I very rarely write reviews, but as I've probably spent more time playing this game than any other game on here, I figured I'd give it a shot. I've followed this VN pretty much from the start, and was a long-time patron. Braindrop is clearly a hard-working dev, and is as interactive with his supporters as any I've seen. Had I left a review of this game 12 months ago, it might have been a 5 star rating, but as each new update has come out, the appeal of the game for me has slowly but steadily dropped.
First, I'll offer what I find to be the game's major PROs:
* The main premise of the story. I found the main story - the MC being a massively hyped athlete attending a small school where he is put on a pedestal - interesting and engaging from the start. In most of the games I've played with a school setting, the MC is an anonymous nobody, if not viewed by his peers as a wimpy loser. Having the MC as an admired and respected character is a nice change of pace from those other games.
* The MC is likeable. Yes, some people may find him to be too much of a God-like character, where everybody immediately loves him and wants to have sex with him, but I prefer it to how so many other games give us an MC that is a creepy pervert who tries to manipulate the women around him into his sexual desires. This MC is neither a pushover nor an asshole, and has genuine concern for the feelings of those around him, including the few characters he's not actively having sex with.
* The renders and animations, for the most part, are very good. There are a massive amount of female characters, and most of them are very attractive.
* The writing is clear and understandable. While I'll address some of my specific issues with Braindrop's writing below, I appreciate that the massive amounts of text and dialog are grammatically correct and in perfect English, with only a handful of typos sprinkled in. It's clear that the dev has consistently taken the time to proofread everything before publishing, something not enough devs do.
* The balance of plot and sex scenes. I think for most games, one of the hardest things to do is find the right balance of sex and story. I think Braindrop has done this better than most, as this game has a ton of very high quality sex scenes, and rather than simply throw them in with no lead-up, for the most part there is plenty of dialog and story in between.
There are a couple things which somehow are both PROs and CONs:
* The number of characters. The dev is incredibly ambitious with the sheer number of characters in this game. As it's the epitome of a harem game, having a lot of different women/sexual partners is generally a big plus. However, and let me preface this with saying that I know plenty of people disagree, for me there are simply too many characters. It's difficult to keep track of who each of the girls are, and what their backstories are. With each update, I find myself having to replay large portions of the game again simply to try to remember who is who. Possibly adding a tab or button in the game that displays a roster of characters and brief synopses of their backstory/relationship with MC would remedy this particular issue.
* The numerous sub-plots. I like that there is significant depth to the story, that there is not merely one single plot line, and that multiple characters are having to deal with particular challenges or conflicts. However, much like the previous bullet point, due to the sheer number of characters, it becomes difficult to track each storyline, as there are often hours of gameplay between a plot point being mentioned. For example, I honestly am having a hard time remembering when the last time anything related to actually playing basketball, which is presumably the main theme, has occurred.
The CONs:
* Many of the story lines are either absurd or stupid, or both. For me, the MC's back-story, aside from testing our ability to suspend belief, is both convoluted and simply not interesting. I don't expect a porn game, especially a harem one, to be particularly realistic. If I did, as someone else cleverly pointed out, the title should be changed to "NCAA Violations: the Game."
However, the fact that a number of people from MC's past, who he had barely any memories of, somehow came back into his life independently and through sheer luck within a couple of days, and immediately are constantly telling each other how much they love one another, is hard to get past.
The one story line that I have the biggest issue with is MC's decision to try to have a baby with Jamie. To be fair, I am not somebody who has a pregnancy/breeding fetish (whether that's because I have a child, and am well aware of all of the non-sexy aspects of pregnancy, I can't say for certain), though I generally have no issues with pregnancy in these kinds of games. That said, the sub-plot where the MC is being paid by Rachael to knock up her clients works well for this game IMO. Similarly, if one of the older characters, like Rachael or Veronica, etc., wanted MC to impregnate them, I think that would work fine for the plot. However, I just can't get over how ridiculous it is that two teenagers with no jobs who are in their first week of college think it's a great idea to try to have a baby right away, and that nobody seems to think there is anything wrong with this plan. Even with all of this, if the pregnancy route was optional, I'd be able to overlook the absurdity of it. I am fine with this VN being linear and having few meaningful options, but I wish this was a storyline that could be avoided.
FWIW, I also think the Talisma plot-line is pretty stupid and annoying, but that may just be me.
* The often mind-numbing repetitiveness. At least with the last few updates, the advancing of the game has been a series of virtually identical conversations and events. The MC is with a group of girls, asks one of the girls if they can talk in private (or vice versa), gets halfway through their conversation, and then gets interrupted by another girl who wants to talk (and who usually has been already told that the MC wants to have a conversation with the previous girl and will talk to her later).
Similarly, in the last update, the MC's insistence on trying to get each of the girls to declare that they are officially his girlfriend seemed both repetitive and childish.
* Trying to distinguish between characters. As I mentioned above, the sheer number of girls can be difficult to keep track of. What makes it exponentially harder is that for some reason, the dev has decided to have all the girls wear identical outfits. I don't know whether Braindrop simply didn't want to have to spend the time rendering different clothing for each girl, or wants there to effectively be a uniform for all the members of the harem, but it makes things slightly confusing.
* The incredibly cringy dialog. Honestly, all the "BruBru" and "Cedey" dialog is so painful to get through it has made me want to delete the game. Similarly, if I go through the rest of my life without having to read "Mwah," it'll be too soon. Additionally, the fact that MC's primary girlfriends have to constantly come up to him, give him a kiss and tell him that they love him and he's the best boyfriend ever, has gotten beyond tedious.
* Certain characters' appearances. While I acknowledge that it has to be difficult to create so many different characters and try to make them look different enough that they are distinguishable, and I think by and large Braindrop has made the girls look good, a few of them look weird to me. I know this may not be a popular opinion, but Jamie in particular, with her cartoonishly large eyes and bizarrely shaped lips, is off-putting.
Ultimately, for me this game is much like a TV show (like GOT, for example) that started off really strong and got you hooked, then stagnated or petered out in quality in later seasons. But, since you've already invested so much time into watching, you find yourself compelled to stick with it until the finale, just to see how things get wrapped up. I still find the game interesting and worth playing, and will likely continue to play as updates come out in the future, but I am not nearly as high on this game as I was in the earlier chapters.