- May 4, 2021
- 103
- 351
I have ran many communities with 10's of thousands of members. I can tell you right now that it wont be a success, you will lose the live people interaction. Alot of people come to this post because of the randomness they might find. They might see requests on the fly they never knew they wanted to see.This has been discussed extensively over the past months, but I'll bite:
1. Keeping a single thread for a forum worth of content is crazy and messy, people keep coming here asking for the same things over and over and over again because they can't find shit.
2.Requests are easier to be solved if they don't get buried under 50 re-requests and bug reports in an hour.
3. Full threads have more links, meaning fewer problems with dead links, especially when there are creators actively antagonizing and shooting down links here.
4. Tags, prefixes, previews, the LU, better search indexing, generally all of the cool tools the forum offers that don't exist in a single thread.
And if you must go there, losing all views of any single thread in the forum would not even show up in the statistics, so yeah, less traffic doesn't matter nearly as much as pushing the VaM section (and by extension the whole forum) to a higher standard.
Once you make people request items in each separate thread the traffic will dwindle to almost nothing because people dont want to click 20 for threads to see what people are asking for. Your average user that requests here and there isn't going to be making threads. The asset section for other games is proof it'll be dead because they are already. If some of those games had a live thread with real time interaction people would stay around more.
You will ruin the VAM community on this site and will end up with 6-7 regulars with hard any interactivity anymore.
Im willing to put money on it.
Ever heard the saying "If it isnt broke dont fix it" ??
This section of the forum is about to become as dead as the rest request/mod sections.