BTLD

Engaged Member
Sep 18, 2017
3,891
7,963
It could be that. But that wouldn't explain why she doesnt like to have sex like she likes to give head. I agree that is a bit easier to say it was rape, it gets the job done, I just feel like it would fill some holes (no pun inteded)
I don't think it would fit that good...Like I said ..with these characters..
If you want for FShauna something just raise up her disgust for her body...make her to be very uncomfortable with her body...
 

Spfjolietjake

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 26, 2019
7,515
14,667
I'm quite curious where is it that i showed disrespect to anyone...
If you're reffering to the crazy part ...didn't named anyone crazy I said lets not get crazy...that is not a insult...so..where is it that i was so rude?intolerant?
I said that I support bouncing ideeas...so?where's the problem?
I listed you on the beautiful posts :unsure:

I quoted the post first because you said it was a crazy idea and i tried to explain why I didn't think it was crazy and you said scene so I tried to explain it was backstory; then I talked about the flippant posts sorry for the confusion. Your post was thoughtful
 

BTLD

Engaged Member
Sep 18, 2017
3,891
7,963
I listed you on the beautiful posts :unsure:

I quoted the post first because you said it was a crazy idea and i tried to explain why I didn't think it was crazy then I talked about the flippant posts sorry for the confusion. Your post was thoughtful
I'm not even gonna try and answer that anymore...whatever you say...
 

Badjourasmix

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 22, 2017
7,272
16,415
What is Shauna's backstory in the female route? Was she just a shy kid and got bullied because of that? From this discussion it seems like her backstory in the trans route is more fleshed out than the female route.
 

DA22

Devoted Member
Jan 10, 2018
8,094
16,695
I don't think it would fit that good...Like I said ..with these characters..
If you want for FShauna something just raise up her disgust for her body...make her to be very uncomfortable with her body...
Something that can be caused by overly negative remarks over a long time by a father or mother that keep telling her year after year that they actually wanted a boy, but are still happy with her.
 

DA22

Devoted Member
Jan 10, 2018
8,094
16,695
What is Shauna's backstory in the female route? Was she just a shy kid and got bullied because of that? From this discussion it seems like her backstory in the trans route is more fleshed out than the female route.
Fleshing out her backstory more as FShauna is part of the reason of the rework Brain has planned for day 1.
 

BTLD

Engaged Member
Sep 18, 2017
3,891
7,963
Something that can be caused by overly negative remarks over a long time or a father or mother that keep telling her year after year that they actually wanted a boy, but are still happy with her.
Exactly..something like that...something that still keeps the character...I'm not even sure how to word this...in theme maybe? with the other characters...
I don't know...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Spfjolietjake

Spfjolietjake

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 26, 2019
7,515
14,667
I think a way of the rape idea working without making people mad is, she almost gets raped and the mc saves her. That would still be an event that would leave her with some trauma and would explain why she is so attached to the mc.
That would be better than it actually happened, but the mere word has started some nasty post wars though. Some great ideas have been voiced. Bd has yet to fail us so I'm looking forward to what he comes up with :)

Edit: I repeated myself:p
 

Badjourasmix

Conversation Conqueror
Sep 22, 2017
7,272
16,415
That would be better than it actually happened, but the mere word has started some nasty post wars though. I'm really anxious to see what bd does. Some great ideas have been voiced. Bd has yet to fail us so I'm looking forward to what he comes up with :)
I kind of get why people are so apprehensive with that idea, even if it's just a game people don't really like knowing that a character that they like went through something like that.
 

DA22

Devoted Member
Jan 10, 2018
8,094
16,695
I kind of get why people are so apprehensive with that idea, even if it's just a game people don't really like knowing that a character that they like went through something like that.
Yeah and that is even discounting people that went through similar situations or had to deal with survivors of it, where it may well awaken painful memories and emotions.
 

armion82

Message Maven
Mar 28, 2017
12,302
16,917
I don't think it would fit that good...Like I said ..with these characters..
If you want for FShauna something just raise up her disgust for her body...make her to be very uncomfortable with her body...
Something like Amber from Lunars' Chosen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BTLD

Uncle Loco

Engaged Member
Game Developer
Apr 28, 2020
3,693
11,647
Oh well, they opened early for MC/S as a favor for Rachel.
You could debate if she was officially on the job already.

But yeah, let us call it bad style at least.
MC also comments about it in your picture. So BD is also aware.
Don't forget she leaves work early that day too, maybe she got in trouble for drinking on the job.
 

ImperialD

Devoted Member
Oct 24, 2019
11,541
11,726
Hey guys, I am a lurker from the shadow realms. Now that I introduced myself let's get down to business.
I was thinking that for the fShauna route it made more sence if she was raped. I know, "How dare you say something to our 2nd queen", but for me it would explain why she prefers giving head then have sex with mc, it would explain why she feel that way for him (it makes sence that if a person its bullyed they would get closer to someone who helps them, im not saying that BD didt get that right), and why Penny wanted to get closer to her because she was on the same boat but didnt have mc.
Maybe I am wrong, I don't know, just wanted to get your opinions on this.
Btw sorry if i made some mistakes, englhis is not my first language and like I said I am a lurker so I am not used to post.
the story is fine the way it is .. no need for any rape scenes
 

Uncle Loco

Engaged Member
Game Developer
Apr 28, 2020
3,693
11,647
Hey guys, I am a lurker from the shadow realms. Now that I introduced myself let's get down to business.
I was thinking that for the fShauna route it made more sence if she was raped. I know, "How dare you say something to our 2nd queen", but for me it would explain why she prefers giving head then have sex with mc, it would explain why she feel that way for him (it makes sence that if a person its bullyed they would get closer to someone who helps them, im not saying that BD didt get that right), and why Penny wanted to get closer to her because she was on the same boat but didnt have mc.
Maybe I am wrong, I don't know, just wanted to get your opinions on this.
Btw sorry if i made some mistakes, englhis is not my first language and like I said I am a lurker so I am not used to post.
Little late on this one since it was posted while I was asleep, but I still wanted to comment on it. I have had this same thought for the background story for female Shauna too. Now I really hate the rape idea, because it is one of the biggest turn offs for me in game No NTR No Rape and No physical violence towards women from men. We already saw the last one in game and it made myself and several others very uncomfortable. I understood the importance of that scene in game and I have come to terms with it, but I remember yelling at my computer when I saw it the first time. I really don't want to be upset and start getting emotional if BD decides that rape is the female Shauna's back story.

Now if it was maybe her mother which we know nothing about was a prostitute and maybe she walked in on her with a client a little less dark I could buy that for not wanting to have sex. Maybe she was touched but someone inappropriately and not a full blow rape that could work too. No matter what if it was something sexual in a bad way like rape or inappropriate touching I hope it is talked about and not a flashback. The bully angle is fine with me the story just needs to be adjusted a little to continue to work, hell BD could make her fat as a younger child for the bullying angle to work even better. Damn kids are so fucking brutal with bullying now days. I mean when I was younger kids got picked on and it went a way over time for most of them, but now days it is crazy what happens to kids when they are bullied.

Either way thanks for jumping in with the theory crafting I always enjoy reading other theory's. Hopefully you stick around and join in more in the future.
 
3.60 star(s) 676 Votes