Jan 4, 2019
133
112
184
I'm just saying that if she wants to break up the adoptive father/adopted daughter relationship, it ends up being an old man/young woman relationship. For example, if you have a relationship with your stepmother and she divorces your father, she ends up being a relationship between an adult woman and a young man. That's why I don't consider it to be incest.
 
  • Like
  • Angry
Reactions: sonhot and Muityek

manscout

Well-Known Member
Jun 13, 2018
1,479
2,645
521
I'm just saying that if she wants to break up the adoptive father/adopted daughter relationship, it ends up being an old man/young woman relationship. For example, if you have a relationship with your stepmother and she divorces your father, she ends up being a relationship between an adult woman and a young man. That's why I don't consider it to be incest.
Dude if she changed your dirty diapers, helped you with your homework, taught you right from wrong, or was there for you doing any of the million other things a parent does to raise their kid out of love; I'm sorry but even if your stepmother divorced your dad, a relationship with her would still absolutely be like fucking your own mother.

Now if what you were thinking of is more among the lines of a scenario where your dad marries your step-mother when you are already in your early 20s and they divorce like not even 1 year later, then sure, you can argue there is no incest and you are just dating a woman that also happened to have a relationship with your dad in the past, since she had not formed any real familial bonds with you yet.

Of course that's kinda irrelevant since that's 100% not the case in TLS. Even though the exact age Simon adopted Robin is never made explicit, I think it is really hard to look at them as characters and say Simon wasn't Robin's dad, the marks of his upbringing are impossible to miss.
 

Rasorui

Newbie
Jun 28, 2020
29
63
193
I like this comment because it's true. But I dislike it because it means there's no incest :(
It is 100% incest. Even if you could argue they can choose not to see each other that way, they do: Simon is still "Father" in every way to Robin even after they fuck.
If you want even more incest there is Esthera/Nalili who are mother and daughter
 

Bob Jared

Active Member
Sep 22, 2017
686
559
328
Dude if she changed your dirty diapers, helped you with your homework, taught you right from wrong, or was there for you doing any of the million other things a parent does to raise their kid out of love; I'm sorry but even if your stepmother divorced your dad, a relationship with her would still absolutely be like fucking your own mother.
So would someone having sex with their nursemaid or orphanage caretaker also be incest?
It is 100% incest. Even if you could argue they can choose not to see each other that way, they do: Simon is still "Father" in every way to Robin even after they fuck.
How they see each other is irrelevant. That's like saying that a person fucking another person whom they view as a pet is bestiality.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sonhot

manscout

Well-Known Member
Jun 13, 2018
1,479
2,645
521
So would someone having sex with their nursemaid or orphanage caretaker also be incest?
How did you go from
things a parent does to raise their kid out of love
to a childcare professional just doing a job?

There are plenty of cases of adoptive children deeming their foster parents to be their real family rather than their biological parents with who they have no attachment.

There are also studies on the weakened parental bonding of absent parents that over-rely on hired help to take care of their children, but iirc those are mostly dependant on what stage of the kid's upbringing the help was prevalent and what are the existing cultural expectations of what a "parent" should be and do.

To answer your question, I do think a relationship with what was meant to be just a "caretaker" could be incestual if both parties are instead seeing each other as "family", beyond the professional boundaries (which is something a professional caretaker would most certainly seek to avoid).

Not like that question is of any relevance as Simon did not sign up to be Robin's professional caretaker, he adopted her, he raised her, he calls her daughter and she calls him father. It is really hard to not see how their relationship is incestual unless you can only see the world in terms of nucleic acids.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stringy Bob

Rasorui

Newbie
Jun 28, 2020
29
63
193
How they see each other is irrelevant. That's like saying that a person fucking another person whom they view as a pet is bestiality.
Not like that question is of any relevance as Simon did not sign up to be Robin's professional caretaker, he adopted her, he raised her, he calls her daughter and she calls him father. It is really hard to not see how their relationship is incestual unless you can only see the world in terms of nucleic acids.
I ment this.
It is relevant if, from the beginning, Robin saw Simon like someone taking care of her but not necessarly a father and he felt the same.
Which is clearly not the case
 

michelleFeegaro12

New Member
Oct 21, 2021
14
1
12
I liked the game, but the lack of any choice regarding girls and their forcible imposition is damn annoying. It also does not help the fact that some interesting minor characters cannot be received into the harem in any way.
 

Stringy Bob

Member
Apr 12, 2021
385
465
178
Well this is so well written that I don't mind there being little choice regarding the harem, the justification for inclusion generally makes sense. Also, if I had found this game on Steam instead of here I might have found Robin ending up with Simon a bit off putting, but the tags are clear and again IMO her story is really well written and the game doesn't throw it at you out off left field either, IMO. There are hints sprinkled through her story that their relationship might become more than father & daughter. Really, its one of these things I'd have been happy with either way.
 
4.50 star(s) 240 Votes