Recommending Western Sharing Games List

[Teye phoon]

I personally prefer NTS myself but im not entirely against true NTR either. For me it depends on how the game handles it if im fine with it. I'm more okay with NTR if I get to make the "NTR" choices for the Girlfriend / Wife as I have an entire different outlook and mindset when I do. As usually I go this might be kind of hot to make her into a cheating slut on this save , as I know what im getting my self into and what to expect. It also helps I don't self insert and I rarely care about a MC in a AVN because I play as a spectator. So because of all this I never really feel any sense of humiliation or Betrayal as long as I can make choices for the Girlfriend / Wife when exploring the NTR path since I know what im getting myself into .

However it's a different story if a few bad choices lead me to the path of NTR unless it's something like my MC is straight up cheating. For example in Pineapple Express I hated the NTR path because it did give me the feeling of betrayal before my MC even had the chance to cheat because the girlfriend just made assumptions at the start before anything even happened. But in A life worth living it didn't feel bad because my MC was a cheating son of a bitch and he deserved it on that path Mind you "NTR" is never my main save.

I agree with a lot of that. I personally like playing FMC and become a cheating slut. and choice is very important.
I quit Pineapple Express because of the reasons you mentioned during the hospital sequence. Even tho the MC had been hurt, she could only think about another guys cock.
Playing as a beta cuck just doesn't do it for me.

 

[Dessolos]

I agree with a lot of that. I personally like playing FMC and become a cheating slut. and choice is very important.
I quit Pineapple Express because of the reasons you mentioned during the hospital sequence. Even tho the MC had been hurt, she could only think about another guys cock.
Playing as a beta cuck just doesn't do it for me.

Honestly the entire hospital part kind of sucked. The hospital part is only tolerable / passable for me if on the sharing path or faithful path , since your choices is what causes those scenes to begin with. But yeah doesn't feel great even then since you can't even really get a good show / view to enjoy the sharing scenes and one of them kind of just happens without any prior knowledge , especially when that relationship is still new so there was no good communication. Honestly the entire sharing path had piss poor communication now I think about it from what I can remember anyhow.

 

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

It confuses me as to why NTR is more popular than NTS. More people get off to feeling humiliated and betrayed than having shared experiences with their significate other?
There are a lot of examples where a "game" starts off looking to be shared experiences and turns into beta cuck simulators because the audience wated it?
No kink shaming, and these are just fantasy. but why? is it just the bata cuck's "moan" louder?

Yeah there's been much discussion over this prior - I agree with whoever said a big part is a sizable portion of ntr fans are more "fem protag/corruption" fans than anything else, and this dictates their tastes - the ORS thread is PACKED with players like this.

I'd say it's also because avns are rooted in hentai culture, and true swinging is a very rare find there, whereas "bully steals the gf" very common/popular.

 

[redoubt27]

I tend to mind-translate NTR and NTS as NTRegret and NTShared. (where Regret means "Fuck!! Why did I let this happen?" And Shared means "Fuck!! Agreeing to do this is Hot!!")
Yeah, I know I'm probably alone in this view...

It confuses me as to why NTR is more popular than NTS. More people get off to feeling humiliated and betrayed than having shared experiences with their significate other?
There are a lot of examples where a "game" starts off looking to be shared experiences and turns into beta cuck simulators because the audience wated it?
No kink shaming, and these are just fantasy. but why? is it just the bata cuck's "moan" louder?

These two thoughts/concepts are linked... The first is part of your answer to the second.

1. NTR is very broad, and there are many "debates" that spring up about what is and isn't NTR... Please, let's not debate it again here...lol Just pointing out that people interpret the NTR tag differently, not debating right and wrong... Your differentiation is pretty good and a fair perspective to have. You're definitely not alone, even if people don't have it clearly defined for themselves...

2. Your characterization of NTShared is valid and relevant to why NTR is "more popular". The cuckold/hotwife fantasy, which may or may not involve "humiliation" or "consensual cheating", is featured in a lot of NTR, but the cuckold/hotwife can be NTS; this is usually when/why that fetish triggers the NTR debates... Doesn't matter what perspective you choose, the point is the "cuckold"/hotwife fetish is found in NTR novels. And with the lack of good "sharing" content, the consensual cuckold/hotwife fantasy is as close as NTR comes to "sharing"... So, NTR stories can draw in a broader audience by making the "cuckolding" consensual, or not...

3. The mistake NTR writers make, is as you suggest, they make the male MC "weak", because that's the "cheating/NTR" path "mained" in the story. The wife is fantasizing about sex with other men because the husband is "inadequate" in some way... Or, she gets "corrupted", or she's really a slut and just needs to let it out... And you're right, those types of stories get out of "control" for the "weak" male MC. "Sharing" is the actual fantasy, because that's not how it usually plays out IRL... Reality is, despite what many may think, what women say, or how it's portrayed; there is a strong correlation between "emotional connection" and sex, especially for women... So, if you give the go ahead for your wife/gf/LI to have sex with other men, the risk of her developing that "emotional connection" with the other guy, displacing "you", is very, very high... And that doesn't even factor in if she enjoys the sex more with her "lover" than the husband/bf...

4. Is the "beta cuck" louder? Yes, partially... They certainly seem to be more willing to throw money away...lol Seriously, there's a JOI simulator game, dev pulling in over 20k monthly on Patreon... like WTF?? I mean, the little customizable succubus is cute and all, but damn... The other factor, that "beta cuck" story is "easier" to write... It provides an easy, quick plot device for the wife/GF/LI's motivation to "cheat" or be "corrupted". It can appeal to more than one audience (the "alpha" trying to "steal" the girl or more likely just fuck her...lol) as well as the "beta cuck" fantasy folks. And with just a little tweak to make it consensual, you have some "sharing" fans reading it... And along the lines of what Johnny said, there is a pretty big audience (that almost seems to dislike women) that really enjoys "corrupting" the woman, especially fem protag stories (Anna, Steps of Debauchery, etc)... And the NTR stories with paths, the reader is generally in control of choices for the FMC, soooo, they get that element of turning her into a total slut who's willing to jump into bed with anyone, including dirty hobos... I swear, it sometimes seems like dudes want to punish/degrade the female MC... It's weird to me...

Yeah, there are people who are into the humiliation part. I don't know if they are "more", or most. But combined with those who like to do the stealing and corrupting, that's a very sizable audience that a dev can appeal to...

Annny way...
The answers, reasons aren't simple.
They're complex and nuanced.

Thankfully, Johnny made this list to help filter out some of the "trash"...

 

[Teye phoon]

Yeah there's been much discussion over this prior - I agree with whoever said a big part is a sizable portion of ntr fans are more "fem protag/corruption" fans than anything else, and this dictates their tastes - the ORS thread is PACKED with players like this.

I love a good FMC game where you corrupt the wife/gf into all sorts of shady scenarios, whether it be cheating/sharing. The male partner in these scenarios is there to make the corruption and downfall that much more potent. But it has to be consensual on her part. A little bit of Sexual harassment to fit the story is ok, but r*pe kills any interest in the game.
As a Male MC I want to be in control of the situation or at the very least OK with what's happening, and slowly grow the partners sexual experience. Not to be side-lined and humiliated.
Wonder if there are any games where the roles are reversed and the FMC is the unwilling cuckquean, and if i would enjoy it.

 

[redoubt27]

Wonder if there are any games where the roles are reversed and the FMC is the unwilling cuckquean, and if i would enjoy it.

I'm not aware of any...
The closest I can think of, they have a scene or two, there's no "cuckquean path/story" reluctant or otherwise...
Babysitters has something of a cuckquean path developing, but the wife is "willing".
TACOS (The Adventurous Couple) has something of an "unwilling" cuckquean scene, but that's it for now.

I'm sure there are some others I haven't played yet that have scenes that might be close to what you're talking about.
But, I have no doubt they are very, very rare and damned difficult to find.

A few "harem" stories get close, but the main or other LIs are usually "on board" with it pretty quickly or the relationship ends. There's little to no "reverse cuckolding" scenes...
Off the top of my head, Ateagina has a few routes where other female LIs watch the MC having sex with another woman, there's some thought dialogue about how the main LI(s) feel about it, but that's it before it's revealed/decided they're "good" with it and it turned them on.

 

[GetOutOfMyLab]

Ateagina

lol I remember when that game had an NTR toggle...

 

[redoubt27]

lol I remember when that game had an NTR toggle...

Been a minute since I played it, think it still does...

 

[GetOutOfMyLab]

Been a minute since I played it, think it still does...

Pretty sure it was removed a very long time ago. Since the game doesn't have any NTR. I think dev lost his nerve. Removed it after whiners.

 

[redoubt27]

Pretty sure it was removed a very long time ago. Since the game doesn't have any NTR. I think dev lost his nerve. Removed it after whiners.

Maybe. I kind of recall a few scenes that were or could be kind of "NTR", and similarly recall being asked if I wanted to see it or not.
I could also be confusing it with a couple other similar stories I've played that did ask if you wanted to see NTR or not...lol

Maybe that's what the dev changed. Removed the NTR once choice toggle and made the scenes selectable to watch or not? idk, again, been a few minutes since I played that one.

 

[GetOutOfMyLab]

Maybe. I kind of recall a few scenes that were or could be kind of "NTR", and similarly recall being asked if I wanted to see it or not.
I could also be confusing it with a couple other similar stories I've played that did ask if you wanted to see NTR or not...lol

yeah, I think the NTR was supposed to happen when the main girl, what's-her-nuts... if you let her go with the demon. I can't remember. Been a long time since I played and never finished it because it just turned into the MC going everywhere and automatically getting pussy.

It did have some good moments, though, when he briefly powered up the first and kicked some major ass. But after that, it became mostly boring vanilla story.

 

[Teye phoon]

I'm sure there are some others I haven't played yet that have scenes that might be close to what you're talking about.
But, I have no doubt they are very, very rare and damned difficult to find

Yea i bet demand for that type of story would not be all that high.

A few "harem" stories get close, but the main or other LIs are usually "on board" with it pretty quickly or the relationship ends. There's little to no "reverse cuckolding" scenes...

ARG to most harem games, all the same really, Male MC screws everything in his path with no real consequences. Rarely makes for a good story, but that's going off topic and not really a topic for this thread.

 

[redoubt27]

Yea i bet demand for that type of story would not be all that high.

ARG to most harem games, all the same really, Male MC screws everything in his path with no real consequences. Rarely makes for a good story, but that's going off topic and not really a topic for this thread.

Not too off topic. Some of the harem games have "swinging", where the MC watching the female LIs have fun with each other, whether he's involved or not... Desert Stalker has a few of those moments...

 

[sagerock820]

lol I remember when that game had an NTR toggle...

'turn based combat'?

 

[GetOutOfMyLab]

'turn based combat'?

It wasn't so bad. I actually enjoyed it. Which isn't usually what I'd say for an AVN.

 

[sagerock820]

It wasn't so bad. I actually enjoyed it. Which isn't usually what I'd say for an AVN.

Yeah, I have no interest in combat in my AVN. lol But I get some people will like it.

 

[GetOutOfMyLab]

Yeah, I have no interest in combat in my AVN. lol But I get some people will like it.

I don't go looking for it... but it worked for that game. And it wasn't overly difficult for that game.

 

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

"Unwilling cuckqueen" that sounds like describing any kind of remotely real-world harem setup

 

[Pr0GamerJohnny]

I don't go looking for it... but it worked for that game. And it wasn't overly difficult for that game.

Yeah, I have no interest in combat in my AVN. lol But I get some people will like it.

Yeah this is how I felt about the first Wicked Rouge - I don't go looking for it, but worked surprisingly well there..... like... was almost fun enough to be a standalone roguelike/or tekken arcade style game.