reidanota

Active Member
Nov 1, 2021
568
450
both, you choose what you prefer.
Although not sure what type of each. The swinging with Paul and Marie stands well in a NTR playthrough, but doesn't stand in NTS unless that path is going to gradually drive John into a willing cuckold role. It's a pity because the same scene could have been written differently, with almost no additional/exchanged renders, to continue a true sharing/swinging route if John had shown enthusiasm in both watching Claire and fucking Marie. He showed neither, and in the end he's crushed. If you divide the last update into 4 parts (Paul's "invitation" to John, John and Claire's conversation and decision, the main event and the post-main event conversation), you notice a pervasive tone throughout: Paul manipulates John, he's hesitant but can't bring himself not to immediately bring Paul's invitation to either Claire or Zoey (you don't have a choice other than whom to pick) without giving it some thought. Pretty much being led by Paul. The connection you could feel between Claire and Paul in the earlier parts of the game is gone, they no longer communicate and that's hugely disappointing, I think it was a good part of what made the game stand out until now. Claire insinuates that she has specific expectations regarding Paul that John can't fulfil, and you feel that once the idea is on the table, John no longer has any say in it, there are no further checks if it's ok to proceed, the whole episode seems reckless from a relationship point and driven solely by Claire and Paul. They don't discuss boundaries or anything a "normal" couple would be expected to discuss leading up to their first swinging experience. During the scene, there is zero connection between Claire and John, Paul completely steals the show, not even Marie is excited as she pity-fucks John. John does cum twice - both times rather quickly like a good cuck - and doesn't make Marie cum, while in another room, Paul makes Claire squirt and nearly pass out. Conversation after is awkward, Marie tells John not to overthink it. Claire and John's going home is even more awkward and neither wants to talk about it before sleep. Again, the contrast with the previous updates. It seems like the game took a 180º turn towards hard NTR.

It was more of a swing than anything else, even though I didn't like it very much.
It was, but a failed swing. Swing is supposed to be wanted by all parts involved, approached with some maturity and care, and involve lots of communication - there was none of that. This was Claire and John not just going out of their comfort zone, but recklessly doing so. What was most striking was the contrast with the previous updates, where you had all the ingredients to let Claire and John approach this with much more maturity.

I guess that in the love playthrough she acts as more of a girlfriend, and in the NTR she's more of a selfish lover. I was just making an observation on that post where they said Claire is a girlfriend in title alone.
It's disappointing because it seems like there's a strict Love vs NTR gap forming, with no nuance in the middle, and some old and spent power dynamics tropes. If you like a route with sharing between equals, this isn't going to be it - but it was clearly suggested in the previous update, with long and detailed conversations between Claire and John about opening up to new experiences. This last update seems like a sudden break of continuity (bad writing) or a cynical statement that good intentions are bound to die in the face of reality - a valid argument, but bland and overly explored.
 
Last edited:

wommerrx

Member
Sep 10, 2022
166
155
Although not sure what type of each. The swinging with Paul and Marie stands well in a NTR playthrough, but doesn't stand in NTS unless that path is going to gradually drive John into a willing cuckold role. It's a pity because the same scene could have been written differently, with almost no additional/exchanged renders, if John had shown enthusiasm in both watching Claire and fucking Marie. He showed neither, and in the end he's crushed. If you divide the last update into 4 parts (Paul's "invitation" to John, John and Claire's conversation and decision, the main event and the post-main event conversation), you notice a pervasive tone throughout: Paul manipulates John, he's hesitant but can't bring himself not to immediately bring Paul's invitation to either Claire or Zoey (you don't have a choice other than whom to pick) without giving it some thought. Pretty much being led by Paul. The connection you could feel between Claire and Paul in the earlier parts of the game is gone, they no longer communicate and that's hugely disappointing, I think it was a good part of what made the game stand out until now. Claire insinuates that she has specific expectations regarding Paul that John can't fulfil, and that once the idea is on the table, Paul no longer has any say in it. They don't discuss boundaries or anything a "normal" couple would be expected to discuss leading up to their first swinging experience. During the scene, there is zero connection between Claire and John, Paul completely steals the show, not even Marie is excited as she pity-fucks John. John does cum twice - both times rather quickly like a good cuck - and doesn't make Marie cum, while in another room, Paul makes Claire squirt and nearly pass out. Conversation after is awkward, Marie tells John not to overthink it. Claire and John's going home is even more awkward and neither wants to talk about it before sleep.



It was, but a failed swing. Swing is supposed to be wanted by all parts involved, approached with some maturity and care, and involve lots of communication - there was none of that. This was Claire and John not just going out of their comfort zone, but recklessly doing so. What was most striking was the contrast with the earlier game, where you had all the ingredients to let Claire and John approach this with much more maturity.



It's disappointing because it seems like there's a strict Love vs NTR gap forming, with no nuance in the middle, and some old and spent power dynamics tropes. If you like a route with sharing between equals, this isn't going to be it - but it was clearly suggested in the previous update, with long and detailed conversations between Claire and John about opening up to new experiences. This last update seems like a sudden break of continuity (bad writing) or a cynical statement that good intentions are bound to die in the face of reality - a valid argument, but bland and overly explored.
Yes, I agree with what you said. I found this last update to be very bad, as I wrote before. I just told him that the game has NTs, even though this update doesn't have them and it was the worst, but in the others there is a bit of sharing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: iSkaz and reidanota

Haza34

Newbie
Jun 20, 2022
54
66
Is there a cheating path in this? I see the tag but no actual cheating the last time I played which was a couple of updates ago. Good game btw, thanks dev.
 

juveforever

Newbie
May 1, 2025
29
72
Unfortunately, DEv has now taken the path of making MC an idiot and a cuckold without a choice, this way of acting, also cost them Steam's choice to remove the game, I now foresee only the worst in the future, now Claire is a slut and MC is a cuckold, and it is the complete opposite of the sentence he said, NTR is avoidable, hahaha, a joke
 

Monty10

Active Member
Jan 30, 2024
526
466
This game had great potential for success, yet its progress has been so poor that seven years after its release, we still haven’t seen even half of the characters featured on the cover.
The developer chose to exploit his supporters by releasing a small update every four or five months.
Had he invested properly in the game and its story, he could have doubled its success and earned even more money.
What a shame!
 
Last edited:

Bobber Tail

Well-Known Member
Nov 28, 2017
1,905
954
View attachment 1857635
Because I Love Her [Part 2 NTR Update] Walkthrough & Cheats Mod
Because I Love Her [v1.0] Walkthrough Mod
Features:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Installation:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Download: -

If you like my work, please consider supporting me on my or , check my .
My browser is blocking the DL from MixDrop, can you load it direct to Patreon like usual?
 

taishon

Newbie
Apr 28, 2022
33
29
This was such a sad and very off update that, with how wrong the characters felt, you could've easily start a new game starting from this update itself, and you wouldn't feel anything wrong with it.

It feels like a total disconnection from everything else before this update TO this one. I forgot the terms, and I'm not going try to sound smart by googling it to confirm if I'm using the right terms, but is this like a "character assassination"? I think I heard that term being used in books, sequels, and so on.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Very sad development, and I hope some of the supporters were able to notice this and voice their opinion.
I liked this game for a while, and I even enjoyed playing every update even if I only came for the LOVE ones since there was some nice dialogues and dynamic between the characters, but I really dislike losing the agency, or not understanding the whys.
 

shobhie

Newbie
Sep 1, 2020
71
35
```
I'm sorry, but errors were detected in your script. Please correct the
errors listed below, and try again.


File "game/script.rpy", line 119: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene black with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 175: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene black with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1236: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene r5_6_7_8_9 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1238: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene r5_6_7_8_9_2 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1240: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene r5_6_7_8_9 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1242: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene r5_6_7_8_9_2 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1244: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene r5_6_7_8_9 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1246: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene r5_6_7_8_9_3 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1263: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene r14 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1838: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_11 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1843: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_14 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1845: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_17 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1847: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_15 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1862: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_16 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1864: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_18 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1866: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_19 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1872: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_20 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1879: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_21 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1889: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_22 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1928: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_31 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1938: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_32 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1940: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_33 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1942: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_34 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1944: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_35 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1946: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_36 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1951: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_37 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1978: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_38 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1980: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_39 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1985: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_40 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 1987: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_41 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 2071: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_58 with hpunch:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 2074: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_59 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 2077: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_60 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 2087: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_65 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 2089: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene salk_66 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 2829: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene m12 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4360: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene rm_42 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4383: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene rm_42 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4387: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene rm_42 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4393: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene rm_43 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4423: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene rm_47 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4427: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene rm_48 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4429: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene rm_47 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4431: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene rm_49 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4470: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene rm_50 with hpunch:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4472: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene rm_51 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4475: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene rm_53 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4478: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene rm_53 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4481: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene rm_54 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4483: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene rm_56 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4487: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene rm_58 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4490: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene roseclean1 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 4492: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene roseclean2 with dissolve:
^

File "game/script.rpy", line 5103: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene black with trans3:
^

File "game/script/ep2/ep2update2/ep2up2freeroam/ep2up2day1home_night.rpy", line 1073: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene sgu_35 with flashln:
^

File "game/script/ep2/ep2update2/ep2update2.rpy", line 825: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene crm_104 with flashln:
^

File "game/script/ep2/ep2update2/ep2update2.rpy", line 3114: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene tb167 with flashln:
^

File "game/script/ep2/ep2update2/ep2update2.rpy", line 3189: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene tbx1 with flashln:
^

File "game/script/ep2/ep2update2/ep2update2.rpy", line 3481: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene msc19 with flashln:
^

File "game/script/ep2/ep2update2/ep2update2.rpy", line 3520: scene statement expects a non-empty block.
scene msc19 with flashln:
^

Ren'Py Version: Ren'Py 8.3.3.24111502
Sun May 18 18:29:26 2025
```

I am getting this error message after I unzipped the game and installed the walkthrough/multi-mod. Can someone help me?
Thank you
 
3.30 star(s) 106 Votes