Can someone explain the waifu wars to me? There are so much postings just about "Quinn/Josy/Jill/... is the best" and why "Goblin/Madam/Maya/..." are shit. I don't get what's the fun about it. Couldn't we all agree to the point that all girls in their own path/branch are good? Of course Madame is a case of it's own because of the design of her renders but even she has a right to exist in this game. Yeah, I know this right to exist is really hard to explain.
Sure, I only can speak for myself but when I'm playing the MaJo branch I only care about Maya and Josy. The same applies when I play the Isabella branch, I'm all into Bella and don't care about the rest. With the Jill branch I love a banana. So what? Okay, some paths/branches I like more because of the story behind but this changes from time to time when the story goes on with the next update. There was a time MaJo path was my favourite, then it was Bella, i had my time with Sage, so on. I really don't get why there's so many waifu war going on.
Some wise ancient greek dude said once: "It doesn't matter if they're white, black, brown, purple or smart, dumb, big, tall, tiny. If you can fuck them you should fuck them." I think it was Aristotle.
I personally have a main route(Bella), but I play all routes except MJ, for personal reasons I shared before.
I even play Bella+Jill route(besides the usual Bella and Jill routes), not because I expect a threesome(there won't be one, doesn't fit the characters), but I wanna witness the chaos/heartbreak/reactions if that makes sense.
I am also an enjoyer of the Jill route because it's it's own brand of naive SFW comedy, I enjoy the innocence of it. Aslo, I get the chance to twist the Jill run into 2 runs if I wanna bang Bianca.
Sage, Quinn and SQ runs are dope.
Sarrah/Mel and so on, it's all good fun.
Zoey is shaping up to enter top 3 or even top 2 territory for me.
Like you said, when I play a branch, I RP it, and my general opinion of the other girls doesn't matter since I play with the info the MC has, not me.
BUT, I get that not everyone is too into the game to wanna play all routes, and just picks what he has hots for.
I don't see it as waifu wars overall, just people liking certain characters more and not vibing with Banana Jill and so on.
Like I don't vibe well with the lil midget Josy and Maya.
Only character I'd say is shit is Becca tbh xD