As has been said before but: This game is mostly a "clusterfuck with potential".
It has good art in several places (the constant copy pasting of vulva gets tiresome though.) And several parts are pretty solid.
But: It seems to have no clue what it wants to be. It has already shifted theme for Elyon (but only Elyon) several times.
Most of the game is a rape simulator where you play Gary Stu, that can't fail or have setbacks.
But then it suddenly tries to be a dating sim. But then it changes its mind again and is a trainer game. Then it's suddenly a harem game. Then it changes to a collection/grind game. And so on and so forth.
Not to mention, it's a constant split of "I have seen the show/read the comic" and "I haven't seen the show/read the comic." along with "That never happened." and "That happened.". Each character lives in a bubble. That is completely unaffected by what every other character does. Until it doesn't. And they suddenly react to another event. Or they go from knowing about a thing/being IC, to suddenly no longer knowing that thing. Or being OOC so that "the porn can happen".
To sum up the above, I can basically summarize the game with the following example: "Oh no! Alchemy is raping Phobos and Vathek, at the same time! - But... isn't Phobos like, super powerful and could stop that with a wave of his pinky? And, isn't Vathek super strong and could easily overpower her? Not to mention: She's just some human girl without powers? - Well... yes, but: Actually no. Since: Otherwise the porn can't happen."
And that's basically it. "So the porn can happen" is practically this game's tagline.
I honestly have no clue what this game is trying to be. Since as said: It often ignores being a WITCH game in favor of porn. But then it turns around and tries to have a story. Just to throw that out the window for random snuff/rape. As many have stated: The game flip flops between over the top grim/non-con just to flip back and try to have some romance/comedy. It honestly feels a bit like the game suffers to having no real direction along with a "sunk cost fallacy".
I think it could benefit from taking a step back, and trying to figure out what the creator is actually after. Or consulting a writer. Since at this point, this game is basically 8 games in one. At least 3 of which, aren't really compatible with the rest.