Not even to show the ability to transform others, she says she intended to show MC that anyway, even before he came. And when MC has a problem with that, to quote Ella "Yeah? Why do you care? It's just a fucking human."
Yeah, because everyone knows Ella doesn't lie, and it's not as if someone might obfuscate their reason for doing something if that reason could be perceived as a vulnerability, especially if they're an abuse victim.

I suggest you take a step back from this and think clearly. If you go looking for reasons to hate someone, you'll find them.
 
Sep 12, 2021
286
547
Yeah, because everyone knows Ella doesn't lie, and it's not as if someone might obfuscate their reason for doing something if that reason could be perceived as a vulnerability, especially if they're an abuse victim.

I suggest you take a step back from this and think clearly. If you go looking for reasons to hate someone, you'll find them.
So her lying or not depends on specific situation and it outcome to fit into your opinion about her? ok. I don't hate the character, it's well written and entertaining, just evil.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hazardgaming

Grimnir098

Member
Jan 27, 2021
162
588
So her lying or not depends on specific situation and it outcome to fit into your opinion about her? ok. I don't hate the character, it's well written and entertaining, just evil.
Yes... whether someone is likely lying is completely dependent on the specific situation. Why are you acting incredulous? Do you not understand how and why people lie, or something?

If it's so obvious Ella wasn't lying here, then you can just explain why.
I don't understand why you continue to digress so you can undermine my character.
Actually, I know do why, it's because you have no argument but you can't accept that you're wrong.
 

TheShelly

Member
Dec 20, 2020
188
2,434
If you remember Ella with Heat and the others digging deep into the earth they uncover two shackled monsters, one of those was the Strength Eater
I have no clue what youre on about. Are you referring to Goliath and Valravn? Who is 'Heat'? Do you mean Cole?
 
4.80 star(s) 419 Votes