Oh, absolutely. If I were playing a cookie clicker, and my goal in downloading the game was to see the number go up - then definitely. The choice is self intuitive.
But if your goal is to see the most of sexual content the game has to offer then... the choice is pretty self intuitive too. You just don't help her. Just act like a shithead for no reason.
Look, I feel like we are going in circles.
I'm not trying to say that the whole game is garbage - you don't need to feel defensive over it. But I'm trying to say: if you remove this choice completely, would the game become worse? Or better?
Unlike the example you mentioned ( which I haven't played ), this game does not lock H scenes behind a ''bad guy'' playthrough, you can be a goody-two-shoes and only make whatever you feel are the most advantageous choices and you will still get to have the option to fuck everything that resembles a female.
And no, for the second time, that short ass interaction does not count, even the game does not register it as a actual H scene. So really, get over it.
As for my thoughts on the matter, I can see your point, and there should be a balance, however, I personaly don't necessarily see it as a design flaw, some games place some of the porn hidden behind moraly questionable or outright bankrupt choices, so what ? What's the problem ?
Yes the example you mentioned seems unbalanced, to lock the majority of the porn behind certain choice pattern I agree, but overall, I don't find it necessarily a design flaw. Just needs to be balanced beetwen what a game locks and what it gives depending on your choices.
But, again, Superhuman isn't such a game, you can be logical and good and still catch the absolute vast majority of H scenes.
Other than that interaction which I won't even count, I believe the only other porn content hidden behind ''bad choices'' are I believe one or two scenes related to bad endings, and I guess one or two NTR scenes in the very early game that nobody in this community mentions.
Which, again, don't even make up for 5% of the total scenes the game has to offer.