obibobi
Well-Known Member
- May 10, 2017
- 1,083
- 2,973
- 488
I think you're missing my point in that you can over analyse it, there come's a point where its just pedantic, looking at it in way that no setting with powers will hold up to without being exceedingly because such a setting would waste 90% of its time on explaining.So my thoughts on this are simple, if the story in question doesn't use physics or biology to explain it's world or setting, then no, you shouldn't need to explain it. Sure, people can come up with reasonable explanations using such, but if the story doesn't necessarily use our physics, than the author can just say, "That's not how my story works, okay?" and you have to accept that.
Superhuman, on the other hand, does use a similar enough concept of our physical universe, and in fact delves into how it's physics and biology are similar and different, enough that it could be considered disingenuous to not consider things from that perspective. After all, while the energy source for our powers is not explicitly stated, it has been explained that you cannot bend or break the laws of physics until you are at least a level 4 or 5, respectively, superhuman. I'm not saying you have to, but in this or other threads where the story is somewhat based in real or imagined science, it's not fair to the game to not consider it.
Many of the characters break the laws of biology and physics at level 1 but as long as it doesn't take you out of the story in the moment, its fine, that if the problem is only evident by over analysing fans like us who over analyse the details, then its not nothing issue.
Just to remind you, this is over a single cell and that I don't think the author should have to waste their time to say, well in this circumstance, the single fucking cell doesn't vanish. I could give you a reason, the MC eats food, that food doesn't vanish from existence, surely some of him has to stay.
My point being is that you can make up a reason, but for a lot of smaller or more accepted super hero tropes, the author shouldn't have to waste their time.