I'll probably play it once the game ends, so I get the complete "world picture" of the game.
It's just that both are cheaters, rather toxic towards each other if they stay together. They are not good together or apart.
Going with one will break the other.
Can't have faith in them in being faithful.
Hell, in her own silly way, Quinn wants you to save yourself for her, she is not aware of it fully, but she is starting to ask for the MC to be faithful to her.
Maya and Josy are not bad poeple, it's just that I can't respect them as a LI. I accept them as friends with flaws.
If MC decided to be gay and wants to fuck Derek or Jacob, starts going down the taboo rabbit whole, I can bet my MC won't be eating dick on the side "to find himself". He'll drop pussy from the menu and just rename the game to Eating a DIK xD