I kind of agree with you there, but I’m still wondering how he will be able to form a harem, why would women would find a protagonist like this attractive? I’m sure the main girls care for him, but why would they find a really short, average looking guy with anxiety sexually attractive? For me it doesn’t make sense.
In the old game he was the only man in town and had a huge dick, none of those things are true now, so what makes this protagonist different from other men, as to be able no just to have a girlfriend but to have a harem?
I think the anxiety thing will go away thanks to the mentor.
As for the rest... I don't know? I don't really think about it. I mean look at the principal, just a few mins with her and she was ok with showing him her bikini. I don't think you're supposed to take it
too seriously. It's not that different from other harem games, the MC just impresses multiple girls and voila, harem achieved.
He has karate skills, can kick ass apparently. A milf sees him do that, gets wet and the rest is history.
As for his dick, I can't remember if theres a huge difference between the old one and the new one, one thing I don't like though is that her has hair down there. I hope Waifston rethinks and gives us the choice to remove it...