I believe that is mostly old reviews and people that don't know that is a remake, i'm not gonna lie, the first one, was not that bad, there was some stuff that i don't liked but was not bad, after that he made the first remake, and that one was really bad in my opinion, too much drama (i always hate drama) and all that "you need someone to teach you", this version i must say that is really good, and in my opinion is the best of all, yeah, we don't have much content because is a remake of a remake, yeah, he have the renders, but all the story is new and there is still a lot of characters that need some love too, but i believe that for the first time, in all the versions that i have played (and i have played every single one) this one is the one that i can see a really fucking good future, it was not a easy start for waifston, but one thing that i can say that he learned a lot from every version, and i believe that he will make a really fucking good game, and i honestly wish the best for him.