RPGM Completed Town of Passion [v1.1] [Siren's Domain]

4.20 star(s) 89 Votes
Discussion Reviews (89)
Flare_Restart

Flare_Restart

New Member
Aug 31, 2019
9
41
cavaemon said:
its so simple to look for things to solve half the probs ppl were having and things ppl complain about are usually just preference and personal tastes... yet they call that "criticism" I call that gripe. if the game looks bad in terms of no art or you push a button and it doesn't do what its supposed to THAT is criticism and its CONTRUCTIVE to what is relevant. I also feel you on niches some don't a genre justice like impregnation for Ex. its not as thought out like the game Violated Heroine that system if done right could be very interesting to have in a game that is not just for MC/FMC but npcs. yet others talk shit because they " don't like how it looks to me" excuse never runs out of style lol. I agree nothing looks good in pixel but at least if they tried real hard or something say something other than " pixel is bad" it could be just a thing they can redo or something if everyone doesn't like it. If ppl don't complain enough then its fine and might not be for you is all im saying. if its game breaking yes I agree I know what you mean when ppl were here before and didn't notice or something until recently. ive been here a bit the scene your talking about with the mom or the ninja is I think getting some kinda stand pic soon but could be wrong I think its a placeholder.
Click to expand...
mmh I disagree, If the game is broken in some form or another and you point it out that is not criticism per se, that is an objective flaw that needs to be solved, no one is gonna argue than the game is better off not working. if the game has several game breaking flaws then you can probably make criticism about the creator and their lack of polish and how it should have been properly tested or there wasn't enough QA time.

when you criticize something your personal preferences are obviously gonna take part in your view of the product, just see how divided people are over Death Stranding for example.

and lastly I would wager that it doesn't matter how hard you try you're not gonna make a small pixel sex animations as good an animated drawn piece, likewise unless Siren were to receive severe backlash and lost a ton of patreons, he really doesn't have a reason to redo the pixel scenes as actual scenes, why 'cause he already paid for pixel art. Why would you pay for pixel art to then replace it with actual art, just save the money and go straight into the drawn scenes. Sure he could do it to make us all happy but just from the way he speaks in his updates it doesn't seem like its in his plans to change pixel scenes into actual scenes. in the end that is just my take, I wish Siren would prove me wrong though.
 
B

bobsen

Newbie
Jul 21, 2017
92
104
azure_emblem said:
mmh I disagree, If the game is broken in some form or another and you point it out that is not criticism per se, that is an objective flaw that needs to be solved, no one is gonna argue than the game is better off not working. if the game has several game breaking flaws then you can probably make criticism about the creator and their lack of polish and how it should have been properly tested or there wasn't enough QA time.

when you criticize something your personal preferences are obviously gonna take part in your view of the product, just see how divided people are over Death Stranding for example.

and lastly I would wager that it doesn't matter how hard you try you're not gonna make a small pixel sex animations as good an animated drawn piece, likewise unless Siren were to receive severe backlash and lost a ton of patreons, he really doesn't have a reason to redo the pixel scenes as actual scenes, why 'cause he already paid for pixel art. Why would you pay for pixel art to then replace it with actual art, just save the money and go straight into the drawn scenes. Sure he could do it to make us all happy but just from the way he speaks in his updates it doesn't seem like its in his plans to change pixel scenes into actual scenes. in the end that is just my take, I wish Siren would prove me wrong though.
Click to expand...
He didn't pay for them.
He uses pixel art instead of drawn scenes because he can't get art done on time/doesn't want to pay for it anymore.

Face it, the pixel art is only included because drawn scenes aren't. They're a band-aid, and that's what people are complaining about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: eamanager
N

Not_A_Horse

Member
Feb 12, 2018
193
625
change_rey said:
you guys do who is complaining that this game is shit , do you even pay for this game? i have seen worse games than this and its being paid. but this guy is posting for free and only asking for donations.. if u want to complain to his patreon and post your complaints not here
Click to expand...
This isn't actually a good defense, presumably, the developer wants us to become Patreons and that isn't going to happen if they choose to make poor decisions. So arguing that only Patreons should criticize the game isn't actually good for the dev(s).

That said, your suggestion to post about it on his Patreon is actually a good idea. If they allow non-patreons to post I might consider doing it.
 
B

bobsen

Newbie
Jul 21, 2017
92
104
Not_A_Horse said:
This isn't actually a good defense, presumably, the developer wants us to become Patreons and that isn't going to happen if they choose to make poor decisions. So arguing that only Patreons should criticize the game isn't actually good for the dev(s).

That said, your suggestion to post about it on his Patreon is actually a good idea. If they allow non-patreons to post I might consider doing it.
Click to expand...
They dont, and if they did there'd be a nonstop wave of criticism - which might be why they dont.
 
T

TestingProtocol

Newbie
Apr 21, 2019
36
14
cavaemon said:
pretty much what I have seen like the one with "pixel art" in the thread above this or a page behind... don't like the game gfto and leave a " not for me" post. if you like the game go ahead give what you know about it and give some points on what you enjoyed.
Click to expand...
The pixel art criticism is a fair one because not only is it cheap and unrewarding but the artist that puts his hard work into making the pixel art isn't even getting paid for it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: deversari and Not_A_Horse
Mistress_Kixen

Mistress_Kixen

Engaged Member
Jun 12, 2017
2,272
1,627
two things.

1) does anyone know where the carrot charm is? been looking for it for a while but I couldn't seen to find it.

2) From what I have been reading of the thread it seems a lot of people have issues with the sprite sex scenes and to be honest while it did leave a bad taste in my mouth at first (due to all the original sex scenes having drawn scenes) not every sex encounter is a major one and for the artist to draw a sex scene for every single sex animation would be time consuming and in some cases a waste of money. So for the major sex scenes for example the drawn art in my honest opinion should be the standard. However for the minor, or monster encounters sprite sex scenes would be for the best.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PugWug, KURO_NEKO_SAM, Not_A_Horse and 1 other person
N

Not_A_Horse

Member
Feb 12, 2018
193
625
Mistress_Kixen said:
2) From what I have been reading of the thread it seems a lot of people have issues with the sprite sex scenes and to be honest while it did leave a bad taste in my mouth at first (due to all the original sex scenes having drawn scenes) not every sex encounter is a major one and for the artist to draw a sex scene for every single sex animation would be time consuming and in some cases a waste of money. So for the major sex scenes for example the drawn art in my honest opinion should be the standard. However for the minor, or monster encounters sprite sex scenes would be for the best.
Click to expand...
Yeah, this is fair.

I think sprite sex scenes for one-off things like monster girls is perfectly justified. The problem IMO is when they're used in a situation when you'd expect an actual sex scene. For example, you can meet Akane in her room and have sex with her, but because it's a sprite scene the eroticism is entirely lost and it just makes one feel disappointed.

So the problem isn't that sprite sex scenes exist, the problem is that they are far too common.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Liquid_Donut and Flare_Restart
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
4.20 star(s) 89 Votes