melissa for me tbh
i didn't like rena's personality a lot
+i hate the mc's ex girlfriend
i know you didn't ask that but i wanted to say it cuz she's annoying
and i hate melissa's step douche he's shit
Yeah Melissa is kind of the poor broken girl and Rena ain't got her shit together but I find her hotter (still undecided).
True for M's SF, but at least we get the option to fuck him up...
And about the MC's ex, the MC sort of did worst than her afterwards, if you choose to get laid with all chicks... (so that can't be a real factor), so idk but she's a bitch anyway, even if you forget that she cheated on him.
I still hope that later you can choose to date her as well, probably won't be able to though. (maybe if she wasn't trying to pressure the MC and was trying to play with his feelings instead by taking things smoothly she could be one more relationship option).
I'm starting to get off topic so I'll just stop here