VN Ren'Py Where the Heart Is [S1 Rev1] [CheekyGimp]

[ename144]

You Shure know how to ruin a potential orgy by having those idiots waste $30k of wine for a guy who only got the $100k and may not get any more. I would demand they pay every cent before ever letting any of them set 1 fot in the beach house again(and maybe pres charges). It is one thing to offer/give some of that wine to be nice, but them taking 3 bottles with out asking (not even texting to ask) is stealing and not cool, not even close. Are you trying to make the players hate those girls?

I kind of agree, actually.

I don't think the MC should throw them out over it or anything, but for the life of me I don't understand why this was put in the game at all. At best it makes the girls look like selfish idiots, at worst it makes them look like flat-out assholes. All for a joke that was both irrelevant and (IMHO) not especially funny. No idea what the thought process was on that one.

 

[acewinz]

You Shure know how to ruin a potential orgy by having those idiots waste $30k of wine for a guy who only got the $100k and may not get any more. I would demand they pay every cent before ever letting any of them set 1 fot in the beach house again(and maybe pres charges). It is one thing to offer/give some of that wine to be nice, but them taking 3 bottles with out asking (not even texting to ask) is stealing and not cool, not even close. Are you trying to make the players hate those girls?

Would have to play it again, but I thought they said they went digging.

And I wouldn't call it being a dick, it's natural consequences of their actions.

I kind of agree, actually.

I don't think the MC should throw them out over it or anything, but for the life of me I don't understand why this was put in the game at all. At best it makes the girls look like selfish idiots, at worst it makes them look like flat-out assholes. All for a joke that was both irrelevant and (IMHO) not especially funny. No idea what the thought process was on that one.

Spoiler: ep19 minor spoils

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[ename144]

Spoiler: ep19 minor spoils

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Long Way For a Gag

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[acewinz]

Spoiler: Long Way For a Gag

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Oh, we will go to great lengths for a joke! WTHI is chock full of humor across a lot of spectrums, but that wasn't just a joke, in fact that was the least part of that particular exchange... There was a lot of nuance there that made it a lot more complex. Something Cheeky does really well that I do my best to emulate when given the chance.

Spoiler: EP19 spoils and there is never a gag too far!

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

On a side note, I've seen how Cheeky is shaping up the Full version of EP19 and it has options more accommodating to people who felt slighted by being tossed out of the beach house.

 

[Avaron1974]

It's one thing to watch the twitter tards getting all upset over video games objectifying women, I now come to an adult piracy forum and see people getting upset over imaginary wine.

 

[Valrin72]

I kind of agree, actually.

I don't think the MC should throw them out over it or anything, but for the life of me I don't understand why this was put in the game at all. At best it makes the girls look like selfish idiots, at worst it makes them look like flat-out assholes. All for a joke that was both irrelevant and (IMHO) not especially funny. No idea what the thought process was on that one.

Well, in reality a 1986 chateau margaux only sells for about $700 canadian per bottle so if he changes the price to match the real world then it would be better because honestly no matter how hot they are no 3 bimbos are worth $30k worth of good wine. That would be pretty much a relationship ender if they were so cavalier about it. Just change it $2100 worth of wine and Lily's tits are worth it.

 

[acewinz]

Well, in reality a 1986 chateau margaux only sells for about $700 canadian per bottle so if he changes the price to match the real world then it would be better because honestly no matter how hot they are no 3 bimbos are worth $30k worth of good wine. That would be pretty much a relationship ender if they were so cavalier about it. Just change it $2100 worth of wine and Lily's tits are worth it.

I'd totally drop 30k for a night with those three. Of course I'd have to take out another mortgage and convince my wife it was for research purposes... or I suppose she could tag along so long as the price doesn't double.

 

[voyeurkind]

The real problem is that the MC didn't buy enough booze.

 

[EJW]

It's one thing to watch the twitter tards getting all upset over video games objectifying women, I now come to an adult piracy forum and see people getting upset over imaginary wine.

Yes it is crazy but to me you have to credit the writing. I mean from what I have seen there is more pages wondering who the third woman in the will is than about the sex scenes.

As far as complaining about whine and the beach house, Ace is right we are spoiled. The game is amazing. The story has given us so many choices to say no or yes to who or what we do that when we don't have a choice we complain like kids. I say this proves the writing is great.

I would've introduced the beach house around now in the timeline. Why? Because of players like me. Katie is hot but I don't care for the attitude. I think of her more of friend to watch football with. Jenna, the voyeur thing creeps me out. I don't like the idea of being spied on (Government does this enough!). Monica, she only loosens up after she drinks which is fine, but I have dated women in RL that did this and it did not go good. So I would of moved out and tried to stay friendly with them. Just not sure about Monica a 100% about not being the third woman. I'm about 95% sure. Just something off about the way she is always so set on you staying no matter what.

Just my 2 cents.

 

[Smarmint]

imo "revamping" is a joker-card many devs pull out when they dont know how to manage/continue their game further, while wanna to provide some "im working/improving illusion" to their fanbase/patreons and not be a complete jackasses.

You think? That explains a lot. I never understood why it happens so often. It is one thing if the original is super grainy, or uses ugly models, but when all the fans praise the game, why go back and redo 6 months of work? I am not a dev, so what do I know, but I can't see myself doing that when I know I have a legion of fans I am trying to please.

I should get off my soapbox, haha, it just seems that in the last year it was revamp fever for many of my favorite games for some reason.

Anyway, thanks to the WTHI devs for not falling into any of these common scenarios. I personally think the development is going great. I am even warming up to Lily after this last update. She is very hot of course, but I was a little suspicious of her motives. But, she seems more genuine this update. And she always provides great comic relief. It is even funnier knowing it is all an act.

 

[MurkyTurtle]

You think? That explains a lot. I never understood why it happens so often. It is one thing if the original is super grainy, or uses ugly models, but when all the fans praise the game, why go back and redo 6 months of work? I am not a dev, so what do I know, but I can't see myself doing that when I know I have a legion of fans I am trying to please.

It's not unusual for creatives to be thoroughly unsatisfied with their work, sometimes to the point of outright disgust. Where we see beautiful renders or writing, they only see the flaws they didn't have the time or expertise to fix when it was being made. They're not redoing work to pad billable hours or rack up empty Patreon months, they're doing it because what they did before is still to them a rough draft. To quote an oft-repeated phrase, "A work of art is never finished, merely abandoned".

I agree that it sucks to see them going over what seems to be perfectly fine work, but I'd rather see a dev be happy over feeling like they're being forced to put their name on sub-par work. That road leads inevitably to burnout.

 

[ename144]

Oh, we will go to great lengths for a joke! WTHI is chock full of humor across a lot of spectrums, but that wasn't just a joke, in fact that was the least part of that particular exchange... There was a lot of nuance there that made it a lot more complex. Something Cheeky does really well that I do my best to emulate when given the chance.

Spoiler: EP19 spoils and there is never a gag too far!

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Oh I like Lily! And her humor works for me normally. I just thought this one flopped.

On a side note, I've seen how Cheeky is shaping up the Full version of EP19 and it has options more accommodating to people who felt slighted by being tossed out of the beach house.

Very glad to hear that.

On that note, I didn't want to critique this episode endlessly without playing it, so I downloaded the Episode 19 beta. Overall I felt it was not your best work, which is a shame when it has such potential. I stand by most of earlier concerns. But here are a few other thoughts now that I've played it.

Spoiler: Minor Issues

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Bella

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: Structural Problems

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Spoiler: End on a high Note

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Alright, I think that covers everything. Sorry for the length.

 

[lordofhirunds]

I believe that at this rate, we will soon write a treatise about whether the bottle of wine is so important or not and we will come to say that Cheeky will have to compensate Mc for the damage caused by the breaking of the bottle.
WTHI is a beautiful game not reality. As long as Monica, Elaine, Bella, Jolina, Kate and Jenna are the topics of the discussions, okay, but the bottle of wine is not.

 

[Snugglepuff]

but the bottle of wine is not.

Hey now, that bottle of wine could've been the one wine to rule them all...
Now it's all gone, and the possibilities it could have opened up are gone, GONE!

 

[alex13_zen]

If Monica finds out at the carnival about you and Katie, is it possible for you to tell Katie of this? I was curious how she'd react but I didn't get the option to tell her (when she comes in your room to watch a movie).

 

[Maviarab]

If Monica finds out at the carnival about you and Katie, is it possible for you to tell Katie of this? I was curious how she'd react but I didn't get the option to tell her (when she comes in your room to watch a movie).

Monica doesn't actually find anything out, other than you went on a date and some vague mumblings from the FT and as you also went on a 'dinner date' with Monica, why would you tell katie anything and why would Monica over-think it?

 

[alex13_zen]

Monica doesn't actually find anything out, other than you went on a date and some vague mumblings from the FT and as you also went on a 'dinner date' with Monica, why would you tell katie anything and why would Monica over-think it?

The way I see it, there's little doubt in Monica's mind about what's going on, since she says it was only a matter of time untill 2 attractive people like you would be together. She also warns against doing anything in her house because she's too young to be a grandma. Thus, it's clear to me that Monica understands there's more than just a dinner date between you and Katie.

 

[ename144]

If Monica finds out at the carnival about you and Katie, is it possible for you to tell Katie of this? I was curious how she'd react but I didn't get the option to tell her (when she comes in your room to watch a movie).

It would be nice if we could mention that Monica knows the truth to Katie (or Jenna), but that does not seem to be an option thus far.

It's probably to ensure the relationships remain secret for now lest things veer offtrack with other girls. Thus the MC will forget to mention it to either girl until the time is right (or, more likely, until something else obviates the need).

 

[Avaron1974]

First it was the Incest Conflict.

Then it was the battle of the Harem.

Now, after months of brutal fighting in the thread of WTHI where incest and harems saw utter defeat ....... a new fight has begun.

The great Wine Wars rage on.

 

[Snugglepuff]

Wine Wars

Cue the Star Wars music!
Backwards and in a different pitch, of course... that bloody mouse....

On a completely unrelated note, it's going to be a fine beginning to next year when the full release for Ep19 comes our way