Butt plug: From what I remember we locked it in the draw were we found Julia's gun. We found the key to the draw I think in the laundry room. Now however we don't have the key. It came down to us choosing the revenge bath or not at the time. If you chose the revenge path you ended up with the driver asshole tied up in the basement. If not everything got locked in the draw.
Only problem is the author in writing his story didn't bother to remember you would need the key later on. From playing through it it seems he didn't plan out this story that much just adds to it as he goes along.
Only problem is the author in writing his story didn't bother to remember you would need the key later on. From playing through it it seems he didn't plan out this story that much just adds to it as he goes along.