So, going back to the two sided Monica/Dad story, the code is kind of curious in regard to your reactions. When listening to Elaine, you get a bump if you believe her or keep an open mind. If you don't believe her, there's no penalty. With Monica, you get the same small bump for believing her, but do incur a 2 point love penalty for not believing her. And oddly, she approves of you complimenting Elaine.
Does Elaine not get miffed over not being believed because she's understanding, or is she running a game on you?
Is Monica genuinely hurt by your distrust? Is she consorting with Elaine? Did they work out that R-ratetd Whitesnake video in the garage between them?
I swear Katie is the only woman in this game that's easy to figure out.