Yes It was out of character for him but I let it slide on the back of insanity, he was betrayed three times and guilt trapped - each time there was something he did or didn't that led to the betrayal. At that point it is believable the dude just broke and went insane. His insanity is that he can't trust woman and expects to be betrayed, the only time he can see relief is when that becomes reality. (note: he doesn't tell his new gf to fuck Luca, so he is not exactly willing cuckold, he is just broken).
I believe it is far more important for Harry to be consistent compared to the girls. Luckily this inconsistency is short and only at the very end of a route, but what you are suggesting (reverse ntr) would be very early in route and would take away from other routes in major way. It would put Harry love for Laura in question, after that playing other routes you may see Harry as a cheater that got cheated.
My dislike for Aya doesn't make my points any less invalid. Fundamentally I also dislike people trying to force what HC should write. I was advocating for gangbang scene for Laura but HC said that Luca is not a one to share and I dropped the subject. He also expressed in regards to last bonus scene that it is not consistent with the characters. So i do think HC cares about consistency of characters and whenever he breaks them he tries to provide believable reason for it.
Harry had part in distancing Laura from him by pushing her to reconcile with her mother which was clearly something she didn't want to do. Harry also knows Laura is not accepting Lucas proposal of her own will. This is just not enough to justify him cheating, especially given his got trauma of being cheated, there is no way he would hurt another the way he was hurt. That is not who Harry is.
Who acknowledged this ? Laura I bet? Laura view point is different than Aya's. Laura believes that given more time she will be able to win the game. Meanwhile Aya expects that the further down the rabbit hole Laura goes the less likely is for Harry to forgive her.
You are ignoring how Aya collaborates with Luca. While Laura does horrible things to Harry that is after being blackmailed and brainwashed. Meanwhile Aya sides with Luca
willingly i would say Aya is far more of a traitor than Laura is.
Also how do you know that Aya won't be married to Harry and feeding him cum as well? Maybe there will be a competition going between Laura and Aya who can feed Harry more of Lucas cum ?
Yea, same.